Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCDismissedNyahururu ELC Appeal ( memorandum of appeal dated 15.05.2023; from Nyahururu CM ELC No. 358 of 2018)· [2024] KEELC 5422 (KLR)

Kimani (Sued as the legal representative of the Estate of Stephen Kimani Gakenia) v Murage & another (Environment and Land Appeal 3 of 2023) [2024] KEELC 5422 (KLR)

Environment and Land Court
18 July 2024
3,746 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~15 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

The Environment and Land Court dismissed a landowner's appeal because he presented no evidence at trial and raised new claims only on appeal.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This is a first appeal from the judgment of Hon. S. O. Mogute (SPM) in Nyahururu CM ELC No. 358 of 2018, which allowed the 1st Respondent's claim to Plot No. UNS Comm. Plot No. Y45 – Ol Kalou Town. The 1st Respondent had pleaded purchase of the plot in 2005 for Kshs. 350,000 through the 2nd Respondent as agent of Priscilla Bochere Ogendi, transfer into his name by the defunct Ol Kalou Town Council, and subsequent possession and development. The Appellant, the legal representative of the deceased Stephen Kimani Gakenia, claimed the deceased had bought the plot in 1994, that his documents were lost in 1997 violence, and alleged fraud. At trial the Appellant tendered no defence evidence after his advocate missed the defence hearing, and judgment was entered as prayed. Y. M. Angima J, in the Environment and Land Court at Nyandarua, framed three issues: whether the 1st Respondent proved his claim, whether the Appellant was entitled to the reliefs sought on appeal, and costs. Applying the settled principles governing a first appellate court (Selle, Peters, Watt, Kapsiran Clan), the court re-evaluated the evidence and found no fault with the trial court's concurrent findings that the claim was proved on a balance of probabilities. The complaint of violation of the right to a fair hearing was rejected as mischievous and fanciful, there having been no adjournment request, application to re-open the case, or review. The substantive reliefs sought on appeal were untenable for want of pleadings, no counterclaim having been filed. The appeal was dismissed in its entirety with costs to the 1st Respondent.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the 1st Respondent proved his ownership claim to the suit property

Holding

Yes; the Appellant tendered no defence evidence, and the concurrent findings of the trial court were supported by credible evidence of purchase, transfer by the Council, possession, development and payment of rates

Reasoning

The trial court did not decide merely because the Appellant did not testify; it evaluated the evidence of the Plaintiff and 1st Defendant. On its own re-evaluation, the first appellate court found adequate evidence of purchase through the agent, transfer into the 1st Respondent's name, possession, development and payment of rates without objection by the deceased, proving the claim on a balance of probabilities.

p. 6
02

Whether the Appellant's right to a fair hearing was violated when his advocate missed the defence hearing

Holding

No; the Appellant was present, the court adjourned to await the advocate, no adjournment or application to re-open the case was made, and the complaint was raised only after judgment

Reasoning

The record showed the advocate was absent on 20.12.2022 though the Appellant was present; the court awaited the advocate until 12.10 p.m. There was no application to re-open the case or for review, and no explanation for the absence. The constitutional complaint of violation of Articles 47 and 50 was therefore mischievous and fanciful.

p. 7
03

Whether the Appellant was entitled to the substantive reliefs sought in the appeal

Holding

No; those reliefs (declarations, rectification, injunction) were not pleaded before the trial court and could only have been sought through a counterclaim

Reasoning

The Appellant sought declarations that the transfer was void, rectification of records in favour of the deceased, and a permanent injunction. None of these were pleaded or canvassed at trial, and a party cannot obtain relief not based on pleadings. Lacking a counterclaim, the reliefs were untenable.

p. 7
04

Costs of the appeal

Holding

Costs follow the event; the successful 1st Respondent was awarded costs

Reasoning

Under the proviso to Section 27 of the Civil Procedure Act, the general rule is that costs follow the event, and a successful party should ordinarily be awarded costs unless the court, for good reason, directs otherwise. No good reason was found to depart from that rule.

p. 7

Legal principles established

#
  • A first appellate court must reconsider and re-evaluate the entire evidence and draw its own conclusions, while making due allowance for the trial court's advantage of seeing and hearing the witnesses.
  • Pleadings that are not supported by tendered evidence cannot found a case; untested defence averments remain unsubstantiated.
  • A party alleging violation of the right to be heard must show that it sought an adjournment, an opportunity to re-open its case, or review; a party cannot simply wait for judgment and then complain.
  • Costs follow the event under the proviso to Section 27 of the Civil Procedure Act unless the court, for good reason, directs otherwise.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The appeal be and is hereby dismissed in its entirety.
  2. 2.The 1st Respondent is hereby awarded costs of the appeal.

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of KenyaArticles 47 and 50
  • Fair Administrative Action ActSection 4
  • Limitation of Actions ActCap. 22
  • Civil Procedure ActSection 27 (proviso), Cap. 21

Cases cited (5)

  • Selle & Another –vs- Associated Motor Boat Co. Ltd & Others
    [1968] EA 123
  • Peters –vs- Sunday Post Ltd
    [1958] EA 424
  • Watt –vs- Thomas
    [1947] A.C. 424
  • Kapsiran Clan -vs- Kasagur Clan
    [2018] eKLR
  • Hussein Janmohamed & Sons –vs- Twentsche Overseas Trading Co. Ltd
    [1967] EA 287
On appeal from
Chief Magistrate's Court, Nyahururu
Nyahururu CM ELC No. 358 of 2018
Jurisdiction invoked
First appellate jurisdiction over the Environment and Land Court appeal from the magistrates' court

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Kimani (Sued as the legal representative of the Estate of Stephen Kimani Gakenia) v Murage & another (Environment and Land Appeal 3 of 2023) [2024] KEELC 5422 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2024). Nyahururu ELC Appeal ( memorandum of appeal dated 15.05.2023; from Nyahururu CM ELC No. 358 of 2018). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2024/5422/eng@2024-07-18

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.