Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCDismissed· [2024] KEELC 6441 (KLR)

Board of Directors New Victory School & 15 others v Ndegwa; Chief Land Registrar (Interested Party) (Environment and Land Case Civil Suit 119 of 2019) [2024] KEELC 6441 (KLR)

Environment and Land Court of Kenya
30 September 2024
3,770 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~15 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Environment and Land Court refused a defendant permission to file evidence five years late, warning that procedural deadlines must be respected.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This first-instance ruling of the Environment and Land Court, delivered by Oguttu Mboya J on 30 September 2024, disposed of a four-pronged oral application made by the Defendant immediately after the close of the Plaintiffs' case. The Defendant, who had entered appearance and filed a statement of defence but never a witness statement, sought: (i) leave to file and serve a witness statement; (ii) liberty to adopt a replying affidavit previously filed in a disposed-of interlocutory application as its witness statement; (iii) liberty to tender and produce documents already on record despite the absence of a witness statement; and (iv) in effect, the court's equitable discretion excusing these defaults. Counsel for the Plaintiffs and the Interested Party (the Attorney-General's office, per Deputy Chief Litigation Counsel C.N. Menge) opposed, arguing prejudice, dilatoriness since 2019, and that a replying affidavit cannot morph into a witness statement. Framing four issues, the court held that the Defendant failed to comply with Order 7 Rule 5 and Order 11 Rule 3 of the Civil Procedure Rules, offered no plausible explanation, and that the application was an afterthought calculated to plug gaps in the defence - a fishing expedition and litigation by instalment that would negate the Plaintiffs' right to a fair hearing. Relying on the Court of Appeal's decision in Nicholas Kiptoo Arap Korir Salat v IEBC and Said Sweilem Gheithan Saanum v Commissioner of Lands, the court held that Article 159(2)(b) and the overriding objective do not excuse non-compliance with rules. The application was dismissed in its entirety, with costs reserved to abide the outcome of the suit.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether leave to file a witness statement should be granted at the close of the Plaintiffs' case

Holding

Leave refused; the Defendant had failed to file the witness statement within the timelines in Order 7 Rule 5 and Order 11 Rule 3 of the Civil Procedure Rules and gave no plausible explanation for the delay since 2019.

Reasoning

The Defendant was obliged under Order 7 Rule 5 to file a witness statement within fourteen days of entering appearance and could have done so before the trial conference under Order 11 Rule 3, yet filed none and confirmed compliance at the case conference. The application was raised only after the Plaintiffs closed their case, with unreasonable and inordinate delay, and was designed to plug gaps in the defence using evidence obtained from the Plaintiffs - a fishing expedition and litigation by instalment that would prejudice the Plaintiffs and negate fair hearing.

p. 5
02

Whether a replying affidavit from a disposed-of interlocutory application can serve as a witness statement

Holding

No; the replying affidavit served its purpose in the interlocutory application and cannot revert to or be constituted as a witness statement.

Reasoning

The replying affidavit was not among the documents discovered by the Defendant and was filed in opposition to an interlocutory application that was heard and determined, rendering it redundant. Allowing reliance on it would distort the level playing field and prejudice the diligent Plaintiffs. The court declined to bend the rules to serve a party that declined to follow the law, holding that the consequences of the Defendant's or its agents' default should fall on the Defendant.

p. 5
03

Whether documents filed without a witness statement can be produced in evidence

Holding

No; the witness statement is the forerunner and foundation of the documents and a witness who has not filed a witness statement cannot tender documents in evidence.

Reasoning

It is the witness statement that references the documents, laying the foundation for their production; it is like the horse that pulls the wagon. Permitting production of documents without a witness statement would defeat the rules of procedure and the overriding objective under Sections 1A and 1B of the Civil Procedure Act. The court thus rejected the Defendant's alternative prayer to tender its documents.

p. 6
04

Whether the Defendant accounted for the failure to file the witness statement

Holding

No; the Defendant did not merit the exercise of equitable discretion, having waited five years since the suit was lodged in 2019.

Reasoning

The application sought equitable discretion, and one who seeks to partake of the court's discretion must account for the delay with candour. The Defendant could not wait five years before seeking indulgence; the conduct was intended to obstruct and delay the expeditious disposal of the suit, contrary to Article 159(2)(b) of the Constitution and Sections 1A and 1B of the Civil Procedure Act, and the mistake of counsel could not be disclaimed by the Defendant.

p. 6

Legal principles established

#
  • A party seeking equitable indulgence of the court must account for the delay and offer a candid explanation for the default; mistakes of counsel may be visited upon the litigant.
  • Article 159 of the Constitution and the oxygen principles do not permit courts to bend rules of procedure to aid non-compliant parties at the expense of diligent litigants.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The multi-pronged application by and on behalf of the Defendant (for leave to file a witness statement, to adopt the replying affidavit as a witness statement, and to produce documents without a witness statement) be and is hereby dismissed.
  2. 2.The costs attendant to and arising from the application shall abide the outcome of the suit.

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Civil Procedure Rules 2010Order 7 Rule 5
  • Civil Procedure Rules 2010Order 11 Rule 3
  • Civil Procedure ActSections 1A and 1B
  • Civil Procedure Act, Chapter 21, Laws of KenyaSections 1A and 1B
  • Constitution of KenyaArticle 159
  • Constitution of KenyaArticle 159 2(b)

Cases cited (3)

  • Nicholas Kiptoo Arap Korir Salat v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 6 Others
    [2013] eKLR
  • Said Sweilem Gheithan Saanum v Commissioner Of Lands (being sued through Attorney General) & 5 others
    [2015] eKLR
  • Ketterman v Hansel Properties Ltd
    (1988) 4 All ER 769
Jurisdiction invoked
Original civil jurisdiction under the Civil Procedure Act (Cap 21) and Civil Procedure Rules 2010; the court exercises equitable discretion guided by Sections 1A and 1B of the Civil Procedure Act and Article 159(2)(b) of the Constitution

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Board of Directors New Victory School & 15 others v Ndegwa; Chief Land Registrar (Interested Party) (Environment and Land Case Civil Suit 119 of 2019) [2024] KEELC 6441 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2024). . Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2024/6441/eng@2024-09-30

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.