Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELRCDismissedNot stated in the judgment text (Judicial Review Notice of Motion dated 04.09.2019)· [2019] KEELRC 284 (KLR)

Bernadette Nyambura Njoroge v Attorney General & another [2019] KEELRC 284 (KLR)

Employment and Labour Relations Court
22 November 2019
2,863 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~11 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan court ruled that a board's uncommunicated resolution to renew an employee's contract can be changed, and her lapsed contract was not unlawfully terminated.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The applicant, formerly Director, Legal and Enforcement at the Water Services Regulatory Board (WASREB), moved the Court by notice of motion dated 04.09.2019 under Order 53 rules 1, 2 and 3 of the Civil Procedure Rules and section 3A of the Civil Procedure Act, seeking leave to apply for certiorari to quash the Board's special resolution of 12.07.2019, the termination letter of 05.08.2019 and two press advertisements, or alternatively compensation of salaries for the unexpired contractual period to 02.01.2021 plus gratuity and terminal benefits. Her case was that the new Board had on 20.05.2019 resolved to renew her contract for two years, and its later decision not to renew was unprocedural, unlawful and in breach of natural justice, Article 47 of the Constitution and the Fair Administrative Action Act, 2015. The 2nd respondent opposed, contending that the 20.05.2019 resolution was never communicated per Clause 3.7 of the HR Manual; that the Board changed its mind on 04.07.2019 upon appreciating constitutional and statutory requirements for competitive, transparent filling of public offices; that the contract had lapsed on 02.01.2019; and that the applicant failed to exhaust internal remedies. The Court found the contract lapsed on 02.01.2019 and the conditional service under the 31.10.2018 Ministerial no objection terminated automatically on the Board's appointment; the renewal request had been frustrated; there was no continuing legitimate expectation; no breach of natural justice or fair administrative action was established; the uncommunicated resolution remained an internal matter the Board could vary; and the exhaustion submission failed for want of specificity. The motion was dismissed, with each party bearing own costs, and the applicant left free to compete in the impending recruitment.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether there was a valid renewal of the applicant's contract

Holding

No. The contract lapsed on 02.01.2019 and the service granted by the Ministerial no objection in the letter of 31.10.2018 was conditional, lapsing automatically on the appointment of the new Board, whichever was earlier.

Reasoning

The applicant's timely renewal request could not be considered because no Board was in place, so the contractual renewal provision was frustrated. The Ministerial approval granted service for one year or until the new Board was in place, whichever was earlier. The applicant accepted those terms, so she knew she would automatically vacate office if a new Board was appointed. There was therefore no subsisting renewal for the Board to revoke.

p. 3
02

Whether the Board's decision breached natural justice and Article 47 of the Constitution

Holding

No adverse decision was made against the applicant; the Board's wide, unchained contractual discretion over renewal was lawfully exercised.

Reasoning

The contract contained no provisions limiting the matters the Board could consider in allowing or rejecting renewal, so the discretion was open and not chained by the applicant's performance. The letter of 05.08.2019 did not give reasons, but the applicant knew she would automatically vacate office upon the new Board's appointment. The Board was entitled to invoke constitutional, statutory and policy requirements for competitive filling of vacancies.

p. 3
03

Effect of the uncommunicated Board resolution of 20.05.2019 renewing the contract

Holding

The Board was entitled to change its mind; the uncommunicated resolution remained internal and the change of mind was not shown to be in bad faith or malicious.

Reasoning

The 2nd respondent exhibited all records of proceedings after 20.05.2019, showing the Board internally changed its mind. Since the resolution was never communicated to the applicant per Clause 3.7 of the HR Manual, it was not official communication and remained open to variation. Bad faith, malice or other impairing reason was not established, and no legal provision barred the new Board from appointing an Ad hoc Committee instead of using a standing committee.

p. 3
04

Whether the applicant failed to exhaust internal review and appeal procedures under section 9(3) of the Fair Administrative Action Act, 2015

Holding

The submission failed because the respondent did not identify any specific internal appeal or review procedure that the applicant failed to use.

Reasoning

The Court revisited the replying and further replying affidavits and found that no specific internal procedure was identified. The letter of 05.08.2019 did not confer or refer to any right of review or appeal, and the demand letter received no reply on that issue. The exhaustion submission therefore collapsed as unjustified.

p. 3
05

Effect of repetition of the leave prayer in the substantive motion

Holding

The repetition of the prayer for leave in the substantive motion served as an impetus to declining the prayers as made.

Reasoning

The applicant had already obtained leave to apply for judicial review by way of certiorari. The substantive notice of motion nonetheless repeated the prayer for leave. The Court considered this procedural defect an impetus to declining the prayers as framed in the motion.

p. 3

Legal principles established

#
  • A Board resolution that has not been communicated to the affected employee remains an internal matter which the Board may vary, as it is not implemented by way of relevant communication.
  • Where a contract renewal request could not be considered because the appointing Board was absent, the request was frustrated and no legitimate expectation of renewal survives the Board's appointment where conditional service terms provided for automatic lapse.
  • A submission on failure to exhaust internal remedies must identify the specific internal appeal or review procedure that was not complied with.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Judgment entered for the 2nd respondent against the applicant for dismissal of the notice of motion dated 04.09.2019
  2. 2.Each party to bear own costs of the proceedings

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Civil Procedure ActSection 3A
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 53 rules 1, 2 and 3
  • Water ActNo. 43 of 2016, section 73
  • Fair Administrative Action Act2015, sections 7, 8, 9 (including 9(3)), 10 and 11
  • Public Service (Values and Principles) Act2015, section 10
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Articles 47 and 232
Jurisdiction invoked
Order 53 rules 1, 2 and 3 of the Civil Procedure Rules and Section 3A of the Civil Procedure Act; leave to apply for judicial review orders of certiorari already obtained

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Bernadette Nyambura Njoroge v Attorney General & another [2019] KEELRC 284 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2019). Not stated in the judgment text (Judicial Review Notice of Motion dated 04.09.2019). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2019/284/eng@2019-11-22

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.