Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELRCPartially AllowedCause No 4 of 2021· [2021] KEELRC 453 (KLR)

Raphael Munyua Ndung’u v County Government of Lamu & another [2021] KEELRC 453 (KLR)

Employment and Labour Relations Court
19 November 2021
4,166 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~17 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Lamu County was ordered to pay a fired health executive KSh 3.9 million because the Governor dismissed him without a hearing, using reasons already settled in court.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The claimant, Raphael Munyua Ndung'u, was appointed Member of the County Executive Committee (MCEC) for Health Services and Environment of Lamu County on 12.10.2017 on a five-year term. After a first dismissal on 03.04.2018, the ELRC at Mombasa (Ndolo J, ELRC Constitutional Petition 2 of 2018) found the dismissal unlawful and ordered his reinstatement without loss of benefits. The respondents reinstated him by letter dated 24.09.2018 but, on 26.09.2018, the Governor issued a fresh dismissal letter invoking section 31(a) of the County Governments Act on grounds of incompetence, abuse of office and gross misconduct based on health workers' complaints. The claimant sued for declarations that the dismissal was unconstitutional, plus pay for the unexpired four-year term, punitive damages of twelve months' salary, service gratuity, costs and interest. The court found the dismissal unfair, unlawful and unconstitutional: the grounds had already been litigated to finality in the earlier petition, offending res judicata and amounting to double jeopardy, and the Governor afforded no hearing, contrary to Articles 41(2) and 47, as reinforced by the Court of Appeal's decision in County Government of Garissa v Idriss Aden Mukhtar. Declarations issued as prayed. The claim for salaries for the unexpired term failed for want of demonstrated mitigation. Applying section 49 of the Employment Act (held applicable to State Officers), the court awarded twelve months' gross salary (Kshs. 3,358,548.00) plus contractual service gratuity of Kshs. 580,056.00, totalling Kshs. 3,938,604.00 (less PAYE), payable by 01.12.2021, with interest on default, plus costs. The Deputy Registrar was directed to transfer the file to the Malindi Sub-Registry.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the dismissal under section 31(a) of the County Governments Act was fair and lawful

Holding

The dismissal was unfair, unlawful and unconstitutional

Reasoning

The dismissal relied on grounds of incompetence, abuse of office and gross misconduct that had already been canvassed and rejected with finality in the prior Mombasa petition, where the claimant had been reinstated by court order. The Governor afforded no hearing, contrary to Articles 41(2) and 47, natural justice and due process. Re-dismissing two days after reinstatement without fresh administrative process amounted to double jeopardy.

p. 4
02

Whether there are two parallel statutory paths for removal of an MCEC and which applied

Holding

Section 31(a) allows the Governor to dismiss on his own motion; section 40/31(b) requires a County Assembly resolution - the Governor invoked section 31(a)

Reasoning

The court identified two statutory routes: dismissal under section 31(a) where the Governor considers it appropriate or necessary, and dismissal under section 31(b) upon a resolution of the County Assembly under section 40. The dismissal letter expressly invoked section 31(a), but even that route required fair administrative action and a hearing per the Court of Appeal's Garissa decision.

p. 4
03

What compensation is payable for the unfair and unconstitutional dismissal

Holding

Twelve months' gross salary (Kshs. 3,358,548.00) under section 49 of the Employment Act plus contractual service gratuity of Kshs. 580,056.00; claim for the unexpired term's salaries refused

Reasoning

Relying on the Court of Appeal's Garissa decision, the court held the Employment Act applies to State Officers and adopted section 49 factors: 12 months of service, over 4 years of contractual tenure remaining, the respondents' disregard of the earlier court order, and failure to pay promised terminal dues. The claim for salaries for the unexpired term failed for want of mitigation.

p. 4

Legal principles established

#
  • Under section 31(a) of the County Governments Act a Governor must nonetheless afford an MCEC a hearing; dismissal without hearing breaches Article 41(2) and Article 47 and is unfair termination
  • The Employment Act applies to State Officers unless the Constitution, a relevant statute or contract provides better terms
  • Dismissal upon reasons already litigated to finality amounts to double jeopardy and is unfair

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Declaration that the termination of the claimant's employment as MCEC for Health and Sanitation on 26.09.2018 was irregular, unlawful, unfair, wrongful, capricious, unreasonable, untenable in law and contrary to Chapter 6 of the Constitution
  2. 2.Declaration that the respondents' act in relieving the claimant of his duties breached his constitutional rights under Articles 27(1)(2) and (3), 28, 41, 47, 50(1), 200(2)(c) and 236 of the Constitution and was null and void and in breach of contract
  3. 3.Respondents to pay the claimant Kshs. 3,938,604.00 (less PAYE) by 01.12.2021, failing interest at Court rates from the date of judgment until full payment
  4. 4.Respondents to pay the claimant's costs of the petition
  5. 5.Deputy Registrar to transfer the Court file to the Court's Sub-Registry at Malindi within 7 days

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Articles 10(1)(a)(b)(c), 10(2)(a)(b)(c), 22(1), 23(1), 27(1)(2)(3), 28, 41(1)(2), 47(1)(2), 50(1), 165(3)(b), 200(2)(c), 236, 258(1), Chapter 6
  • County Governments Act, 2012sections 31(a), 31(b), 40(1)
  • Employment Act, 2007sections 3, 49(1), 49
  • Public Officer Ethics Act, 2003sections 8, 9, 10
  • Leadership and Integrity Act, 2012sections 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 13(b), 34
  • Gazette Notice No. 6518 Vol. CXIX No. 89 of 07.07.2017gratuity at 31% of basic remuneration

Cases cited (4)

  • John Chumia Nganga –Versus- Attorney General & Another
    [2019] eKLR
  • Raphael Munyua Ndung'u –Versus- County Government of Lamu
    [2018] eKLR (ELRC Constitutional Petition 2 of 2018, Mombasa, Ndolo J)
  • County Government of Garissa & Another –Versus- Idriss Aden Mukhtar & 2 Others
    [2020] eKLR
  • County Government of Nyeri & Another –Versus- Cecilia Wangechi Ndungu
    [2015] eKLR
Jurisdiction invoked
Articles 22(1), 23(1), 165(3)(b) and 258(1) of the Constitution as pleaded; matter before the Employment and Labour Relations Court

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Raphael Munyua Ndung’u v County Government of Lamu & another [2021] KEELRC 453 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2021). Cause No 4 of 2021. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2021/453/eng@2021-11-19

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.