Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELRCPartially Allowednot stated in the extract· [2020] KEELRC 128 (KLR)

Agoko Otieno Apodo v Aegis [Kenya] Limited t/a Leopard Beach Resort & Spa [2020] KEELRC 128 (KLR)

Employment and Labour Relations Court
15 December 2020
4,234 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~17 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan court ruled a security guard was unfairly dismissed after 11 years of 'seasonal' contracts, awarding him over Kshs. 426,000 and full employee protections.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Claimant, employed as a Security Guard by the Respondent hotel from 2004 on successive temporary/seasonal contracts and on casual terms between contracts, served 11 years. On the advice of his trade union KUDHEIHA he gave four months' notice of retirement on 19th March 2015, which the Respondent accepted, fixing retirement for 31st July 2015. On 9th June 2015 the Respondent's Director ordered him to collect garbage, a duty outside his job description; the Claimant refused, an altercation followed in which the Director used vulgar language, and the Claimant was locked out and his contract summarily terminated without a hearing, charges or a termination letter. The Court held that after 11 years the Claimant was a regular employee under clause 19 of the CBA and Section 37 of the Employment Act, which strongly favours decasualization. Refusing an out-of-contract command was not insubordination under Section 44(4). Termination was unfair for lack of valid reasons and fair procedure under Sections 41, 43 and 45 of the Employment Act. The Court awarded compensation of 5½ months' salary (Kshs. 97,746), adopted the Respondent's tabulated terminal dues of Kshs. 310,651, and granted service charge of Kshs. 18,300 for July, August and September 2014 and May 2015, holding that exclusion from service charge was unjustified discrimination since clause 21 covers all unionisable employees. Total award: Kshs. 426,697, subject to P.A.Y.E. A Certificate of Service was ordered, with costs to the Claimant and a 30-day stay of execution. Other prayers, duplicating the tabulated offer or unestablished, were refused. Judgment delivered electronically at Nairobi on 15th December 2020 by James Rika, Judge.

Key legal issues

#
01

Status of employment after 11 years of repeated seasonal contracts

Holding

Claimant had become a regular employee entitled to full Employment Act protections

Reasoning

Clause 19 of the CBA limits temporary/seasonal employment to a maximum of one year and forbids re-employment on casual terms to avoid permanent employment. Section 37 of the Employment Act strongly favours decasualization. Guarding was long-term and central to the Respondent's business, so the Claimant could not remain casual after 11 years.

p. 4
02

Unfairness of summary dismissal during notice of retirement

Holding

Termination was unfair; the Respondent initiated termination the Claimant had himself initiated, without valid reason or procedure

Reasoning

The Claimant had validly served notice of retirement which the Respondent accepted and extended to 31st July 2015. Instead of letting the notice run, the Respondent summarily dismissed him over refusal to collect garbage — a duty outside his job description — without hearing, charges or a termination letter. Sections 41, 43 and 45 required valid reasons and fair procedure.

p. 4
03

Refusal to collect garbage as insubordination

Holding

Not insubordination; the command was outside the contract

Reasoning

The CBA's job categories clearly delineate Cleaner and Security Guard roles. The Director's directive to collect garbage was not a lawful command under the employment contract, so refusal could not constitute insubordination under Section 44(4) of the Employment Act. The Director's vulgar language also breached industrial relations decorum.

p. 5
04

Service charge entitlement

Holding

Claimant entitled to service charge for July, August, September 2014 and May 2015 totalling Kshs. 18,300

Reasoning

Clause 21 of the CBA provides that service charge shall be distributed equally to all unionisable employees. Neither the Works Committee nor the Respondent could exclude the Claimant on the ground that he was out of contract, since the Court deemed him a regular employee at all times. Exclusion was unjustified discrimination.

p. 6
05

Quantum of compensation and terminal dues

Holding

Compensation of 5 ½ months' salary (Kshs. 97,746) and acceptance of the Respondent's tabulated terminal dues of Kshs. 310,651

Reasoning

The Claimant was a diligent 11-year employee, decorated for excellence, but was already on retirement notice and would have left by 31st July 2015. The hurtful exit warranted compensation at 5 ½ months. The Human Resource Manager's tabulation was not way off the mark and the Court adopted it as terminal dues.

p. 5

Legal principles established

#
  • After 11 years, the claimant was a regular employee; re-employment on casual terms for an integral, long-term role is contrary to Section 37 of the Employment Act and clause 19 of the CBA (decasualization)
  • An employee does not commit insubordination by refusing a lawful-outside-the-contract command
  • Termination without valid reasons or procedure (no hearing, no charges, no termination letter) is unfair under Sections 41, 43 and 45 of the Employment Act
  • The Works Committee cannot exclude a unionisable employee from service charge; doing so is unjustified discrimination under the CBA

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Declared that termination was unfair
  2. 2.Respondent to pay compensation for unfair termination equivalent of 5 ½ months' salary at Kshs. 97,746
  3. 3.Respondent to pay terminal benefits offered by the Respondent at Kshs. 310,651
  4. 4.Respondent to pay service charge at Kshs. 18,300 (total award Kshs. 426,697)
  5. 5.Certificate of Service to issue
  6. 6.Costs to the Claimant
  7. 7.Execution of the Judgment stayed for 30 days from the date of delivery
  8. 8.Total sum subject to P.A.Y.E.

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Employment ActSection 37
  • Employment ActSection 41
  • Employment ActSection 43
  • Employment ActSection 44 [4]
  • Employment ActSections 41, 43 and 45
  • Collective Bargaining Agreement (Respondent and KUDHEIHA)Clause 19
  • Collective Bargaining Agreement (Respondent and KUDHEIHA)Clause 21
  • Collective Bargaining Agreement (Respondent and KUDHEIHA)Clause 27 [a]
  • Collective Bargaining Agreement (Respondent and KUDHEIHA)Clause 9 [d]
  • Industrial Relations Charternot specified
Jurisdiction invoked
Employment and Labour Relations Court jurisdiction under the Employment Act 2007 and the CBA between the Respondent and KUDHEIHA

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Agoko Otieno Apodo v Aegis [Kenya] Limited t/a Leopard Beach Resort & Spa [2020] KEELRC 128 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2020). not stated in the extract. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2020/128/eng@2020-12-15

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.