Fredrick Ngari Muchira, Howard Kipkoech Korir & 98 v Pyrethrum Board Of Kenya [2013] KEELRC 828 (KLR)
The bottom line
#Kenya's Employment Court ruled you cannot review a judgment twice, appeal and review at the same time, or join outsiders after judgment.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Permissibility of a second review
A second review is not permissible; the rule against review of an order made consequential to review exists to bring litigation to an end, subject only to inherent power to correct typographical errors or obvious manifest injustice.
The court reasoned that Rule 32(7) bars further review of an order made on review, and that the purpose of the rule is finality in litigation. Parties and decision-makers may make a mistake once but not repeat it. Neither exception - typographical correction nor manifest injustice on the face of the decision - was established on the facts, so the respondent's second application had to fail.
Standing of non-parties to apply for review
The use of 'a person' in Rule 32(1) does not open review applications to strangers to the suit; only parties have standing.
The court contrasted the phrase 'a person' in Rule 32(1) with Rule 32(3), which refers to 'a party seeking review', and held that the grounds for review (new evidence, mistake or error, breach of written law, clarification, sufficient reason) attach to parties and not strangers. Non-parties therefore lack standing to seek review of a judgment, order, decree or determination of the court.
Joinder of interested parties after judgment
There can be no addition of an interested party after the hearing and determination of a suit; doing so would allow a new cause of action and violate due process and natural justice.
An interested party is a secondary or collateral party whose participation aids resolution of the dispute between primary parties. Such a party must, when admitted, have the chance to plead, undergo discovery, and participate in the hearing. Admitting an interested party claiming substantive remedies after judgment would amount to a fresh suit and a full violation of the rules of natural justice.
New evidence on review
A document not produced at the hearing without explanation fails the due diligence test and, in any event, did not show that the alleged refunds related to the unremitted welfare funds.
The respondent sought to introduce a document dated 31.09.2009 without explaining why it was not produced at the hearing; with due diligence it would have been produced. Further, while it showed refunds may have been made to some employees, it did not show the refunds concerned the welfare funds deducted from claimants and not remitted, so it could not justify variation of the judgment even on the merits.
Legal principles established
#- A decree or order made on review is not subject to further review, save for the court's inherent power to correct typographical errors or revise on account of obvious manifest injustice.
- Persons who are not parties to a suit lack standing to apply for review of the court's judgment, order, decree or determination.
- An interested party cannot be added after hearing and determination of a suit; an interested party must be admitted in time to plead and fully participate in the hearing.
- A party cannot simultaneously appeal against a judgment and apply for its review.
Court orders
#- 1.The respondent Pyrethrum Board of Kenya's application for review dated 13.09.2013 is dismissed with costs
- 2.Family Bank Limited's application dated 12.09.2013 is dismissed with costs
- 3.Pareto Sacco Limited's application dated 26.09.2013 is dismissed with costs
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Industrial Court (Procedure) Rules, 2010, Rule 32
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Fredrick Ngari Muchira, Howard Kipkoech Korir & 98 v Pyrethrum Board Of Kenya [2013] KEELRC 828 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2013). Cause No 16 of 2013. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2013/828/eng@2013-10-04
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.