Kenya Union of Domestic, Hotels, Educational Institutions, Hospitals and Allied Workers v Upper Hill Mixed Secondary School [2016] KEELRC 1806 (KLR)
The bottom line
#A Kenyan school failed to overturn a court order recognising a workers' union and was fined costs for trying.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Power to enter into recognition agreements under the Basic Education Act, 2013
Boards of Management, not the Cabinet Secretary, have the power to enter recognition agreements with unions, because they are the employers of non-teaching staff under section 59(p) of the Basic Education Act
Section 54 of the Labour Relations Act obligates an employer to recognise a union with a simple majority membership, and the Respondent did not dispute the Union met that threshold. The Union recruits from non-teaching staff who are publicly known to be employed by Boards of Management. Section 59(p) of the Basic Education Act empowers Boards to recruit, employ and remunerate non-teaching staff, making the Board the employer competent to conclude recognition agreements. The Respondent cited no provision empowering the Cabinet Secretary.
Whether Legal Notice No. 263 of 1993 was rendered obsolete by the Basic Education Act, 2013
The Legal Notice remains in force by virtue of the saving provisions of section 101(2) and (4) of the Basic Education Act, 2013
The Respondent argued the Notice was obsolete after the introduction of free secondary education. The Union relied on section 101 of the Basic Education Act, under which relevant provisions of the repealed Education Act on recognition agreements were saved. The Court found the revocation argument untenable given the clear general saving provisions.
Whether the absence of a constituted Board of Management defeated enforcement of the judgment
The argument was a red herring; the Respondent should have attended the hearing, and its advocate's instructions implied a legal entity existed
The Court reasoned that the Respondent should have attended the hearing to raise that factual position. If no Board existed, there would be no legal entity to instruct the Respondent's advocate to file the motion. Moreover, the Union had not moved to execute; once a Board is in place it would be obliged to comply or face contempt proceedings.
Whether fee constraints from free secondary education defeated recognition
Recognition by itself does not affect fees or costs; financial obligations arise only upon conclusion of a collective bargaining agreement
The Respondent argued that fee caps under free schooling would prevent it from meeting financial obligations arising from recognition. The Court held that a recognition agreement alone leads to no adjustment in fees or costs, and questions of costs and finances become relevant only when a collective bargaining agreement has been concluded, which was a long way off.
Scope of the Court's review jurisdiction
The Court's review jurisdiction is wider than the High Court's under the Civil Procedure Rules, including review where a judgment is contrary to written law
The Respondent invoked review without expressly citing a ground. The Court took the Respondent to be relying on the ground that the judgment was against or contrary to a written law, a ground available to this Court though not under the Civil Procedure Rules. On examining the written law, the Court found the judgment consistent with the statutory scheme.
Legal principles established
#- The Employment and Labour Relations Court's power to review its judgments is wider than the High Court's under the Civil Procedure Rules, extending to review on the ground that a judgment is against or contrary to a written law.
- Under section 54 of the Labour Relations Act, an employer is obligated to recognise a union which has achieved a simple majority membership, and it is the employer who has legal competence to enter into recognition agreements.
- For purposes of the Labour Relations Act and Employment Act, 2007, the employer of non-teaching staff in public schools is the Board of Management, not the Cabinet Secretary for Education.
- Financial considerations arising from recognition agreements become relevant only upon conclusion of a collective bargaining agreement.
Court orders
#- 1.The Respondent's motion filed in Court on 10 July 2015 is dismissed with costs of Kshs 20,000/- to the Union
- 2.The judgment of 8 May 2015 ordering the Respondent to grant recognition to the Claimant Union within 30 days remains in force
- Jurisdiction invoked
- The Court's inherent power to review its own judgments and orders, which it held is wider than the High Court's power under the Civil Procedure Rules, including review on the ground that a judgment is against or contrary to a written law
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Kenya Union of Domestic, Hotels, Educational Institutions, Hospitals and Allied Workers v Upper Hill Mixed Secondary School [2016] KEELRC 1806 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2016). Cause No 27 of 2013. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2016/1806/eng@2016-01-22
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.