Esther Muringi Wahome & 5 others v Cementers Building and Civil Engineering Contractors Ltd [2016] KEELRC 1660 (KLR)
The bottom line
#Kenyan employers must give reasons and a hearing before firing; even justified dismissals are unfair if procedure is skipped.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Whether termination of the claimant in Cause No. 1643 was fair
Grounds may have been justified but termination was procedurally unfair as no disciplinary hearing or opportunity to defend was afforded; five months' salary awarded.
The claimant was terminated by letter dated 18 July 2011 accusing him of refusal to sign a warning, absenteeism and lack of commitment. He was paid Kshs.65,200 in terminal dues which he acknowledged. However, the respondent neither exhibited nor pleaded that he was taken through a disciplinary hearing and given a chance to defend himself as required by the Act. Procedural fairness therefore failed and compensation followed.
Status of short-service employees and entitlement to fair procedure in Cause No. 1714
Employees serving over one month are regular employees under section 37; they were neither given reasons nor a hearing, and no redundancy procedure was shown; one month's notice pay plus five months' compensation awarded.
The respondent did not deny employment but contended the claimants worked under ten months as casuals. Under section 37 of the Employment Act, service exceeding an aggregate of one month confers regular employee status. There was no evidence of reasons for termination, a hearing, or compliance with redundancy procedures if redundancy was the basis. The court therefore awarded notice pay and compensation.
Whether the dismissal of the storeman in Cause No. 2080 was fair
The reason (missing items) was plausible but dismissal without due process was unfair; five months' salary awarded.
The claimant was dismissed for loss of items under his care. The respondent's own witness admitted he was not aware whether any disciplinary hearing was conducted prior to termination. Although the reason for dismissal was plausible, absence of evidence of due process under the Employment Act rendered the dismissal unfair, warranting five months' salary as compensation and costs of the suit.
Sustainability of the claims in Cause No. 1697
Claims dismissed for failure to rebut substantive defences and for lack of proof; some prayers (committal) not grantable.
The claimants did not file any reply to the respondent's substantive defences (casual status, annual payment of leave, terminability on project completion, and inapplicability of the Employment Act 2007 to pre-2008 terminations), nor did they refute them in testimony or submissions. The evidence did not establish when each claimant was terminated. A party seeking a remedy must plead and prove it; the claims were not proved.
Legal principles established
#- An employee who serves for an aggregate period exceeding one month is deemed a regular employee entitled to procedure, reasons for termination and service pay under section 37 of the Employment Act.
- Termination may be substantively justified yet unfair if due procedure (hearing and reasons) is not followed.
- A party seeking a remedy bears the duty to plead and present evidence in support of it.
Court orders
#- 1.In cause no. 1643 of 2011: 5 months salary as compensation for unfair termination
- 2.Cause no. 1697 of 2011: dismissed with costs
- 3.Cause no. 1714 of 2011: one month's salary in lieu of notice and 5 months salary as compensation for unfair termination
- 4.In 2080 of 2011: 5 months salary as compensation for unfair termination of services
- 5.Costs in (a), (c) and (d) to the claimants
- 6.The respondent shall issue all the claimants with certificates of service
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Employment Act, 2007 (including sections 37 and 90) - first-instance employment claims
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Esther Muringi Wahome & 5 others v Cementers Building and Civil Engineering Contractors Ltd [2016] KEELRC 1660 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2016). Causes Nos. 1714, 1697, 2080 and 1643 of 2011 (consolidated). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2016/1660/eng@2016-02-12
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.