Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELRCPartially AllowedStatement of Claim dated 15th April 2019, filed 7th May 2019· [2023] KEELRC 732 (KLR)

Kariuki v Aga Khan University Hospital (Cause 293 of 2019) [2023] KEELRC 732 (KLR)

Employment and Labour Relations Court
23 March 2023
1,762 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~7 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Employment Court awarded a KENHA employee eight months' salary because she was punished far more harshly than her senior for the same incident.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Claimant, formerly a Nursing Administrator who rose to Officer-Operations in the Respondent's Outreach Division, was dismissed on 15th November 2018 following a disciplinary hearing over allegations that she used the Respondent's contracted motor vehicle for personal activities at a bar and restaurant during a stopover after a burial in Murang'a on 11th May 2018. She claimed unlawful, unfair and discriminatory termination under Sections 5 and 45 of the Employment Act, seeking a declaration, damages for discrimination, compensation of Kshs. 1,188,816, pension records and refund, plus costs and interest. The Respondent defended the dismissal as based on a valid reason and due process, noted prior reprimand, payment of terminal dues and pension benefits. The court framed three issues: lawfulness and fairness of the termination, discrimination, and entitlement to remedies. Applying the range of reasonable responses test from British Leyland UK Ltd v Swift, the court distinguished the Respondent's authorities on disparate treatment, finding the same transaction underlay the differing disciplinary outcomes for the Claimant and her superior David Macharia, with no justification for the disparity. The termination was therefore substantively unfair and compensation of eight months' salary (Kshs. 792,544) was awarded, taking into account the Claimant's long service moderated by her adverse employment record. The discrimination damages claim failed as unproved, and the pension claim was dismissed as benefits had been paid. Judgment carried interest at court rates from the date of judgment, with costs to the Claimant.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the termination was lawful and fair

Holding

The termination was substantively unfair because the disciplinary action against the Claimant was disparately harsher than that taken against her colleague over the same incident, without justification.

Reasoning

The Claimant and her superior David Macharia were involved in the same stopover incident; Macharia, by seniority, would have been in charge of the vehicle. The court distinguished the persuasive authorities relied on by the Respondent, noting that in those cases the transactions were different or there was a clear distinction justifying differential treatment. Here there was none, so no reasonable employer would have treated the Claimant so disparately, placing the dismissal outside the band of reasonableness.

p. 4
02

Whether the Claimant proved discrimination

Holding

The claim for damages for discrimination failed.

Reasoning

Although the Claimant alleged discriminatory and unfair treatment under Sections 5 and 45 of the Employment Act, the court found that she did not prove a case of discrimination entitling her to separate damages, even though the disparate treatment informed the unfair termination finding and compensation award.

p. 4
03

Whether the Claimant was entitled to pension refunds

Holding

The pension claim was dismissed as the benefits had been paid.

Reasoning

The Respondent showed the Claimant's husband collected a cheque for Kshs. 858,030.77 from Diamond Trust Bank pursuant to her email instructions, and terminal dues of Kshs. 158,357.30 were paid, so the pension claim lacked basis.

p. 5

Legal principles established

#
  • Where the same transaction leads to disparate disciplinary actions against employees and the employer offers no justification for the disparity, the employer's action is unreasonable and the dismissal unfair
  • The reasonableness of a dismissal is assessed on the range of reasonable responses test

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Judgment entered in favour of the Claimant in the sum of Kshs. 792,544 being eight (8) months' salary in compensation for unfair termination of employment
  2. 2.Interest at court rates from the date of judgment until payment in full
  3. 3.Costs of the case awarded to the Claimant

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Employment ActSections 5 and 45

Cases cited (5)

  • British Leyland UK Ltd v Swift
    [1981] IRLR 91
  • Hadjiannou v Coral Casinos Ltd
    [1981] IRLR 352
  • MBNA Ltd v Jones
    [2015] UKEAT/0120/15
  • Levens Solicitors v Dalleyhe
    [2006] UKEAT 0330-06-2311
  • Enterprise Liverpool PLC v Bauress and Ealey
    [2006] IRLR 352
Jurisdiction invoked
Employment and Labour Relations Court jurisdiction under the Employment Act, 2007 (Sections 5 and 45 invoked)

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Kariuki v Aga Khan University Hospital (Cause 293 of 2019) [2023] KEELRC 732 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2023). Statement of Claim dated 15th April 2019, filed 7th May 2019. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2023/732/eng@2023-03-23

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.