Reuben Ngila Kitonyi v Central Bank of Kenya [2019] KEELRC 871 (KLR)
The bottom line
#Kenya's Employment Court reinstated a dismissed worker's case, ruling his lawyer's mix-up was an honest mistake, not neglect.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Whether mistake of counsel constitutes 'any other sufficient reason' for review under Rule 33(1)(d) of the ELRC Procedure Rules
Yes - where the failure to comply with court directions resulted from inaccurate information given by holding counsel and not from willful neglect by the litigant, it amounts to sufficient reason warranting review
The court reviewed SMS correspondence showing the holding counsel, Mr Malinzi, conveyed inaccurate court directions to petitioner's counsel, who then filed submissions two weeks late. Applying Shah v Mbogo, the court held the discretion to review exists to remedy injustice from inadvertent or excusable mistake. The default was neither willful nor deliberate obstruction, and the respondent's prejudice could be cured by throw away costs, so review was warranted.
Whether 'any other sufficient reason' must be ejusdem generis with the other grounds of review
No - the Shah v Mbogo guiding principle on judicial discretion should be applied rather than restricting the scope of the ground
The respondent argued, relying on Stephen Gathua Kimani v Nancy Wanjira Waruingi, that 'any other sufficient reason' must be analogous to mistake or error apparent on the face of the record or discovery of new evidence. The court rejected that restrictive reading, holding that the proper approach is to assess whether the decision flowed from willful neglect or excusable mistake and whether injustice or prejudice would result.
Whether prejudice to the respondent outweighs the grant of review
No - the respondent can be sufficiently compensated by throw away costs
The court considered whether granting review would occasion prejudice on the respondent which cannot be remedied by costs. It concluded that monetary compensation by way of throw away costs was adequate, consistent with the principle that a court's primary duty is to do justice and that procedural lapses should not lock a litigant out of a hearing on the merits absent demonstrable irreparable prejudice.
Legal principles established
#- 'Any other sufficient reason' under Rule 33(1)(d) is not confined to reasons ejusdem generis with mistake on the face of the record or discovery of new evidence; the guiding principle is the Shah v Mbogo discretion test - whether the default resulted from willful neglect or inadvertent/excusable mistake and whether injustice would follow
- A mistake of counsel that was not willful neglect on the part of an innocent litigant can constitute sufficient reason for review, provided any prejudice to the other party is remediable by costs
Court orders
#- 1.The application for review is allowed as prayed; the orders of 9th April 2019 are reviewed and set aside and the petition is reinstated for the preliminary objection to be heard on merit
- 2.The applicant is condemned to pay throw away costs of Kshs.10,000/= to the respondent within 14 days of the date hereof
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Rule 33(1)(d) and (3) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Procedure Rules, Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution of Kenya and the inherent powers of the Court
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Reuben Ngila Kitonyi v Central Bank of Kenya [2019] KEELRC 871 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2019). Petition dated 22nd August 2018 (ELRC, Nairobi). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2019/871/eng@2019-09-20
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.