Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCPartially AllowedPetition dated 18th January 2023 (Application dated 19th June 2023)· [2024] KEELC 4133 (KLR)

Legal Advice Centre t/a Kituo Cha Sheria v National Environment Management Authority & 5 others (Petition E002 of 2023) [2024] KEELC 4133 (KLR)

Environment and Land Court
9 May 2024
4,003 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~16 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

The Environment and Land Court in Malindi lifted its stay and directed that the constitutional challenge over the export of Kilifi's baobab trees proceed to full hearing without delay.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This is a ruling on a review application by the petitioner, who had filed a constitutional petition on 18th January 2023 challenging the uprooting, translocation and exportation of baobab trees from Kilifi County to Georgia. On 18th May 2023 the Court, upholding a preliminary objection, dismissed the motion, collapsed all licensing-related aspects in favour of pending National Environment Tribunal proceedings (NET 45 of 2022, Omar Salim Mwakweli and Others v NEMA and Georgy Gvasaliya), stayed the constitutional violation claims pending that determination, and ordered each party to bear its own costs, applying the Kibos doctrine on exhaustion of multifaceted claims. The petitioner then applied for review, arguing that the eight baobab trees had been exported in August 2023 and that the NET lacked jurisdiction over constitutional issues. The respondents opposed, contending the Court was functus officio and the Kibos decision remained binding. Taking judicial notice of the Supreme Court's decision of 28th December 2023 in Nicholus v Attorney General, which clarified that constitutional environmental violations fall within the ELC's jurisdiction and that exhaustion must be applied flexibly, and noting that the trees had already been shipped abroad, the Court held there was nothing barring it from determining the constitutional claims. It allowed the application in part, directing that the petition proceed to full hearing on the constitutional issues without further delay, with costs in the cause. E. K. Makori, Judge, delivered the ruling at Malindi virtually on 9th May 2024.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the Court's orders of 18th May 2023 staying the constitutional claims pending NET 45 of 2022 should be revisited

Holding

The stay is lifted and the petition proceeds to full trial on the constitutional issues, because the eight baobab trees have been exported and the Supreme Court's Nicholus decision has recast the exhaustion doctrine.

Reasoning

The Court noted that its earlier ruling, applying the Kibos doctrine, had reserved the dominant licensing issue to NET and stayed the constitutional claims. But the trees were shipped to Georgia, shifting the substratum of the petition, and the Supreme Court's 28th December 2023 judgment in Nicholus gave fresh guidance on exhaustion in multifaceted claims, holding that constitutional violations belong before the ELC. Had that guidance existed earlier, the ruling would have been different; the constitutional claims still stand and warrant full trial.

p. 9
02

Grounds for review under Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 of the Civil Procedure Rules

Holding

The Court acknowledged the three statutory grounds for review (new and important matter, error apparent on the face of the record, sufficient reason) but found the application, while allowed, was unnecessary in form.

Reasoning

The Court restated that review lies on discovery of new and vital evidence, apparent error, or sufficient reason, and that sufficient reason is not exhaustive. It considered the authorities cited by both sides, including National Bank of Kenya v Ndungu Njau and Zablon Mokua, and took judicial notice of the Supreme Court's recent Nicholus decision as new and significant legal guidance. However, it observed that given the changed facts, a simple direction to proceed would have sufficed rather than a formal review application.

p. 5

Legal principles established

#
  • Where the subject matter of a reserved/licensing issue has been overtaken by events, there is nothing to bar the Court from proceeding with the constitutional issues.
  • The doctrine of exhaustion must be applied on a case-to-case basis to avoid hardship where the primary adjudicative forum is ineffective or its determination overtaken by events.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The application dated 19th June 2023 is allowed to the extent that the petition proceeds to a full hearing before the Court on the constitutional issues raised by the petitioner without further delay
  2. 2.Costs in the cause

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Articles 1, 10, 11, 42, 43, 50, 60, 69, 70(1)
  • Environmental Management and Coordination Act, 1999Sections 50, 51, 53, 129
  • Civil Procedure ActSection 80
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 45
  • Energy ActSections 25, 106

Cases cited (12)

  • Nicholus v Attorney General & 7 others; National Environmental Complaints Committee & 5 others (Interested Parties) (Petition E007 of 2023)
    [2023] KESC 113 (KLR) (28 December 2023)
  • National Bank of Kenya v Ndungu Njau
    [1997] eKLR
  • Shanzu Investment Limited v Commissioner for Land
    [1993] eKLR
  • Raila Odinga & others v Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission & 3 others
    [2013] eKLR
  • Zablon Mokua v Solomon M. Choti & 3 others
    [2016] eKLR
  • Serengeti Road Services v CRBD Bank Limited
    [2011] 2 EA 395
  • Benjoh Amalgamated Limited & Another v Kenya Commercial Bank Limited
  • Kibos Case (Kibos Sugar factories and others v Attorney General and others)
  • Benson Ambuti Case
  • Railroad Commission of Texas v Pullman Co.
    312 U.S. 496 61 S. Ct. 643, 85 L. Ed. 971 (1941)
  • England v Louisiana State Board of Medical Examiners
    375 U.S. 411 (1964)
  • NET 45 of 2022 Omar Salim Mwakweli and Others v NEMA and Georgy Gvasaliya
Jurisdiction invoked
Articles 42, 70(1) of the Constitution (enforcement of environmental rights); Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 of the Civil Procedure Rules (review)

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Legal Advice Centre t/a Kituo Cha Sheria v National Environment Management Authority & 5 others (Petition E002 of 2023) [2024] KEELC 4133 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2024). Petition dated 18th January 2023 (Application dated 19th June 2023). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2024/4133/eng@2024-05-09

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.