Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELRCPartially AllowedCause No 1332 of 2011· [2012] KEELRC 112 (KLR)

ENGINEER IDDI ALI MWASINA V COAST WATER SERVICES BOARD [2012] KEELRC 112 (KLR)

Industrial Court (Employment and Labour Relations Court)
23 October 2012
3,072 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~12 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Employment Court awarded a wrongly terminated water board CEO over Kshs. 5.3 million, ruling a ministry could not redeploy an employee who had signed a new contract with the board.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Claimant, formerly of the Ministry of Water and Irrigation, was seconded to the Coast Water Services Board in 2005 and later opted to remain with the Board under a fresh three-year contract as Chief Executive Officer commencing 1st December 2008, with gratuity at 31% of annual basic salary upon successful completion and terminable on three months' notice. While on approved 51 days' leave from 25th January 2010, the Permanent Secretary purportedly redeployed him to Ministry headquarters; the Respondent stopped his salary, and his position was later advertised. The matter was determined on the pleadings and written submissions by consent, with no witnesses called. The court framed three issues: whether the termination was unlawful, who was responsible, and the remedies. It held that upon signing the second contract the claimant ceased to be a Ministry employee, so the Permanent Secretary's redeployment was null and void; under s.54(1) of the Water Act the Board appoints the CEO. No disciplinary process was undertaken and no s.44 Employment Act gross misconduct was established, so summary dismissal was not proved. The Respondent, having approved the leave and stopped salary and taken no corrective action, was responsible for the wrongful dismissal. The counterclaim for mileage allowance and notice pay failed. The court awarded Kshs. 5,317,350/= less statutory deductions, comprising pro rata gratuity for 17 months, three months' notice pay, unpaid salary for February to April 2010, six months' compensation, and unpaid leave allowance, ordered a certificate of service, and awarded the Claimant costs.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the claimant's services were unlawfully terminated by the Respondent

Holding

Yes. The purported redeployment by the Permanent Secretary was null and void because the claimant had ceased to be a Ministry employee and was the Respondent's employee under a contract renewable only with ministerial concurrence; no disciplinary process was undertaken and no gross misconduct was established.

Reasoning

The court traced the claimant's employment history: secondment from the Ministry in 2005, then election to remain with the Respondent on a fresh three-year contract from 1st December 2008. Under s.54(1) of the Water Act, the Board appoints the CEO. The Permanent Secretary had no power to redeploy him. No disciplinary action was initiated by the Board, and none of the s.44 Employment Act gross misconduct grounds were established, so summary dismissal was not proved.

p. 4
02

Who was responsible for the unlawful termination

Holding

The Respondent, which approved the claimant's leave, stopped his salary and took no steps to correct the Ministry's action.

Reasoning

Although the redeployment letter originated from the Ministry, the Respondent was the claimant's employer. It approved his 51 days' leave yet stopped paying his salary on departure, and its Board, which had hired him, took no action to correct the anomaly when the claimant complained. This passivity made the Respondent liable for the wrongful dismissal.

p. 5
03

What remedies the claimant is entitled to

Holding

Pro rata gratuity for 17 months, three months' salary in lieu of notice, unpaid salary for February–April 2010, six months' compensation for unlawful termination, unpaid leave allowance, certificate of service and costs.

Reasoning

The court declined to award the full 22 months' salary claimed to the end of the contract. Instead it computed the contractual gratuity on a pro rata basis for the period served, applied the contractual three-month notice clause, awarded salary actually worked but unpaid, and exercised discretion to award six months' salary as compensation for unlawful termination, plus the unpaid leave allowance, less statutory deductions.

p. 6
04

The Respondent's counterclaim for mileage allowance and notice pay

Holding

Dismissed, because the claimant remained the Respondent's employee in May 2010 when the mileage was paid.

Reasoning

Since the purported redeployment to the Ministry headquarters was a blatant disregard of the fact that the claimant's employer was the Respondent, the payment of mileage in May 2010 was made while the claimant was still in the Respondent's employment. The payment was therefore not erroneous and the Respondent could not claim it back, nor claim notice pay.

p. 5

Legal principles established

#
  • Where an employee has opted to remain in a board's substantive employment under a renewed contract, redeployment by the former ministry is null and void; under s.54(1) of the Water Act the CEO of a Water Services Board is appointed by the Board, whose terms are determined by the Board
  • Summary dismissal requires establishment of gross misconduct under s.44 of the Employment Act; a mere redeployment does not amount to summary dismissal
  • An employer that approves an employee's leave and then stops paying salary, and takes no action to correct a third party's wrongful interference, is responsible for the wrongful dismissal

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Declaration that the termination of the claimant by the Respondent was unfair and wrongful
  2. 2.Gratuity on pro rata basis for 17 months under the last contract: Kshs. 1,607,350/= (17 x 31% of 305,000)
  3. 3.Three months' salary in lieu of notice: Kshs. 915,000/=
  4. 4.Salary for February, March and April 2010 worked but not paid: Kshs. 915,000/=
  5. 5.Six months' salary compensation for unlawful termination: Kshs. 1,830,000/=
  6. 6.Unpaid leave allowance of Kshs. 50,000/=
  7. 7.Grand total award of Kshs. 5,317,350/= less statutory deductions
  8. 8.Claimant to be issued with a certificate of service
  9. 9.Respondent to bear the costs of the case
  10. 10.Counterclaim dismissed

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Water ActSection 54(1)
  • Employment ActSection 44
Jurisdiction invoked
Employment and labour relations jurisdiction over the claim and counterclaim (statement of claim and memorandum of reply determined on pleadings by consent); Water Act s.54(1) and Employment Act considered

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "ENGINEER IDDI ALI MWASINA V COAST WATER SERVICES BOARD [2012] KEELRC 112 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2012). Cause No 1332 of 2011. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelrc/2012/112/eng@2012-10-23

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.