Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELRCPartially AllowedCause No. 7 of 2015· [2016] KEELRC 419 (KLR)

John Rioba Maugo v Riley Falcon Security Services Limited [2016] KEELRC 419 (KLR)

Employment & Labour Relations Court
8 September 2016
4,061 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~16 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan court ruled that smelling of alcohol alone cannot justify sacking a worker; employers must prove drunkenness actually stopped the employee from working.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The claimant, a security guard, was summarily dismissed on 24th April 2014 on grounds of being drunk while on duty. He sought notice pay, accrued leave, compensation for wrongful dismissal, severance pay, underpayments and unpaid rest days, among other remedies. The court framed three issues: the date of commencement of employment, the fairness of the dismissal, and entitlement to remedies. On the first issue, the court held that employment commenced on 17th November 2010 under the letter of re-employment dated 20th November 2010, not 18th May 2006, since the claimant accepted the new contract without objection and worked under it for over three years. On substantive fairness, the court held that drinking alone or smelling alcohol is not a ground for summary dismissal; the employer must prove intoxication rendered the employee unwilling or incapable of performing his work. RW2 testified the claimant was sober, and the controller who found him drunk did not testify, so the grounds for dismissal were not established. Medical or scientific proof of drunkenness was held unnecessary, there being no generic scientific measure of intoxication. On procedure, the same-day show cause letter, hearing invitation and hearing amounted to cosmetic compliance with section 41 of the Employment Act, rendering the dismissal procedurally unfair. The court awarded notice pay, accrued leave for 41 months, overtime for 20 hours weekly, the balance of double-rate pay for rest days, underpayments from May 2011, and six months' gross salary as compensation, plus a certificate of service. Severance pay was refused as the claimant was not declared redundant. Costs and interest from the date of judgment were awarded to the claimant.

Key legal issues

#
01

Date of commencement of employment following dismissal and re-engagement

Holding

Employment commenced on 17th November 2010, not 18th May 2006, per the re-employment letter

Reasoning

The letter of 20th November 2010 was titled 'RE-EMPLOYMENT' and offered fresh employment under new terms and conditions with a new employment number, effective 17th November 2010. The claimant did not object to the letter and worked under it for over three years before his dismissal, showing acceptance of its terms.

p. 4
02

Whether drunkenness justified summary dismissal

Holding

Respondent failed to establish grounds for the dismissal

Reasoning

Section 44(4)(b) requires proof that intoxication rendered the employee unwilling or incapable of performing his work. RW2 testified the claimant was sober and never saw him drinking; the controller who determined the claimant was drunk did not testify. No evidence proved the claimant was incapable or unwilling to work, so the substantive grounds for dismissal were not established. Medical/scientific proof of intoxication was held unnecessary.

p. 6
03

Whether the dismissal was procedurally fair

Holding

The summary dismissal was procedurally unfair

Reasoning

The show cause letter, hearing invitation and hearing all occurred on the same day, leaving no time to prepare a defence. No minutes of the hearing were produced, the claimant was not informed of his right to be accompanied by a colleague or union official, and nothing was recorded of his defence. This fell short of the procedural fairness requirements in section 41 of the Employment Act.

p. 7
04

Entitlement to underpayments, overtime, rest day and public holiday pay

Holding

Claimant awarded underpayments from May 2011, overtime of 20 hours weekly, and balance of double-rate pay for rest days

Reasoning

The respondent did not deny underpayment contrary to section 26 of the Employment Act and section 48 of the Labour Institutions Act but argued limitation; the court limited underpayments to the three years before dismissal. RW1 confirmed 72 hours worked in six days against the 52-hour week in Rule 6 of the Regulation of Wages (Protective Security Services) Order, entitling the claimant to overtime, and payslips showed single rather than double rate pay for rest days and public holidays.

p. 7

Legal principles established

#
  • Drinking alone or smelling alcohol is not of itself a ground for summary dismissal; the employer must prove intoxication rendered the employee unwilling or incapable of performing his work.
  • There is no generic scientific measure of intoxication; the court rejected the need for medical proof of drunkenness.
  • An employer should adopt a policy for determining intoxication, using physical observation and simple functional tests recorded before witnesses, rather than relying on medical testing.
  • Procedural fairness under section 41 of the Employment Act requires the employer to inform the employee of the charges, allow time to prepare and be heard, and hear and consider representations before summary dismissal.
  • A same-day show cause letter, hearing invitation and hearing amounts to cosmetic compliance with section 41 and does not permit the employee to prepare a defence.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.One month's salary in lieu of notice of Kshs. 12,548.50
  2. 2.Accrued leave at 26 days per year for 41 months from 17th November 2010 to 24th April 2014, Kshs. 37,157.40
  3. 3.Overtime at 20 hours per week for 52 weeks at one and a half times the normal hourly rate, Kshs. 87,002.90
  4. 4.Rest days: balance of 1x1 double hourly rate based on 12x the hourly rate, Kshs. 34,901.00
  5. 5.Underpayments of Kshs. 4,156.50 per month for 12 months, Kshs. 49,878.00
  6. 6.Compensation for unfair dismissal at 6 months gross salary, Kshs. 75,291.00
  7. 7.Certificate of service
  8. 8.Respondent to pay the claimant's costs and interest on the decretal sum from date of judgment

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Employment Actsection 41
  • Employment Actsection 44(2)
  • Employment Actsection 44(4)(b)
  • Employment Actsection 44(4)(e)
  • Employment Actsection 47(5)
  • Employment Actsection 49(c)
  • Employment Actsection 26
  • Employment Actsection 90
  • Labour Institutions Actsection 48
  • Regulation of Wages (Protective Security Services) OrderRules 6, 7, 9 and 10

Cases cited (3)

  • David Gichana Omuya v Mombasa Maize Millers Limited
    [2014]eKLR
  • Anthony Mkala Chitavi v Malindi Water & Sewerage Co. Limited
    [2013]eKLR
  • Nicholas Otinyu Muruka v Equity Bank Limited
    [2013]eKLR
Jurisdiction invoked
Employment and labour relations jurisdiction over unfair termination and wrongful dismissal claims (Employment Act, 2007)

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Later judgments citing this (1)

#

Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "John Rioba Maugo v Riley Falcon Security Services Limited [2016] KEELRC 419 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2016). Cause No. 7 of 2015. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2016/419/eng@2016-09-08

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.