Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELRCDismissedPetition No. 12 of 2018 (as implied by Amended Petition dated 5th March 2019)· [2020] KEELRC 941 (KLR)

Peter Mbae v National Environment Management Authority & 4 others; Law Society of Kenya & 2 others (Interested Parties) [2020] KEELRC 941 (KLR)

Environment and Land Court of Kenya
4 June 2020
4,693 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~19 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

The court dismissed a constitutional petition over the Solai dam tragedy because existing environmental laws and NEMA processes had to be used first.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The petitioner, the Member of County Assembly for Kabazi Ward, filed an amended petition in public interest under Articles 20, 21, 22(1), 258, 23(1), 42, 60 and 70 of the Constitution following the breach of Milmet Dam at Patel Farm, Solai, on 9th May 2018, in which over 40 lives were lost and property destroyed. He sought an order that an Environmental Impact Assessment and Social Audit be conducted on the Patel Farm dams within 60 days, an order that the 4th and 5th respondents (the dam owners) restore the ecosystem, and costs. NEMA responded that EIAs are pre-project requirements and that it had already conducted a control audit and issued an Environmental Restoration Order dated 19th July 2018. The Water Resources Authority raised a preliminary objection under Sections 137(a) and (c) of the Water Act, 2016, which the court dismissed: the objection was unsupported by submissions and turned on whether the authority acted in good faith, a matter of fact requiring evidence. On the merits, the court noted that the dams existed since the colonial era so Section 58 EMCA did not apply, that environmental impact and social audit reports for 2014 to 2018 existed, and that statutory processes under EMCA were already underway. Citing the Supreme Court's guidance in Benard Murage, the court held the constitutional claim was prematurely raised and dismissed the petition, with each party bearing own costs. Judgment delivered remotely on 4th June 2020 by D. O. Ohungo, J.

Key legal issues

#
01

Validity of the 2nd respondent's preliminary objection under Sections 137(a) and (c) of the Water Act, 2016

Holding

The objection fails both for want of prosecution (no submissions advanced) and because whether the 2nd respondent acted in good faith is a matter of fact requiring evidence, so it is not a valid preliminary objection

Reasoning

Applying Mukisa Biscuit, a valid preliminary objection must be a pure point of law on assumed facts. Section 137 protects from liability matters done in good faith; whether the 2nd respondent acted in good faith is a factual question requiring evidence, which the petitioner did not aver. The objection also had no supporting submissions, so it could not succeed on autopilot.

p. 4
02

Whether the 4th and 5th respondents violated the right to a clean and healthy environment under Articles 42, 69 and 70 of the Constitution

Holding

On the material before the court the issue was prematurely raised; existing statutory processes under EMCA (audit reports, Environmental Restoration Order, Public Complaints Committee investigation) should first take their course

Reasoning

The dams predate Section 58 EMCA (colonial era) and environmental impact and social audit reports for 2014-2018 exist. Their adequacy and follow-up fall within NEMA's mandate under Sections 68 and 69 EMCA. Tort or statutory liability questions are distinct from constitutional questions; per the Supreme Court, statutory remedies should be pursued first.

Legal principles established

#
  • A preliminary objection must be a pure point of law, argued on the assumption that all facts pleaded by the other side are correct, and cannot be raised if any fact has to be ascertained
  • A party raising a preliminary objection must prosecute it and advance arguments to justify it
  • An objection that requires ascertainment of facts or evidence is not a valid preliminary objection
  • Not every violation of law must be brought as a constitutional petition; statutory remedies should be pursued first
  • Breach of a dam embankment does not per se prove that a party's actions threaten the constitutional right to a clean and healthy environment

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The 2nd respondent's preliminary objection is dismissed
  2. 2.The petition is dismissed
  3. 3.Each party shall bear own costs

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Articles 20, 21, 22(1), 42, 60, 69(1), 69(2), 70, 156, 162(2)(b), 23(1), 258
  • Environmental Management and Co-ordination Act, 1999 (EMCA)Sections 2, 3, 7, 31, 58, 64, 68, 69, 130
  • Water Act, 2016Sections 11, 12(b), (d) and (h), 30, 137(a) and (c)
  • Water Act No. 8 of 2002Section 103(a) and (c)
  • State Corporations ActSection 3; Legal Notice No. 270 of 24th June 1988
  • Law Society of Kenya Act, 2014Section 3
  • Law Society of Kenya Ordinance, 1949Section 3
  • Environment and Land Court Act, 2011Sections 4 and 13

Cases cited (5)

  • Martin Osano Rabera & another v Municipal Council of Nakuru & 2 others
    [2018] eKLR
  • Moffat Kamau & 9 Others vs Aelous Kenya Limited & 9 Others
    [2016] eKLR
  • Benson Ambuti Adega & 2 others v Kibos Sugar and Allied Industries Limited & 4 others; Kenya Union of Sugar Plantation and Allied Workers (Interested Party)
    [2019] eKLR
  • Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd vs West End Distributors Ltd
    (1969) EA 696
  • Benard Murage - v - Fine Serve Africa Limited & 3 others
    [2015] eKLR
Jurisdiction invoked
Article 162(2)(b) of the Constitution and Sections 4 and 13 of the Environment and Land Court Act, 2011

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Peter Mbae v National Environment Management Authority & 4 others; Law Society of Kenya & 2 others (Interested Parties) [2020] KEELRC 941 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2020). Petition No. 12 of 2018 (as implied by Amended Petition dated 5th March 2019). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2020/941/eng@2020-06-04

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.