Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELRCPartially AllowedNot stated in judgment text supplied· [2020] KEELRC 1439 (KLR)

Ephantus Wambua Macharia v Presbyterian Church of East Africa & another [2020] KEELRC 1439 (KLR)

Employment and Labour Relations Court
6 March 2020
1,618 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~6 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan hospital unfairly sacked an optician for referring a patient elsewhere, because patients have the right to buy medicines anywhere.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Claimant, Ephantus Wambua Macharia, was employed by the Presbyterian Church of East Africa, Kikuyu Hospital as an Ophthalmic Clinical Officer, first under a contract dated 29 February 2012 and later a renewed five-year contract effective March 2015. In May 2015 he was accused of referring a patient to purchase eyeglasses elsewhere, depriving the hospital of revenue. After meetings, a written incident report and a disciplinary hearing, his contract was terminated by letter dated 29 June 2015. He sued for unfair termination and breach of contract. The Cause, initially heard ex parte and decided in June 2019, was by consent heard afresh on 20 January 2020. On procedure, the Court found the Claimant was informed of the allegations and given written and oral opportunities to be heard, satisfying sections 35 and 41 of the Employment Act. On substance, although the Court believed the patient's testimony that the Claimant referred her elsewhere, the Respondents produced no policy against referral and did not show the Claimant knew of one. Taking judicial notice of the Kenya National Patients' Rights Charter, the Court held that a prescription belongs to the patient, that a patient may not be coerced into purchasing medicines from a particular facility, and that any contrary employer policy is invalid to that extent. The termination was therefore neither valid nor fair. The Court awarded pay in lieu of notice of Kshs 84,994/- and compensation of six months' gross salary (Kshs 509,964/-), totalling Kshs 594,958/-. The claim of Kshs 4,844,658/- for lost income over the unexpired 57 months of the contract was refused, the Court endorsing Bank of Uganda v Tinkamanyire that compensation for the remainder of a contract is unattainable in law, and noting the Claimant failed to mitigate. Costs were denied to the Claimant for failure to serve his submissions.

Key legal issues

#
01

Procedural fairness of the termination

Holding

Termination procedure complied with sections 35 and 41 of the Employment Act

Reasoning

The Claimant was informed of the allegations, asked for a written incident report, invited to a disciplinary hearing with the right to be accompanied by a colleague, and attended the hearing before the termination letter of 29 June 2015. The Court found both written and oral opportunities to defend himself were afforded, satisfying the statutory requirements and the contractual notice clause.

p. 2
02

Substantive fairness - validity of the reason for termination

Holding

The reason (referring a patient to buy eyeglasses elsewhere) was neither valid nor fair

Reasoning

Although the Court believed the patient's testimony that the Claimant referred her elsewhere, the Respondents produced no policy against referral nor proved the Claimant knew of one. The Court took judicial notice of the Kenya National Patients' Rights Charter, which guarantees a patient's right to choose a healthcare provider, and held that a prescription belongs to the patient. The referral therefore breached no fundamental contractual obligation.

p. 3
03

Entitlement to pay in lieu of notice and compensation

Holding

One month's salary in lieu of notice and six months' gross salary as compensation for about six years of service

Reasoning

Having found the termination unfair, the Court applied the contractual one-month notice provision (salary Kshs 84,994/-) and, considering the Claimant's cumulative service of about six years, awarded compensation equivalent to six months' gross salary (Kshs 509,964/-), a total of Kshs 594,958/-.

p. 3
04

Claim for lost income for the unexpired contract term

Holding

Claim rejected; no legal basis and no mitigation

Reasoning

The contract contained no clause providing for lost income on premature termination. Endorsing Bank of Uganda v Tinkamanyire, the Court held that compensation for the remainder of a contract is unattainable in law. The Claimant, a professional, also gave no evidence of steps taken to mitigate his income loss after termination.

p. 3

Legal principles established

#
  • A prescription is the property of the patient, who is free to purchase prescribed items from any facility; forcing a patient to procure medicines from a particular facility violates patients' rights
  • An internal employer policy contrary to the Kenya National Patients' Rights Charter is invalid to that extent
  • An employee whose contract is terminated prematurely is not entitled to compensation for the unexpired remainder of the contract

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Declaration that the termination of the Claimant's employment was unfair (implicit in the finding)
  2. 2.Award of pay in lieu of notice of Kshs 84,994/-
  3. 3.Award of compensation equivalent to 6 months gross salary of Kshs 509,964/-
  4. 4.Total award of Kshs 594,958/-
  5. 5.Claimant denied costs for failing to serve submissions

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Employment Act, 2007Section 35(1)(c)
  • Employment Act, 2007Section 41
  • Employment Act, 2007Section 43
  • Employment Act, 2007Section 45
  • Kenya National Patients' Rights CharterPatients' rights to choose a healthcare provider and to informed consent

Cases cited (1)

  • Bank of Uganda v Tinkamanyire
    (2009) 2 EA 66
Jurisdiction invoked
Employment and Labour Relations Court jurisdiction under the Employment Act, 2007 (first-instance employment cause)

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Ephantus Wambua Macharia v Presbyterian Church of East Africa & another [2020] KEELRC 1439 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2020). Not stated in judgment text supplied. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2020/1439/eng@2020-03-06

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.