Shalimar Flowers (K) Limited v Kenya Plantation & Agricultural Workers Union [2016] KEELRC 1652 (KLR)
The bottom line
#Kenya's Employment Court refused to block a union strike, ruling that a properly issued strike notice under section 76 of the Labour Relations Act was lawful and constitutionally protected.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Lawfulness of the strike notice under section 76 of the Labour Relations Act
The strike notice was lawful: the dispute concerned terms and conditions of employment, had gone through conciliation and adjudication, and seven days' written notice was given.
Section 76 requires that the dispute concern terms and conditions of employment or recognition, be unresolved after conciliation, and that seven days' written notice be given. The 2013-2015 CBA dispute was reported to the Cabinet Secretary, conciliation deadlocked, and the Court determined it on 14 November 2014, yet the parties could not agree on implementation even after the Labour Officer's interpretation. The strike notice dated 25 September 2015 therefore met all statutory conditions and was anchored in Article 41 of the Constitution.
Whether internal dispute resolution mechanisms in the recognition agreement (clause 3(d)) barred the strike
Clause 3(d) did not assist the Claimant because the dispute had already gone through conciliation and judicial adjudication; requiring the parties to repeat the process would be a mockery.
The Court found the 2013-2015 CBA dispute had passed through conciliation under the Cabinet Secretary and adjudication by the Court, which awarded two 10% wage increases in a judgment not appealed against. To expect the parties to traverse the same processes again would render the Court's establishment objectives meaningless - a 'game of musical chairs'. The recognition agreement's internal mechanisms were therefore spent in respect of this dispute.
Whether the Respondent failed to negotiate in good faith
The Court found hardball tactics on both sides but held it could not force agreement, and declined to stop a strike where one partner had complied with statutory requisites.
The Court observed that disputes between these parties came to it regularly and that both sides employed hardball tactics. It lacks jurisdiction to compel agreement, and where a partner has satisfied the statutory requirements for industrial action, the Court would refuse injunctions. It cautioned against being drawn into power plays where one party seeks to use the law tactically, and against clawing back the constitutionally protected right to strike through implied limitations.
Procedural observation on commencement of section 76 applications
The Court observed that the rules should be amended so that applications predicated on section 76 be commenced by Originating Motion or Summons, since final orders granted under the guise of interlocutory applications confer tactical advantage.
Once the interlocutory application predicated on section 76 of the Labour Relations Act is determined, nothing remains of the Memorandum of Claim; the motion effectively sought final relief (a permanent prohibitory order). Granting final orders under the guise of an interlocutory application gives one social partner a tactical advantage. The Court recommended that the rules be amended to require commencement by Originating Motion or Summons.
Legal principles established
#- A strike notice founded on enforcement of a court judgment over terms and conditions of employment, issued after conciliation and a 7-day written notice, satisfies section 76 of the Labour Relations Act.
- The Court has no jurisdiction to compel social partners to reach agreement and will not stop a strike where a partner has met the statutory requirements.
- The right to strike is constitutionally protected and courts should not read implicit limitations into it to rebalance power between social partners.
Court orders
#- 1.The Notice of Motion dated 30 September 2015 dismissed
- 2.Costs of the motion awarded to the Respondent
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Employment and Labour Relations Court jurisdiction over trade disputes and strikes under Article 41 of the Constitution and section 76 of the Labour Relations Act
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Shalimar Flowers (K) Limited v Kenya Plantation & Agricultural Workers Union [2016] KEELRC 1652 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2016). Notice of Motion dated 30 September 2015 (Cause number not stated in judgment; proceedings commenced in Kisumu and heard in Nakuru). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2016/1652/eng@2016-02-26
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.