Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCAllowedEnvironment and Land Appeal 1 of 2023· [2023] KEELC 21756 (KLR)

Jamlick Mutugi Mate v Peter Gitonga

Environment and Land Court
22 November 2023
2,913 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~12 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Environment and Land Court ruled that a res judicata objection based on disputed facts cannot end a land case before a full hearing.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The appellant appealed against a ruling of Hon. E.M Ayuka in Nkubu CM ELC No. E032 of 2021 upholding a preliminary objection that his trespass and malicious damage suit over L.R. No. Nkuene/Mitunguu/1116 and 1659 was res judicata, given a prior suit (PMCC No. 5 of 2015) between the respondent and the appellant's father. The appellant also complained that the trial court wrongly held his written submissions had not been filed. As a first appellate court, Nzili J rehearsed the pleadings and the parties' submissions. The court held that the res judicata plea, as raised, depended on contested facts and evidence - the respondent relied on his list of documents - and was therefore not a pure point of law; the trial court should have deferred it to the merits or required a formal notice of motion with pleadings annexed. The court further found the trespass events of 2.1.2021 and 12.5.2021 and the encroachment overlap between the two parcels had not been previously litigated, so the matters were not identical. On the submissions issue, the court found the appellant's submissions were filed after the 3.12.2022 deadline and were never stamped and placed on the court file; emailing alone is insufficient, and a court is not obliged to consider written submissions, so the appellant was not condemned unheard. Allowing the appeal with costs, the court did not expressly set aside the ruling or remit the suit, leaving the precise disposition of the underlying suit open.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the res judicata plea was properly raised as a preliminary objection

Holding

No - the plea required determination of contested facts and evidence, so the trial court should have deferred it to the merits or required a formal notice of motion.

Reasoning

The respondent relied on his list of documents and contested facts to establish res judicata. A preliminary objection must be a pure point of law argued on assumed facts. Since the plea required probing into evidence on the identity of parties, title and issues, the trial court should have considered it with the merits or directed a notice of motion with pleadings annexed.

p. 5
02

Whether the matters in the former suit and the current suit were identical for res judicata

Holding

The trespass events of 2.1.2021 and 12.5.2021 on L.R. No. 1659 and the encroachment overlap had not been previously litigated.

Reasoning

The court found the issues of who encroached on which land and with what rights as at 2.1.2021 and 12.5.2021 were new issues not determined in the previous suit, undermining the identity of matters required for res judicata.

p. 5
03

Whether the appellant was condemned unheard due to non-consideration of written submissions

Holding

No - the appellant's submissions were filed late (after the 3.12.2022 deadline) and were not on the court file; a court is not obliged to consider written submissions.

Reasoning

The court found no stamped, duly paid filing of the submissions within the deadline. Emails alone are insufficient without follow-up to ensure receipt and stamping. Citing authority, the court held it is not mandatory for a court to consider written submissions, so there was no breach of the right to be heard.

p. 5

Legal principles established

#
  • A preliminary objection based on res judicata that requires the court to delve into evidence on contested facts is improperly raised and should not be upheld at the preliminary stage.
  • A preliminary objection must be a pure point of law, not based on disputed facts requiring evidence.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Appeal allowed with costs

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Civil Procedure ActSection 7
  • Civil Procedure ActSection 34
  • Land Registration ActSection 18
  • Constitution of KenyaArticle 159

Cases cited (20)

  • Abok James Odera t/a A.J Odera & Association v John Patrick Machira t/a Machira & Co Advocates
    (2013) eKLR

    First appellate court's duty to consider the record and make independent findings on facts and law.

  • Nancy Mwangi t/a Worthlin Marketers v Airtel Networks (K) Ltd
    (2014) eKLR

    Cited by appellant on identity requirements for res judicata.

  • Michael Gachoki Gacheru v Joseph Karobia Gicheru
    Kerugoya ELC No. 783 of 2013

    Cited by appellant on res judicata.

  • Bernard Mugo Ndegwa v James Nderitu Githe and others
    (2010) eKLR

    Cited by appellant on res judicata.

  • Kenyariri t/a Kenyariri & Associates Advocates v Salama Beach Hotel Ltd and 3 others
    (2017) eKLR

    Cited by respondent in support of res judicata plea.

  • C.K Bett Traders Ltd and others v Kennedy Mwangi & another
    Kajiado HCA No. 7 of 2020

    Cited by respondent in support of res judicata plea.

  • Ganatra v Ganatra
    (2007) 1 E.A 76

    Cited by respondent in support of res judicata plea.

  • Mukhisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd
    (1969) E.A 696

    Definition of a preliminary objection as a pure point of law argued on assumed facts.

  • IEBC v Maina Kiai
    (2017) eKLR

    Requirements for res judicata: identity of matter, sameness of title, concurrence of jurisdiction and finality.

  • E.T. v A.G. & others
    (2012) eKLR

    Parties cannot evade res judicata by cosmetic changes such as adding parties or causes of action.

  • James Njuguna Chui v John Kimani
    (2017) eKLR

    Doctrine of res judicata stops vexatious relitigation.

  • Siri Ram Kaura v M.J.E Morgan
    (1961) E.A 462

    A party cannot raise in subsequent proceedings a ground open to him in former proceedings; fresh evidence is no answer to res judicata.

  • John Florence Maritime Services Ltd & 7 others v Cabinet Secretary for Transport and Infrastructure and 3 others
    (2015) eKLR

    Res judicata rests on public interest in finality of litigation and economical use of court resources.

  • Kenya Power & Lighting Company v Ringera & 2 others
    (2022) KECA 104 (KLR)

    Trespass may be continuous.

  • Margaret Njeri Gitau v Julius Mburu Gitau & 2 others
    (2022) eKLR

    Cited Oraro v Mbaja with approval on the nature of preliminary objections.

  • Oraro v Mbaja
    (2005) 1 KLR 141

    A preliminary objection must not deal with disputed facts or derive from factual information to be tested by evidence.

  • Henry Khaemba v Standard Chartered Bank and another
    (2014) eKLR

    A preliminary objection on res judicata may require probing through evidence.

  • George Kamau Kimani & others v County Government of Transnzoia & others
    (2014) eKLR

    Best way to raise res judicata is by notice of motion with pleadings annexed.

  • Daniel Toroitich Arap Moi v Mwangi Stephen Murithi and another
    (2014) eKLR

    It is not a must that a court considers written submissions.

  • Imperial Bank Ltd v Bakari Juma Bech Pende
    (2016) eKLR

    It is not a must that a court considers written submissions.

On appeal from
Chief Magistrate's Court at Nkubu
Nkubu CM ELC No. E032 of 2021
Jurisdiction invoked
First appellate jurisdiction over appeals from subordinate courts in environment and land matters

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Jamlick Mutugi Mate v Peter Gitonga", Case Analysis (2023). Environment and Land Appeal 1 of 2023. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2023/21756/eng@2023-11-22

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.