Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCDismissedPetition dated 11/9/2023 (number not stated in the judgment)· [2024] KEELC 85 (KLR)

Sunlodges Kenya Limited (Suing on its Own Behalf and on Behalf of the Residents of Ukunda Area, Kwale County) v Alliance Developments Limited t/a Safari Beach Hotel & 2 others (Environment & Land Petition E001 of 2023) [2024] KEELC 85 (KLR)

Environment and Land Court
24 January 2024
4,870 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~19 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Environment and Land Court confirmed it can hear environmental rights cases directly, even when a NEMA licence dispute could go to a tribunal first.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This ruling of the Environment and Land Court determines a preliminary objection raised by the 1st Respondent, the operator of Safari Beach Hotel in Diani, against a petition by the operator of Ocean Village Club dated 11/9/2023. The objection contended that the court lacked first-instance jurisdiction because section 129 of EMCA requires disputes over NEMA licences to go to the National Environment Tribunal; that the petition offended the doctrine of exhaustion under Article 159(2)(c) of the Constitution; and that the Petitioner lacked locus standi under a management agreement clause restricting suits in the owner's name. The 1st Respondent urged dismissal with costs. The Petitioner argued it was challenging NEMA's failure to conduct environmental audit and monitoring rather than a licensing decision, that section 13 of the ELC Act confers exclusive first-instance jurisdiction over environmental-rights claims, and that Articles 22 and 258 confer standing. The court, applying Mukisa Biscuit through Oraro v Mbaja, held the jurisdictional objection was a pure point of law properly raised. On the merits it accepted that, given paragraph 36 of the petition, the Petitioner complains of the grant of a licence, so section 129(1)(a) applies and parties are bound by their pleadings. However, the petition presents a mixture of issues - including infringement of the right to a clean and healthy environment under Articles 40, 42 and 43 - which the NET has no mandate to determine, and permanent injunctions it cannot issue. Relying on the Supreme Court's decision in Abidha Nicholus and Taib Investment Ltd, the court found the issues cannot be severed, so the ELC must hear the whole petition. On locus standi, Article 70 and section 3(3) of EMCA remove any requirement to demonstrate loss, and the Petitioner could sue on behalf of Diani residents. The preliminary objection was dismissed with costs to the Petitioner.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the court has original jurisdiction over the petition notwithstanding section 129 of EMCA establishing appeals to the NET

Holding

Section 129(1)(a) of EMCA applies because the Petitioner's pleadings complain of the issuance of a licence, so the NET would ordinarily be the first port of call; however, the petition also raises constitutional environmental-rights claims and prayers the NET cannot grant, and the issues cannot be severed, so the ELC has jurisdiction over the whole petition

Reasoning

The court found the Petitioner, by paragraph 36 of the petition, complains of the grant of a licence, so section 129(1)(a) was triggered and parties are bound by their pleadings. But the petition mixes constitutional claims (Articles 40, 42, 43) with claims the NET cannot entertain; the NET cannot enforce Bill of Rights violations or issue permanent injunctions, whereas section 13(7) of the ELC Act allows this court to grant all such reliefs. Following the Supreme Court in Abidha Nicholus and Taib Investment, the inseverable issues must all go to the ELC.

p. 9
02

Whether the preliminary objection on jurisdiction is a pure point of law

Holding

Yes - the objection questioning the court's jurisdiction is a pure point of law and was properly raised

Reasoning

Applying Oraro v Mbaja adopting Mukisa Biscuit, the court held that a preliminary objection must be a point of law not blurred with contested facts. Since the objection challenged the court's jurisdiction under sections 125 and 129 of EMCA and section 13 of the ELC Act, it was purely a question of law and properly before the court on the merits.

p. 4
03

Whether the Petitioner has locus standi

Holding

The Petitioner has locus standi; under Article 70 of the Constitution and section 3(3) of EMCA no proof of loss or injury is required and one may sue on behalf of a group or in the public interest

Reasoning

The court held lack of locus standi is distinct from lack of jurisdiction. Article 70(3) removes the requirement to demonstrate loss, and section 3(3) of EMCA permits a person to apply on his own behalf, on behalf of a group or class of persons, or in the public interest. Even if the hotel owner had not consented to the suit, the Petitioner could properly bring the petition on behalf of the residents of Diani.

p. 10

Legal principles established

#
  • Redress for constitutional violations of environmental rights is not part of the NET's mandate under EMCA; the right to a clean and healthy environment can only be determined before the Environment and Land Court
  • Where a petition raises environmental and developmental issues that cannot be dealt with separately by various tribunals or bodies, only the ELC can deal with all those issues
  • Under Article 70 of the Constitution and section 3(3) of EMCA, an applicant enforcing environmental rights need not demonstrate loss or injury, and may sue on his own behalf or on behalf of others
  • Lack of locus standi does not necessarily mean lack of jurisdiction
  • Where an Act of Parliament provides a clear procedure or mechanism of redress, the same ought to be strictly followed (doctrine of exhaustion)

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The 1st Respondent's preliminary objection is dismissed with costs to the Petitioner

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Environmental Management and Coordination Act, No 8 of 1999section 129
  • Environmental Management and Coordination Act, No 8 of 1999section 125
  • Environmental Management and Coordination Act, No 8 of 1999sections 3(3), 7, 101, 102, 108, 117
  • Constitution of KenyaArticles 22, 42, 69, 70, 159(2)(c), 162(2)(b), 165(1)(c), 165(2)(b), 165(5)(b), 258
  • Environment and Land Court Actsections 13(1), 13(2), 13(7)
  • Environment Management and Coordination (Noise and Excessive Vibration Pollution Control) Regulations 2009Regulation 18
  • Physical Planning and Land Use Actdevelopment permission provisions

Cases cited (14)

  • Wakenya Pamoja Sacco v Stephen Ogamba
    Kisii HCCC No 8 of 2008
  • Robert Khamala Situma & 8 Others v Acting Clerk of the Nairobi City County Assembly
    [2022] eKLR
  • Geoffrey Muthinja Kabiru & 2 Others v Samuel Munga Henry & 1756 Others
    [2015] eKLR
  • Joseph Ojwang Oundo v National Environmental Management Authority & 8 Others
    [2015] eKLR
  • Agatha Jeruto Kimaswai v Attorney General & 3 Others
    [2021] eKLR
  • Taib Investment Ltd v Fahim Salim Said & 5 Others
    [2016] eKLR
  • Oraro v Mbaja
    [2005] 1 KLR 141 (Civil Suit No 85 of 1992)
  • Mukisa Biscuit v West End Distributors
    (1969) EA 696
  • Public Service Commission & 2 others v Eric Cheruiyot & 16 others consolidated with County Government of Embu & Another v Eric Cheruiyot & 15 others
    Nakuru Civil Appeal No 119 of 2017 consolidated with Civil Appeal No 139 of 2017 (unreported)
  • The Speaker of the National Assembly v Hon. James Njenga Karume
    Civil Application No Nai 92 of 1992
  • Samson Chembe Vuko v Nelson Kilumo & 2 others
    [2016] eKLR
  • Abidha Nicholus v The Attorney General & 7 Others
    SC Petition No E007 of 2023
  • Law Society of Kenya v Commissioner of Lands & Others
    Nakuru High Court Civil Case No 464 of 2000
  • Alfred Njau and Others v City Council of Nairobi
    [1982] KAR 229
Jurisdiction invoked
Section 13 of the Environment and Land Court Act and Articles 42, 70, 162(2)(b) and 165 of the Constitution of Kenya 2010

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Sunlodges Kenya Limited (Suing on its Own Behalf and on Behalf of the Residents of Ukunda Area, Kwale County) v Alliance Developments Limited t/a Safari Beach Hotel & 2 others (Environment & Land Petition E001 of 2023) [2024] KEELC 85 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2024). Petition dated 11/9/2023 (number not stated in the judgment). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2024/85/eng@2024-01-24

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.