Joram Sire Malit & 199 others v Municipal Council Of Kisumu & another [2015] KEELRC 951 (KLR)
The bottom line
#A Kenyan court ruled that former Kisumu Council employees who left before March 2003 lost their right to claim, because time limits can't be waived.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Whether the claim is time barred
Partially - any claimant who left employment before 13th March 2003 is time barred and should be struck off the claim
The applicable limitation period is determined by the date of termination: 6 years under Section 4(2) of the Limitation of Actions Act for terminations before 2nd June 2008, and 3 years under Section 90 of the Employment Act thereafter. The 12-month limitation argued by the respondent applies only to continuing wrongs of employees still in employment. The claim was filed on 13th March 2009, so claimants who left employment 6 years prior are barred.
Capacity of the respondents in view of the establishment of the County Government
Section 59 of the Urban Areas and Cities Act applies; the 1st respondent's liabilities transfer to the County Government of Kisumu, but there was misjoinder of the two respondents
The claim was filed before the Urban Areas and Cities Act came into force, so Section 59 preserves causes of action against the body established by law and transfers the local authority's liabilities to the county government. The 1st and 2nd respondents are separate legal entities with liabilities that are neither the same nor joint; the misjoinder can be managed by separating submissions on remedies.
Whether the suit should proceed without amendment despite the 24 deceased plaintiffs
Yes - the suit proceeds with all names including deceased claimants; abatement to be dealt with at the payment stage
Taking judicial notice of the age of the case, the court held that prolonging the proceedings would be against the interest of justice. No proof of death or substitution had been filed, so the question of abatement will be addressed after determination, when dealing with payment of any proceeds of the claim.
Whether the claimants were retired or dismissed
The evidence on record refers to retirement; the real question is whether they are deemed retained in service under Section 16A of the Pensions (Amendment) Act 2003
All the evidence, including documents attached to the claimants' submissions, refers to retirement rather than dismissal. The court therefore reframed the issue as whether the claimants should be deemed retained in service pursuant to Section 16A of the Pensions (Amendment) Act 2003 and entitled to attendant benefits.
Legal principles established
#- Limitation of actions is substantive law and cannot be disregarded as a procedural technicality under Article 159 of the Constitution
- For terminations before the Employment Act 2007 came into force, the applicable limitation period is 6 years under the Limitation of Actions Act; the 12-month period applies only to continuing wrongs accruing to an employee still in employment
- Under Section 59 of the Urban Areas and Cities Act, legal rights and causes of action commenced before its commencement continue, and liabilities of a local authority transfer to the county government
Court orders
#- 1.That the names of all claimants who left employment before 13th March 2003 be struck off the list of claimants
- 2.That the claimants file submissions on the justification for each head of claim as set out in the prayers under items 1 to 22 in the plaint
- 3.That the claimants compile a list showing date of appointment, date of retirement and particulars of remedies sought by each claimant stating the amount claimed and how the amount claimed under each head has been tabulated, to be filed within 30 days
- 4.That the claimants do separate the list of claimants for the 1st and 2nd respondents
- 5.That the respondents file a response to the claimant's submissions 21 days after service
- 6.That parties take a date for mention to confirm compliance and further directions
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Not stated in the judgment (claim originally filed in the High Court on 13th March 2009 and proceeding before the Employment and Labour Relations Court)
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Joram Sire Malit & 199 others v Municipal Council Of Kisumu & another [2015] KEELRC 951 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2015). Not stated in the judgment. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2015/951/eng@2015-03-19
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.