Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELRCPartially AllowedPetition (amended, filed 17.05.2019)· [2019] KEELRC 523 (KLR)

Ruto v Judicial Service Commission & another (Petition 48 of 2019) [2019] KEELRC 523 (KLR)

Employment and Labour Relations Court
1 November 2019
4,842 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~19 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan court ruled the Chief Registrar lacked power to discipline a magistrate, but the magistrate's dismissal still stood.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The petitioner, a former Senior Principal Magistrate, challenged his dismissal from the Judiciary after disciplinary proceedings over habitual drunkenness during working hours. He had earlier been interdicted in 2015 for similar conduct, interdiction being lifted with a stern warning and a chance at rehabilitation, before a further charge of 02.09.2016 and dismissal effective 09.02.2017 by the Judicial Service Commission. The petitioner sought declarations that the charge and interdiction drawn by the Chief Registrar were unconstitutional and a nullity, that section 23 of the Third Schedule to the Judicial Service Act denying judicial officers reports or recorded reasons was unconstitutional, and reinstatement with back salaries, damages and costs. The Court held that the 2nd respondent acted ultra vires sections 16 and 25 of the Third Schedule, which vest the powers of interdiction and charging a Magistrate in the Chief Justice, and declared the charge and interdition null and void ab initio, awarding the withheld half salary of Kshs.1,275,501.00. It also declared section 23 of the Third Schedule unconstitutional as inconsistent with Articles 47(2) and 35, while holding that the Third Schedule provisions are parliamentary enactments not reviewable as subsidiary legislation. However, the dismissal was upheld: the Commission's Committee gave the petitioner an elaborate hearing, he admitted the gross misconduct, the doctrine of waiver applied, and the employer had afforded reasonable rehabilitation support before terminating for a valid reason under sections 43, 45 and 47(5) of the Employment Act. Reinstatement, compensation and aggravated damages were refused. The judgment is to be served on the Attorney General for legislative intervention, and the respondents were ordered to pay 50% of the petitioner's costs.

Key legal issues

#
01

Ultra vires charge and interdiction by the Chief Registrar

Holding

The 2nd respondent acted ultra vires sections 16 and 25 of the Third Schedule to the Judicial Service Act; the charge and interdiction were null and void ab initio.

Reasoning

The respondents admitted that the powers to interdict, suspend and draw charges against a Magistrate are vested in the Chief Justice under the Third Schedule. Following Radido J in N.M.I v JSC, the Court held the Chief Registrar could not exercise those powers, especially where no vacancy in the office of Chief Justice was alleged. The petitioner was therefore awarded the half pay withheld during the interdiction.

p. 9
02

Constitutionality of section 23 of the Third Schedule (no reports or recorded reasons)

Holding

Section 23 is unconstitutional and inconsistent with Articles 47(2) and 35, undermining transparency and accountability.

Reasoning

Article 47 entitles every person to reasons for adverse administrative decisions, and access to information in a disciplinary case serves transparency, accountability and enforcement of rights. However, the Third Schedule provisions are parliamentary enactments, not subsidiary legislation, and so cannot be struck down as ultra vires the Fair Administrative Action Act or the Access to Information Act.

p. 9
03

Due process and validity of the dismissal despite the ultra vires charge

Holding

The dismissal stands; the 1st respondent accorded the petitioner a fair hearing, had valid reason to dismiss, and exercised inherent power to regulate its own procedure.

Reasoning

The petitioner attended the Committee hearing, was heard extensively under oath, admitted the gross misconduct, and requested another chance. Section 20 of the Third Schedule preserves the Commission's inherent power notwithstanding the defective charge. Sections 43, 45 and 47(5) of the Employment Act were satisfied; the employer had afforded rehabilitation on full pay and the petitioner failed to improve. Nullifying the dismissal to restart the process would serve no purpose.

p. 11
04

Alleged breach of constitutional rights and entitlement to compensation/reinstatement

Holding

No rights breach established; compensation and reinstatement refused.

Reasoning

Having found a fair hearing before the 1st respondent and no resulting injustice, the petitioner's claims for declarations of rights violations under Articles 27, 28, 29, 40, 41, 43, 47 and 236, and for aggravated damages, fail. The remedy preserved is the withheld half salary during the ultra vires interdiction, which balances justice between the parties.

p. 12

Legal principles established

#
  • The power to interdict, suspend and frame charges against a Magistrate is vested in the Chief Justice under sections 16 and 25 of the Third Schedule to the Judicial Service Act, and the Chief Registrar acting in that regard is ultra vires.
  • Section 23 of the Third Schedule to the Judicial Service Act, denying judicial officers reports or recorded reasons, is unconstitutional as inconsistent with Article 47(2) and Article 35.
  • Where an employer has afforded a needy employee a reasonable chance to benefit from an employee assistance programme but the employee fails to improve, the employer's obligation of fair labour practice in that respect is discharged.
  • Failure to raise procedural irregularity in the manner the charge was imposed during the hearing attracts the doctrine of waiver.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Declaration that the 2nd respondent acted ultra vires sections 16 and 25 of the Third Schedule to the Judicial Service Act by issuing the charge and interdiction dated 02.09.2016, which are declared null and void ab initio
  2. 2.Declaration that section 23 of the Third Schedule to the Judicial Service Act is unconstitutional and inconsistent with Articles 47(2), 35, 10(2)(a)(c) and 232(1)(e)(f) of the Constitution, and is declared unconstitutional, null and void to that extent
  3. 3.The judgment to be served by the petitioner, within 7 days, upon the Hon. Attorney General for appropriate legislative interventions
  4. 4.The respondents to pay the petitioner Kshs.1,275,501.00 (less PAYE) by 15.12.2019, failing which interest at court rates from the date of judgment till full payment
  5. 5.The respondents to pay 50% of the petitioner's costs of the petition

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Articles 2(1)(4), 3(1), 10(2)(a)(c), 23, 35, 41, 43, 47(1)(2), 73, 129, 171(2)(c), 172(1)(c), 232(1)(e)(f), 236(a)(b), 259(11)
  • Judicial Service Act, 2011section 12(1)(c)(f), section 32(3), Third Schedule sections 16(1), 17(2), 20, 23, 25(1), Part IV Third Schedule section 25(11)
  • Judicial Service Commission Actnot specified
  • Employment Act, 2007sections 43, 45, 47(5)
  • Fair Administrative Action Actsection 6
  • Access to Information Act, 2016section 4
  • Universal Declaration of Human RightsArticle 23

Cases cited (4)

  • N.MI –Versus- Judicial Service Commission and Another
    Petition 152 of 2018
  • Bryan Mandila Khaemba –Versus- Chief Justice and President of the Supreme Court of Kenya and Another
    [2019] eKLR
  • Kenya Aviation Workers Union –Versus- Kenya Airways Limited
    [2019] eKLR
  • Peter Wambugu Kariuki and 16 others –Versus- Kenya Agricultural Research Institute
    [2013] eKLR
Jurisdiction invoked
Constitution of Kenya, 2010 (petition under Articles 236, 41, 47 and related provisions; removal under Article 172(1)(c))

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Later judgments citing this (1)

#

Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Ruto v Judicial Service Commission & another (Petition 48 of 2019) [2019] KEELRC 523 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2019). Petition (amended, filed 17.05.2019). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2019/523/eng@2019-11-01

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.