Kenya Union of Commercial, Food and Allied Workers & 5 others v Alliance One Tobacco (Kenya) Ltd [2015] KEELRC 194 (KLR)
The bottom line
#A Kenyan court ruled that redundancy pay must include regular mileage allowances and house allowances agreed in a collective bargaining deal, but rejected most other claims.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Status of the redundancy and collective bargaining agreement of 18.06.2015
It was a collective agreement limited to the concluded redundancy process; registration would serve no practical purpose and the prayer to compel signature and registration failed.
The court found the agreement was genuinely a collective agreement, capable of registration, but since the redundancy it governed was concluded, registration would serve little practical purpose. The parties, being in a recognition agreement, remained free to negotiate and register the next collective agreement, and the sole remaining union member would not be disadvantaged in any future redundancy.
Entitlement of contracted staff to gratuity and 15% house allowance
Gratuity claim failed; NSSF registration satisfied section 35(6)(d) of the Employment Act. However, contracted staff not paid the 15% house allowance in the redundancy package were declared entitled to it.
The exhibited contracts had no gratuity provision and the staff were registered for NSSF, which under section 35(6)(d) was sufficient; the respondent also paid severance of 57 days per year, exceeding the 15 days under section 40. But the 18.06.2015 agreement plainly provided for 15% house allowance and applied across all staff categories, so unpaid contracted staff were entitled to it per computation.
Mileage allowance as part of gross pay for redundancy computation
The monthly mileage reimbursement was remunerative and part of gross pay; its exclusion discriminated against the 4 manager claimants under section 40(1)(d) of the Employment Act.
CW2 testified the mileage was a monthly pay, not a fuel reimbursement. The court found it remunerative and part of gross pay. The manager claimants, though not union members, could not be treated differently from union members under the 18.06.2015 agreement, so exclusion amounted to discrimination and unfair labour practice; severance was to be recomputed to include it.
Housing allowance for the 4 manager claimants and counterclaim/set off
Historical housing allowance claim failed as managers received consolidated salary compliant with section 31(2)(a); the counterclaim and set off against the 3rd claimant also failed.
Both witnesses confirmed managers were paid consolidated salary with a housing element, satisfying section 31(2)(a). On the counterclaim, the respondent failed to show the 3rd claimant, its human resources officer, failed in his duty; the agreement required 15% house allowance in the redundancy package but not as part of gross pay for computation purposes.
Accrued leave days claim
Failed for want of particulars; the union did not file a schedule of disputed leave days.
The union claimed payment for accrued leave days not paid at redundancy, but filed no schedule of leave days. The court saw no reason to doubt the respondent paid for leave days as exhibited. On a balance of probabilities the union failed to establish the claim, which was dismissed.
Legal principles established
#- A person whose office is abolished is entitled to redundancy payments in accordance with relevant statutory provisions and the provisions of the contract between the parties.
- An agreement limited in purpose to a concluded redundancy process may be registered as a collective agreement, but registration after it has served its purpose has little practical value.
- A trade union has standing to sue on behalf of contracted staff who are its members.
- A remunerative monthly mileage payment is part of gross pay for redundancy computation, as distinct from expense reimbursement facilitative of labour.
Court orders
#- 1.Declaration that all contracted staff not paid the 15% house allowance as part of final redundancy dues are entitled to the same, to be paid per computation to be filed and recorded in court
- 2.Declaration that the respondent's failure to include the remunerative car reimbursement in the gross salary of the 1st to 4th claimants in computing final redundancy pay amounted to discrimination and unfair labour practices
- 3.Declaration that the 1st to 4th claimants were entitled to redundancy computations including the remunerative mileage reimbursement in the gross pay as agreed on 18.06.2015, and to be paid per computation to be filed and recorded in court
- 4.Claimants to file and serve computation by 4.12.2015 and the respondent to file and serve any objection by 11.12.2015, with a view to recording the same in court on a convenient date
- 5.Money payable by the respondent to be paid by 1.02.2016, failing which interest to run from the date of judgment until full payment
- 6.Respondent to pay 50% of the claimants' costs of the suits
- 7.Counterclaim and set off against the 3rd claimant dismissed with costs
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Employment and Labour Relations Court jurisdiction under Article 162(2) of the Constitution and the Employment Act, 2007
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Kenya Union of Commercial, Food and Allied Workers & 5 others v Alliance One Tobacco (Kenya) Ltd [2015] KEELRC 194 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2015). Causes No. 163 and 164 of 2015 (Consolidated). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2015/194/eng@2015-11-25
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.