Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELRCPartially AllowedAppeal No. 37 of 2017 (Formerly Civil Appeal No. 69 of 2011, Nakuru)· [2018] KEELRC 1209 (KLR)

Agnes Moraa Omiti v KAPI Limited [2018] KEELRC 1209 (KLR)

Employment and Labour Relations Court of Kenya
17 July 2018
3,045 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~12 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan worker won a reduced award of Kshs.75,000 after the court found missing medical records weakened her workplace injury claim.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The appellant, formerly an employee of Kapi Limited (employed as a supervisor in the manufacturing section from 1972/1986 until 2000), sued the respondent before the Chief Magistrate's Court at Nakuru in Civil Suit No. 2550 of 2002, alleging that exposure to dangerous chemicals at work caused chronic allergic contact dermatitis, chest pains and skin rushes, and that the employer was negligent in failing to provide protective clothing and a safe working environment. The trial court dismissed the suit, holding that the appellant failed to prove her case on a balance of probabilities: her expert, Dr Kiamba, did not treat her and relied on treatment notes not produced in evidence, and the specific dangerous chemicals were never identified. On first appeal, the Court reappraised the evidence, applying Selle v Associated Motor Boat Co Ltd and Kenneth Nyaga Mwige v Austin Kiguta on formal proof of documents. The Court found the causal link between the alleged exposure and the illness unproved, since the medical records and Dr Vilembwa's letter were not produced and the chemicals were not identified. In a somewhat contradictory disposition, the Court nevertheless allowed the appeal, set aside the lower court's orders and entered judgment for the appellant at Kshs.75,000.00, with costs awarded at 50%, holding that the predicated award of Kshs.150,000.00 should be shared 50/50 between employee and employer in the absence of medical records establishing the degree of injury. Costs were awarded at 50%.

Key legal issues

#
01

Sufficiency of treatment notes as proof of work-related injury

Holding

Treatment notes were insufficient without the primary medical report and without identifying the specific chemicals that allegedly caused the illness; the causal link was not established.

Reasoning

Dr Kiamba, the appellant's expert, did not treat the appellant and merely relied on treatment notes that were not produced in evidence; he could not identify the chemicals to which she was exposed. The trial court found, and this Court agreed, that without identification of the specific chemicals and production of Dr Vilembwa's letter, the ill-health could not be related to the workplace. The appellant therefore failed to discharge the burden of proof under section 107(1) of the Evidence Act.

p. 4
02

Standard of proof in civil claims

Holding

The standard of proof in civil cases is on a balance of probabilities, per sections 107, 108 and 109 of the Evidence Act, but the appellant did not meet it.

Reasoning

The Court restated that whoever desires a court to give judgment as to a legal right or liability dependent on facts must prove those facts. Although the appellant's counsel argued that requiring the employee to specify the chemical pollutant demanded proof beyond any cloud of doubt, the Court held that on the evidence the balance-of-probabilities threshold was not attained because the causal connection between the alleged chemical exposure and the diagnosed dermatitis was not demonstrated.

p. 3
03

Formal proof of documents marked for identification

Holding

A medical report marked for identification by its maker does not amount to proved evidence; documents pass through three stages — filing, production as exhibits, and proof on judicial examination.

Reasoning

Relying on Kenneth Nyaga Mwige v Austin Kiguta & 2 others, the Court held that admission of a document in evidence as an exhibit should not be confused with proof of the document. The respondent's medical report from Dr Zachary W.O. was marked for identification by its author/maker and was not proved. Evidence must be interrogated as to its veracity and linked to the facts before the court; mere production is insufficient.

p. 4

Legal principles established

#
  • A first appellate court must reconsider the evidence, assess it and make its own conclusions while remembering it neither saw nor heard the witnesses.
  • Mere production or marking of a document for identification does not amount to proof; the court must interrogate its relevance and veracity at the final hearing.
  • A party producing a document must lay foundation for its relevance and link it to the facts presented before the court.
  • Where injury is alleged to arise from exposure to chemicals, the causal link between the alleged injury and specific chemicals at the workplace must be established on the evidence.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The appeal is allowed and the orders of the lower court set aside
  2. 2.Judgment entered for the appellant against the respondent at Kshs.75,000.00
  3. 3.Costs awarded at 50%

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Evidence Act (Cap 80)Section 107(1)
  • Evidence Act (Cap 80)Sections 107, 108 and 109 (referred to as 'section 107, 108 and 3(2)')

Cases cited (5)

  • Selle versus Associated Motor Boat Company Ltd
    [1968] E.A. 123
  • Tadid Travel & Tours Limited versus Astral Aviation Limited
    Civil Appeal No.3 of 2008
  • George Morara Masitsa versus Tesplast Industries Limited
    High Court Civil Appeal No.540 of 2011; [2015] eKLR
  • Kiruga versus Kiruga & another
    [1988] KLR
  • Kenneth Nyaga Mwige versus Austin Kiguta & 2 others
    [2015] eKLR
On appeal from
Chief Magistrate's Court at Nakuru
Civil Suit No. 2550 of 2002
Jurisdiction invoked
First appeal from the Chief Magistrate's Court under the Employment and Labour Relations Court's appellate jurisdiction

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Agnes Moraa Omiti v KAPI Limited [2018] KEELRC 1209 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2018). Appeal No. 37 of 2017 (Formerly Civil Appeal No. 69 of 2011, Nakuru). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2018/1209/eng@2018-07-17

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.