Kisii County Government & another v Ontegi (Suing as the legal representative and administrator of the Estate of the Late Evans Moya Moindi) (Appeal 12 of 2020) [2023] KEELRC 558 (KLR)
The bottom line
#Kenya's Employment Court overturned a Kshs 5.3 million award against Kisii County because the claimant couldn't prove negligence for the employee's death.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Jurisdiction of the Chief Magistrate under the Work Injury Benefits Act
The Chief Magistrate had jurisdiction because at the time of filing suit, section 16 of the Work Injury Benefits Act had been declared invalid by the High Court and no stay of that judgment had been issued by the Court of Appeal.
The Respondent sued on August 7, 2017. At that time the High Court had declared section 16 of the Act invalid and the pending Court of Appeal challenge had not been stayed, so the invalidity order governed. The accident occurred in the course of employment, making it an industrial rather than an ordinary road traffic claim. The Court had also previously confirmed jurisdiction in its Ruling of June 25, 2020.
Liability for the accident
The Respondent failed to prove negligence or failure of statutory duty of care by the Appellants to the required standard; the 100% liability finding by the Chief Magistrate was not supported by the evidence.
The Respondent alleged the vehicle was defective but produced no evidence of negligence or defects; the police abstract had no entry on the mechanical state of the vehicle and blamed no one. The second eyewitness conceded he did not know the vehicle's speed. The motor vehicle assessment report was never produced. The Appellants' witness showed the deceased used the vehicle without authorisation and without any emergency. The defence witness's evidence could not simply be dismissed.
Misjoinder of the 2nd Appellant
The 2nd Appellant (then Governor) was not a necessary or material party to the proceedings as no direct nexus or negligence was alleged between him and the accident.
The pleadings did not allege any direct nexus or negligence between the Respondent, the 2nd Appellant and the accident. The Court agreed with the Appellants that the joinder of the 2nd Appellant, sued personally and as Governor, was improper. However, this misjoinder did not drive the outcome, which turned on failure to prove liability.
Quantum (multiplier and pain and suffering)
The quantum challenges failed because the Appellants cited no precedents to demonstrate the multiplier was wrong or the awards exorbitant.
The Chief Magistrate adopted the deceased's monthly salary of Kshs 23,000, a dependency ratio of 2/3, and retirement at 60 for a 32-year-old. The Appellants did not draw the Court's attention to any precedents showing the wrong multiplier was used, nor demonstrate the Kshs 50,000 award for pain and suffering was exorbitant. The ground therefore failed, though quantum was moot given dismissal of the Cause.
Legal principles established
#- On a first appeal the court must re-evaluate the evidence and reach its own conclusions, making due allowance for not having seen or heard the witnesses
- Where a party sued at a time when a High Court order declaring a statutory provision invalid stood and no stay had been issued, that provision was not part of the law at the time of suit, and a court correctly exercised jurisdiction applying the law as it then stood
Court orders
#- 1.The judgment of the Chief Magistrate is set aside and substituted with an order dismissing the Cause
- 2.Each party to bear own costs of the Appeal and before the Chief Magistrates Court
- On appeal from
- Chief Magistrates Court
- Jurisdiction invoked
- First appeal to the Employment and Labour Relations Court in a cause arising under the Work Injury Benefits Act (No. 13 of 2007); jurisdiction affirmed in the Ruling delivered June 25, 2020 in Misc Civil Application No 1 of 2020
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Kisii County Government & another v Ontegi (Suing as the legal representative and administrator of the Estate of the Late Evans Moya Moindi) (Appeal 12 of 2020) [2023] KEELRC 558 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2023). Memorandum of Appeal filed January 15, 2020 (ELRC at Kisumu). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2023/558/eng@2023-03-01
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.