Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELRCDismissedAppeal No 2 of 2020· [2020] KEELRC 1909 (KLR)

Apex Steel Limited v Paul Otieno Hagoi [2020] KEELRC 1909 (KLR)

Employment and Labour Relations Court
12 August 2020
2,236 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~9 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan employer who denied a workplace injury based only on its accident register lost the appeal and must pay the worker's damages plus costs.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This is a first appeal to the Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi against the judgment of the Senior Resident Magistrate at Mavoko in PMCC No. 272 of 2015 delivered on 28th April 2017, in which the employer (Appellant) was found 100% liable for injuries sustained by its employee (Respondent) and general damages of Kshs.87,000 plus special damages of Kshs.3,000 with costs and interest were awarded. The Respondent, employed by the Appellant, claimed he sustained a cut wound to the second digit of his right hand on 25th May 2013 in the course of his duties at the Appellant's premises, attributing the accident to negligence, breach of statutory duty and breach of contract. The Appellant denied the employment-related accident, relying on the absence of the Respondent's name from its accident register, and contended the damages award was excessive. The court, guided by Selle v Associated Motor Boat Company, re-evaluated the evidence. It found the accident register internally inconsistent, a fact conceded by DW1 who also confirmed the employment relationship, and held that the medical records corroborated the injury in the course of employment. On quantum, applying Butt v Khan, the court declined to interfere, finding the award neither inordinately high nor low. The appeal was dismissed in its entirety with costs to the Respondent in both the appeal and the subordinate court. Judgment delivered at Nairobi on 12th August 2020 by Maureen Onyango, J.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the Respondent was injured in the course of employment despite his name not appearing in the accident register

Holding

Yes; the accident register was internally inconsistent and DW1 admitted the inconsistency, so the medical records supported the finding of injury in the course of employment

Reasoning

The Appellant's denial rested solely on the Respondent's absence from the accident register. DW1 confirmed the employment relationship and admitted the register was inconsistent in how injuries were recorded, with four entries bearing inconsistent dates. The Respondent's treatment card and medical summary corroborated his claim. The inconsistencies may have been occasioned by the Appellant to conceal the accident.

p. 4
02

Whether the general damages award of Kshs.87,000 was inordinately high

Holding

No; the award was neither inordinately high nor low and the court would not interfere

Reasoning

Applying the Butt v Khan principle, interference is warranted only where the award represents an entirely erroneous estimate or the judge proceeded on wrong principles or misapprehended the evidence materially. The Appellant's comparators did not establish such error, so the trial court's award of Kshs.87,000 general and Kshs.3,000 special damages stood.

p. 4
03

The duty of a first appellate court

Holding

The court must evaluate the evidence afresh and reach its own conclusions while allowing for not having seen or heard the witnesses

Reasoning

Following Selle v Associated Motor Boat Company, the court reconsidered the evidence and submissions and reached its own findings, which coincided with those of the trial magistrate on both liability and quantum.

p. 3

Legal principles established

#
  • On a first appeal the court must reconsider and evaluate the evidence and draw its own conclusions, while making due allowance for not having seen or heard the witnesses.
  • An appellate court will not disturb an award of damages unless it is inordinately high or low as to represent an entirely erroneous estimate, or the judge proceeded on wrong principles or misapprehended the evidence.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The instant appeal is dismissed in its entirety
  2. 2.Costs to the Respondent both in the appeal and in the subordinate court

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of KenyaArticle 159(2)(d)
  • Constitution of KenyaArticle 48
  • Civil Procedure Act (Chapter 21, Laws of Kenya)Section 1B
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 21 Rule 1

Cases cited (5)

  • Sielle v Associated Motor Boat Company & Another
    (1968) 128; also cited as Selle v Assorted Motor Boat Company 1968 EA 123-126
  • Eldoret Mills Limited v Emily Wangui
    (2011) eKLR
  • Kreative Roses Limited v Olpher Kerubo Osumu
    (2014) eKLR
  • Ngome Marumu Ngome v Mombasa Maize Millers Limited
    (2014) eKLR
  • Butt v Khan
    (1977) 1 KAR
On appeal from
Senior Resident Magistrate's Court at Mavoko
PMCC No. 272 of 2015
Jurisdiction invoked
First appeal from the Senior Resident Magistrate's Court at Mavoko

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Apex Steel Limited v Paul Otieno Hagoi [2020] KEELRC 1909 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2020). Appeal No 2 of 2020. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2020/1909/eng@2020-08-12

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.