Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELRCPartially AllowedConstitutional and Human Rights Division Petition ( Employment and Labour Relations Court)· [2021] KEELRC 456 (KLR)

Zena Achieng Mohamed v County Public Service Board, Kilifi & 6 others [2021] KEELRC 456 (KLR)

Employment and Labour Relations Court
19 November 2021
7,497 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~30 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's employment court nullified a Kilifi County director's appointment because the county board could not show fair, scored, transparent recruitment records.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The petitioner, a serving Kilifi County officer natively born and raised in Malindi, petitioned the ELRC at Mombasa challenging the recruitment of the 3rd respondent as Director of Environment of the County Government of Kilifi. She alleged that she held all prescribed qualifications, had acted as Director, but was denied substantive appointment on account of her Luo middle name, and that the 3rd respondent lacked the requirements in the advertisement of 16.09.2019 as varied in the advertisements of 24.02.2020 and 19.05.2020 (Master's degree made mandatory, experience reduced, SMC and SLDP removed), the process was biased and predetermined, and her rights under Articles 27, 28 and 47 were violated. She sought declarations, a permanent injunction and costs. The respondents urged lack of jurisdiction for failure to exhaust the Public Service Commission appeal, misjoinder, and that the 3rd respondent emerged best candidate at 82.1%. The Court held all respondents were proper parties, distinguishing Wareham, and was bound by Ndolo J's ruling overruling the preliminary objection on exhaustion, being functus officio on the point. On the merits, the Court found the Board had no explanation for varying the predetermined qualifications, never disclosed an objective scoring criteria, and wrongly claimed the recruitment records were confidential; the appointment violated Articles 27(3) and 47(1) and section 65 of the County Governments Act. However, ethnic discrimination under Articles 27(4) and 28 was not established. The Court declared the 3rd respondent's appointment null and void, granted a permanent injunction restraining his assumption of office, declared the petitioner's residency and background, and refused the declaration that she was the most qualified candidate. Costs were awarded to the petitioner against the 1st, 2nd, 4th and 5th respondents, each bearing their own costs inter se, and the file was ordered transferred to Malindi Sub-Registry.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether all respondents, including the county government and board officials, were proper parties

Holding

All respondents were necessary and proper parties; a petition shall not be defeated by misjoinder or non-joinder

Reasoning

The petitioner made specific allegations against all respondents who played specific roles in the recruitment. Rule 5 of the Mutunga Rules permits suing two or more respondents where the petitioner is in doubt, and the presence of the respondents was necessary to enable just, expeditious and proportionate resolution under section 3 of the ELRC Act. Wareham on suing agents of a disclosed principal was distinguished as arising from ordinary civil proceedings, not a constitutional petition.

p. 6
02

Whether the pending appeal before the Public Service Commission deprived the Court of jurisdiction under the exhaustion principle

Holding

No; parties were bound by the earlier ruling of Ndolo J overruling the preliminary objection and the Court was functus officio on that point

Reasoning

The Court had ruled on 15.04.2021 that it could not lock out a party seeking interim relief on exhaustion grounds because the appeal before the Commission had no timelines and no interim relief mechanism, risking entrenchment of irreversible actions. The Court found no further progress on the appeal, vindicating those fears, and held the parties precluded from re-arguing the issue.

p. 7
03

Whether the recruitment and appointment of the 3rd respondent violated Articles 27(3) and 47(1)

Holding

Yes - deviation from prescribed qualifications, absence of an objective scoring matrix and non-disclosure of records rendered the process unequal, unreasonable and procedurally unfair

Reasoning

The Board offered no explanation for varying the qualification requirements (Master's degree, SMC, SLDP, years of experience), for cancelling the internal advertisement in favour of an external one, or for the absence of a non-serving officer among those shortlisted. No objective scoring criteria was disclosed; reliance on a PSC circular waiving SLDP was ineffective as the waiver was not shown to have been domesticated and did not affect county offices under Articles 234(3)(d) and 235.

p. 7
04

Whether the petitioner proved ethnic discrimination under Articles 27(4) and 28

Holding

No - that limb of the claim failed

Reasoning

The paragraph 20 averment did not identify the person who summoned the Chief Officer and herself, so it could not establish ethnic bias. The 1st respondent explained the delayed appointment letter, the refusal to interview her for Chief Officer, and the unpaid acting allowance under section 64(2) of the County Governments Act. No evidence of the 3rd respondent's ethnic background was adduced, and the Board had originally appointed the petitioner notwithstanding her background.

p. 8
05

Authority of Gideon C. Mumba to swear the replying affidavits

Holding

He had implied authority as Deputy Director, Administration

Reasoning

He could attest to the material facts from his own knowledge or disclosed sources, and there was no dispute he held the office of Deputy Director, Administration for the 1st respondent; the Court therefore found implied authority notwithstanding the petitioner's argument that only the Board's Secretary communicates its decisions.

p. 8

Legal principles established

#
  • A public recruiting body must have and disclose a predetermined, objective scoring criteria applied to all candidates; without documented scores on objective criteria a recruitment process cannot be found consistent with constitutional and statutory provisions
  • Once a petition is filed, the appointing body bears a constitutional duty to exhibit all relevant material showing compliance with section 65 of the County Governments Act; claiming the scoring records are confidential is unconstitutional and unreasonable
  • Predetermined qualifications for a public office declared by the user department may not be varied by the appointing board except through due process entailing consultation of the user department and the prescribed statutory and policy mechanisms

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Declaration that the petitioner is a resident of Malindi Sub-County, natively born and raised in Malindi, schooled at Malindi Central Primary School, Kombeni Girls and Pwani University, and is entitled accordingly in her relationships with the respondents
  2. 2.Permanent injunction restraining the 1st, 2nd and 4th respondents from confirming, deploying and allowing the 3rd respondent to assume office as Director of Environment, and restraining the 3rd respondent from assuming that office
  3. 3.Declaration that the 3rd respondent's appointment as Director of Environment failed to meet the requirements in the advertisement dated 16.09.2019 and was based on discrimination, bias, injustice and violation of Articles 27(3) and 47(1), and is null and void
  4. 4.Costs of the petition awarded to the petitioner payable severally or jointly by the 1st, 2nd, 4th and 5th respondents, and for the respondents, each to bear own costs of the proceedings
  5. 5.Deputy Registrar to transfer the Court file to the Court's Sub-Registry at Malindi within 7 days from the date of judgment

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Articles 10(2)(c), 27(3), 27(4), 28, 47(1), 73(2), 176(1), 232(1), 234(2)(i), 234(3)(d), 235
  • County Governments Act, 2012ss. 12, 44, 45, 57, 59, 63, 64(2), 65, 68, 77
  • Employment and Labour Relations Court Act, 2011s. 3
  • Public Service Commission Act, 2017s. 85 (as urged; also s. 85 cited for 2nd/4th/5th respondents' submissions)
  • Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) Practice and Procedure Rules, 2010Rule 5
  • Public Service Commission (County Governments Public Services Appeals Procedures) Regulations, 2016timelines for appeals
  • Public Service Human Resources Policies and Procedures Manual, 2016clause C.14(4)
  • County Public Service Human Resource Manual, 2013clause A.15
  • Public Service Commission Human Resource Policies and Procedures Manualclause K.10

Cases cited (3)

  • Osman Abdullahi Sheikh –Versus- County Government of Garissa
    [2020]eKLR
  • Antony Francis Wareham t/a AF Wareham & 2 Others –Versus- Kenya Post Office Savings Bank
    [2004]eKLR
  • Chama Cha Mawakili (CCM) –Versus- Chairperson Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 2 Others
    [2020]eKLR
Jurisdiction invoked
Articles 27(3), 27(4), 28, 47(1), 234 and 235 of the Constitution; County Governments Act, 2012 (ss. 57, 63, 65, 68, 77); Employment and Labour Relations Court Act, 2011 s.3

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Zena Achieng Mohamed v County Public Service Board, Kilifi & 6 others [2021] KEELRC 456 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2021). Constitutional and Human Rights Division Petition ( Employment and Labour Relations Court). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2021/456/eng@2021-11-19

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.