Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELRCDismissedPetition No E067 of 2021· [2022] KEELRC 1186 (KLR)

Ongaro v Judicial Service Commission & another (Petition E067 of 2021) [2022] KEELRC 1186 (KLR)

Employment and Labour Relations Court
14 July 2022
3,519 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~14 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Employment Court dismissed a dismissed Judiciary clerk's petition, ruling his firing was fair and that employment disputes belong under the Employment Act, not the Constitution.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Petitioner, a Clerical Officer in the Judicial Service Commission employed in July 2016, was suspended in October 2019 and summarily dismissed on 10th December 2020 for gross misconduct, namely colluding with his step-brother, an accountant at Maua Law Courts, to defraud the Judiciary of Kshs. 100,000. A 2018 audit revealed two cheques of Kshs. 50,000 each from Maua Law Courts credited to his bank account in 2016. The Petitioner initially denied receiving the money but later admitted receipt, claiming he did not question its source and later refunded part of it. He petitioned the ELRC at Kisumu seeking declarations that the dismissal was unfair, certiorari, prohibition, mandamus, reinstatement, withheld salaries and general damages, citing Articles 10, 20, 23, 41(1) and 47 of the Constitution. The court framed three issues: violation of rights, remedies, and constitutional avoidance. It found the dismissal procedurally fair (show cause letter, responses, three disciplinary hearings and an appeal) and substantively justified, applying the range of reasonable responses test and holding that the refund did not absolve him as a beneficiary of proceeds of crime. No violation of Articles 41 and 47 was established. The court further held that the petition offended the doctrine of constitutional avoidance, as the dispute was an employment matter that should have been brought as a normal cause under the Employment Act. The petition was dismissed in its entirety with each party bearing its own costs.

Key legal issues

#
01

Procedural fairness of the summary dismissal

Holding

The dismissal met the procedural fairness test: the Petitioner was issued a show cause letter, responded to it, attended disciplinary hearings and lodged an appeal.

Reasoning

The court applied section 41 of the Employment Act and section 4(4) of the Fair Administrative Actions Act, citing Hosea Akunga Ombwori on show cause letters and the Nigerian decision in BA Imonikhe v Unity Bank. Answering a query before a decision is taken satisfies natural justice. Aggrievement with the outcome does not make the decision unprocedural.

p. 6
02

Substantive justification for the dismissal

Holding

The reason for dismissal (gross misconduct through collusion in defrauding the Judiciary of Kshs. 100,000) was valid, fair and reasonable.

Reasoning

The Petitioner admitted receiving the money from his step-brother; his refund did not absolve him. Applying the range of reasonable responses test and section 43 of the Employment Act, a reasonable employer could dismiss an employee who benefited from proceeds of crime against the employer. The dismissal was within the band of reasonable responses.

p. 7
03

Alleged violation of Articles 41(1) and 47(1)

Holding

No violation of the rights to fair labour practices and fair administrative action was established.

Reasoning

Having found the dismissal both procedurally and substantively fair, the court held that the Petitioner's rights under Articles 41 and 47 were not violated. The Respondents had acted reasonably and responsibly in dismissing an employee involved in a fraudulent scheme against them.

p. 7
04

Constitutional avoidance

Holding

The petition offended the doctrine of constitutional avoidance because the dispute was essentially an employment matter that should have been brought as a normal cause under the Employment Act.

Reasoning

The court relied on Re Application by Bahadur, SA Naptosa and Gabriel Mutava, holding that where a claim can be founded under substantive law, the proper cause is that law and not the Constitution. The contract of employment should be the entry point; the Constitution should not be a thoroughfare for every common grievance.

p. 7

Legal principles established

#
  • Fairness of dismissal requires both procedural fairness (notice and hearing under section 41 of the Employment Act) and substantive justification (valid and fair reasons under sections 43 and 45).
  • An employee's dissatisfaction with the outcome of a disciplinary hearing does not render the process unfair or unconstitutional where a show cause letter was issued, a response given and a hearing held.
  • An employer may apply the range of reasonable responses test; if the dismissal falls within the band of responses a reasonable employer might adopt, it is fair.
  • An employee who receives and benefits from misappropriated employer funds may be sanctioned notwithstanding a later refund; employment claims should ordinarily be brought under the Employment Act rather than by constitutional petition (constitutional avoidance).

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The petition is dismissed in its entirety
  2. 2.Each party shall bear their own costs of the petition

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Articles 10, 20, 23, 23(3), 41(1), 47, 47(1)
  • Fair Administrative Actions ActSections 3, 4, 4(1), 4(4), 11(1), 12
  • Employment Act, 2007Sections 41, 41(1), 43, 43(3), 44, 44(4)(g), 45, 46, 47, 47(5), 49(1)(c)

Cases cited (13)

  • Judicial Service Commission & Another v Lucy Muthoni Njora
    (2021) eKLR
  • Charles Musungu Odana v Kenya Ports Authority
    [2019] eKLR
  • Benedict Kariuki v DHL Worldwide Express [K] Limited
    [2017] eKLR
  • Silvester Malei Kyengo v Kenya Meat Commission
    (2019) eKLR
  • Hosea Akunga Ombwori v Bidco Oil Refineries Limited
    (2017) eKLR
  • Mary Mutanu Mwendwa v Ayuda
    [2013] eKLR
  • BA Imonikhe v Unity Bank PLC
    S.C 68 of 2001
  • Reuben Ikatwa & 17 Others v Commanding Officer British Army Training Unit Kenya & Another
    [2017] eKLR
  • Cooperative Bank of Kenya Limited v Banking Insurance & Finance Union
    [2017] eKLR
  • Pius Machafu Isindu v Lavington Security Guards Limited
    [2017] eKLR
  • Re Application by Bahadur
    [1986] LRC 297
  • SA Naptosa & Others v Minister of Education Western Cape & others
    [2001] BLLR 338
  • Gabriel Mutava & 2 others v Managing Director Kenya Ports Authority & another
    [2016] eKLR
Jurisdiction invoked
Articles 10, 20, 23, 41(1) and 47 of the Constitution; Employment Act, 2007; Fair Administrative Actions Act

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Later judgments citing this (2)

#

Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Ongaro v Judicial Service Commission & another (Petition E067 of 2021) [2022] KEELRC 1186 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2022). Petition No E067 of 2021. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2022/1186/eng@2022-07-14

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.