Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELRCPartially AllowedConsolidated Petitions (petition filed 18th October 2020 and 25th October 2022, consolidated)· [2023] KEELRC 747 (KLR)

Benjamin & another v Kihika, Governor Nakuru County Government & 3 others; Kuria & 8 others (Interested Parties) (Petition E013 & E014 of 2022 (Consolidated)) [2023] KEELRC 747 (KLR)

Employment and Labour Relations Court
21 March 2023
6,861 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~27 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Nakuru's Governor was found in contempt for ignoring a court order requiring a fresh nomination process, though the court chose to reiterate its orders rather than jail her.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This ruling of the Employment and Labour Relations Court by Hellen Wasilwa, J, delivered on 21st March 2023, determines the 2nd Petitioner's notice of motion dated 13th December 2022 seeking contempt findings against Hon. Susan Wakarura Kihika, Governor of Nakuru County, for disobeying the Court's judgment of 5th December 2022. That judgment had quashed the Governor's skewed nomination of County Executive Committee members of 13th October 2022 and ordered, by mandamus, initiation of a proper/legal process of finding CEC members. Despite that order, the Governor on 8th December 2022 published a list substantially identical to the quashed list, substituting only one name (Dr. Samuel Mwangi Mwaura for Jacqueline Mong'ina Osoro), and had the nominees vetted and sworn in on 15th December 2022. The Respondents argued the new list was substantially different and complied with the judgment, that no order barred fresh nominations, and that the application failed to identify numerically each alleged act of contempt as required. The Court applied the four-element test for civil contempt from Samuel M N Mweru v National Land Commission: clarity of the order, knowledge, breach and deliberateness. It found the orders clear and unambiguous, the Respondents had knowledge (counsel were present at delivery and they filed a notice of appeal and a stay application at the Court of Appeal), and the Governor deliberately breached the orders by merely re-presenting her former list. The Court found the 1st Respondent's conduct contemptuous and punishable, and reiterated its orders of 5th December 2022 to preserve the integrity of the Court.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the post-judgment nomination of CEC members breached the Court's orders of 5th December 2022

Holding

Yes - the order of mandamus required a proper/legal process of finding CEC members, meaning a fresh advertisement, selection and nomination, which was not done

Reasoning

The judgment of 5th December 2022 quashed the skewed nomination of 13th October 2022 and compelled initiation of a proper/legal process. The Court held this required fresh advertisements, a selection process, then submission for nomination. Instead the Governor merely re-presented her former list with one substitution, which breached the clear and unambiguous orders.

p. 11
02

Whether the contempt threshold (knowledge, breach, deliberateness) was met

Holding

Yes - the Respondents had knowledge (counsel present at delivery; they filed a notice of appeal and a stay application), and deliberately disregarded the judgment

Reasoning

The judgment was delivered in the presence of the Respondents' counsel, establishing knowledge. The 1st Respondent's filing of a stay application at the Court of Appeal (COAPPL/E 097/2022) further evidenced knowledge. Having that knowledge, she proceeded with the substantively unchanged list, which the Court found to be a deliberate breach, making the conduct contemptuous and punishable.

p. 15
03

Whether the Governor has sole authority to nominate CEC members and on what parameters

Holding

The Governor has sole authority to nominate, but the composition must reflect community and cultural diversity, affirmative action, the two-thirds gender rule and other statutory parameters under Section 35 of the County Government Act and Article 179

Reasoning

Section 35 of the County Government Act and Article 179 of the Constitution vest nomination power in the Governor, but nominations must reflect community and cultural diversity, take account of affirmative action, the two-thirds gender rule, minorities and marginalized groups. The prior list was found skewed and not reflective of the county's ethnic diversity.

p. 14

Legal principles established

#
  • The test for civil contempt requires proof that the terms of the order were clear and unambiguous and binding, the defendant had knowledge of the terms, the defendant breached them, and the conduct was deliberate
  • Where a court orders a fresh nomination process, the implication is a fresh advertisement, selection process and then submission of the list for nomination - merely re-adopting a former list with one substitution breaches the order

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Finding that the 1st Respondent's action was contemptuous and punishable
  2. 2.In order to preserve the integrity of the Court, the Court reiterated its orders in the Judgment of 5th December 2022

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Employment and Labour Relations Court ActSections 1A and 3
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 40 Rule 3
  • Civil Procedure ActSections 1A, 1B and 3
  • Constitution of KenyaArticles 159, 179, 1, 2, 3, 10, 23, 27, 28, 73, 75, 232
  • County Government ActSections 30(2)(d), 35, 36
  • Judicature Actcontempt of Court
  • Civil Procedure (Amendment) No. 2 Rules 2012 (England)Part 81

Cases cited (15)

  • John Njue Nyaga v Nicholas Njiru Nyaga & Another
    [2013] eKLR
  • Sheila Cassatt Issenberg & another v Antony Machatha Kinyanjui
    [2021] eKLR
  • Econet Wireless Kenya Ltd v Minister for Information & Communication of Kenya & another
    [2005] KLR 828
  • T. N. Gadavarman Thiru Mulpad v Ashok Khot and Anor
    [2006] 5 SCC
  • Samuel M N Mweru and others v National Land Commission & 2 others
    [2020] eKLR
  • Re: Vinay Chandra Mishra
    (1995) 2 SCC 584
  • A.B & Another v R.B
    Civil Application number 4 of 2016 [2016] eKLR
  • Satma Bhama Gandhi v Director of Public Prosecution & 3 others
    [2018] eKLR
  • Bellevue Development Company Limited v Francis Gikonyo & 3 others
    [2020] eKLR
  • Japheth Ododa Origa v Vice Chancellor University of Nairobi & 2 others
    [2018] eKLR
  • Harrikissoon v Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago
    [1980] AC 265
  • KKB v SCM & 5 others
    (Constitutional Petition 014 of 2020) [2022] KEHC 289 (KLR) (22 April 2022)
  • Justus Kariuki Mate & Another v Martin Nyaga Wambora and another
    [2017] eKLR
  • Peter Kyalo v Alfred Mutua, Governor Machakos County & 6 others
    [2018] eKLR
  • Gatharia K Mutikika v Baharini Farm Limited
    [1985] eKLR
Jurisdiction invoked
Section 1A and 3 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act, Order 40 Rule 3 of the Civil Procedure Rules, Section 1A, 1B and 3 of the Civil Procedure Act and Article 159 of the Constitution of Kenya

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Benjamin & another v Kihika, Governor Nakuru County Government & 3 others; Kuria & 8 others (Interested Parties) (Petition E013 & E014 of 2022 (Consolidated)) [2023] KEELRC 747 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2023). Consolidated Petitions (petition filed 18th October 2020 and 25th October 2022, consolidated). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2023/747/eng@2023-03-21

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.