Bloomingdale Roses (K) Ltd v Nteere (Civil Appeal 1 of 2018) [2018] KEELRC 538 (KLR)
The bottom line
#A Kenyan court dismissed a worker's injury award won in the magistrates' court, ruling work injury claims must go through the Director of Occupational Safety and Health, not court.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Retroactivity of the Court of Appeal's restoration of the Work Injury Benefits Act 2007
The 2017 Court of Appeal decision operates prospectively only; suits concluded before its pronouncement remain valid and cannot be reopened as per incuriam.
The court reasoned that at the time the Respondent filed her suit, Ojwang J's ruling and 2009 judgment had declared parts of WIBA unconstitutional, allowing pending and new claims to proceed in the magistrates' courts. The subsequent reversal by the Court of Appeal on 17 November 2017 could not invalidate judgments delivered before that date, else every party could resile from concluded WIBA decisions. Hence the Chief Magistrate's judgment of 22 February 2018, though delivered after the reversal, could not stand for the separate reason that WIBA procedure was then binding, but the earlier law-based suit was not per incuriam.
Jurisdiction of the magistrates' court over work injury claims
The Appellant admitted jurisdiction in its defence before the trial court and raised no objection there; the WIBA channel through the Director of Occupational Safety and Health was nevertheless the proper route once the Court of Appeal reversed the High Court.
The Appellant, as defendant in the lower court, admitted the court's jurisdiction, explaining why no jurisdictional challenge was made at first instance. However, applying the Court of Appeal's 2017 judgment restoring WIBA, exclusive power to determine compensation lies with the Director of Occupational Safety and Health, with appeal routes to the ELRC. The court thus held the Chief Magistrate's determination of 22 February 2018 was delivered after the Court of Appeal's pronouncement and was per incuriam, warranting dismissal of the suit with referral to DOSH.
Legal principles established
#- A declaration of unconstitutionality is not retroactive; it does not affect suits that were concluded and judgments given prior to its pronouncement.
- A first appellate court must analyse and evaluate the evidence afresh while allowing for the trial court's advantage of seeing the witnesses.
- Jurisdiction flows from the Constitution or legislation and a court cannot arrogate itself jurisdiction exceeding that conferred by law.
Court orders
#- 1.The suit before the Chief Magistrate's Court is dismissed
- 2.The Claimant's injury claim is to be referred to the Director of Occupational Safety and Health as required by law
- 3.No order as to costs on the appeal
- On appeal from
- Chief Magistrate's Court at Meru
- Chief Magistrate's Civil Case No. 239 of 2016
- Jurisdiction invoked
- First appellate jurisdiction over the Chief Magistrate's decision (statute not specified in the judgment)
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Bloomingdale Roses (K) Ltd v Nteere (Civil Appeal 1 of 2018) [2018] KEELRC 538 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2018). Meru Chief Magistrate's Civil Case No. 239 of 2016, Appeal (judgment at first appellate instance). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2018/538/eng@2018-11-08
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.