Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCPartially AllowedEnvironment & Land Case 371 of 2019· [2023] KEELC 19806 (KLR)

Alton Homes Limited & another v Chelegoi & 4 others

Environment and Land Court of Kenya
30 August 2023
11,047 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~44 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan court found a property transfer fraudulent but refused to force the sale, because the buyer hadn't completed all its own payment obligations.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Plaintiffs sued over L.R. Nairobi Block 26/113, alleging the 1st Defendant breached three successive sale agreements (27 February 2007, 3 May 2009 and 4 August 2009), fraudulently transferred the property to the 2nd Defendant, and that the 2nd and 3rd Defendants unlawfully evicted them and seized chattels. They sought cancellation of the transfer, specific performance, injunctions and damages. The 4th Defendant (a 2014 auction purchaser from the Third Party) counterclaimed for declarations of good title and damages for unlawful eviction; the 5th Defendant and Third Party (chargees) defended their charges. The court found the 2nd Plaintiff occupied as purchaser, not tenant; that the 1st Defendant breached the 4 August 2009 agreement by demanding sums not provided for and failing to complete; that the transfer to the 2nd Defendant was fraudulent; but that the Third Party's charge, the 5th Defendant's charge and the transfer to the 4th Defendant were valid, the chargees and purchaser having acted without notice of any dispute. Specific performance was refused because the 1st Plaintiff had not performed all its obligations. The court granted prayers (a), (g), (i) and (j) of the plaint, dismissed the 2nd Defendant's counterclaim (no evidence called), allowed prayers (a), (b) and (d) of the 4th Defendant's counterclaim and awarded him Kshs 2,000,000 general damages for unlawful eviction. The 1st to 3rd Defendants were ordered to bear the costs of the suit and counterclaim.

Key legal issues

#
01

Status of the 2nd Plaintiff's occupation

Holding

The 2nd Plaintiff was a purchaser in occupation, not a tenant or licensee of the 1st or 2nd Defendant

Reasoning

The 1st Defendant gave vacant possession in anticipation of the sale and adduced no evidence of any tenancy or licence. The earlier ruling of 25th February 2011 had found nothing to substantiate the tenancy allegation. The court therefore found occupation was pursuant to the sale agreements, known to the 1st Defendant.

02

Breach of the sale agreements

Holding

The 1st Defendant, not the 1st Plaintiff, was in breach of the sale agreement dated 4th August 2009

Reasoning

The 1st Defendant only obtained title on 9th December 2009, outside the completion period, and the 1st Plaintiff's obligation to pay the balance of Kshs 2,000,000 was conditional on transfer. The 1st Defendant then demanded additional sums not provided for in the agreement, which the court could not imply into the contract.

p. 16
03

Fraudulent transfer to the 2nd Defendant

Holding

The transfer of the suit property to the 2nd Defendant was fraudulent

Reasoning

The green card showed the 1st Defendant obtained title on 9th December 2009 and transferred to the 2nd Defendant on 14th November 2010 while the property was occupied by the 2nd Plaintiff. No agreement, payment evidence or instrument of transfer was tendered for the transaction.

p. 17
04

Validity of the charges and transfer to the 4th Defendant

Holding

The charge by the Third Party and the 5th Defendant and the transfer to the 4th Defendant were valid

Reasoning

Evidence that the Third Party and 4th Defendant had no notice of any pending dispute or competing interest was uncontroverted. The statutory power of sale was exercised lawfully and in good faith, and the 4th Defendant was a bona fide purchaser for value without notice.

p. 18
05

Specific performance

Holding

Specific performance refused despite proof of breach and fraud against the 1st to 3rd Defendants

Reasoning

Specific performance is discretionary and requires the plaintiff to have performed all his obligations. The 1st Plaintiff had not paid the full purchase price, including the Kshs 2,000,000 balance, and an adequate alternative remedy in damages existed.

06

4th Defendant's counterclaim

Holding

The 4th Defendant proved unlawful eviction and was awarded general damages of Kshs 2,000,000

Reasoning

The uncontroverted evidence of DW2 showed the 4th Defendant was evicted without notice, paid rent of Kshs 75,000 from March 2019 to August 2021, and proved renovation costs and police assistance costs. Guided by comparable authorities, the court awarded Kshs 2,000,000.

p. 19

Legal principles established

#
  • A party alleging fraud must specifically plead the particulars of fraud and prove them on a higher standard than the balance of probabilities
  • No term should be implied in a contract unless it was intended by the parties
  • A plaintiff seeking specific performance must show performance of all terms he undertook to perform
  • A counterclaim is like a suit and must be proved to the required standard
  • Special damages must first be pleaded and then strictly proved
  • Costs follow the event under Section 27 of the Civil Procedure Act

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The counterclaim by the 2nd defendant is dismissed
  2. 2.Prayers (a), (g), (i) and (j) of the Plaint dated 27th April 2010 are granted
  3. 3.Prayers (a), (b) and (d) of the 4th Defendant's counterclaim dated 20th September 2021 are granted
  4. 4.The 4th Defendant is granted general damages for unlawful eviction of Ksh 2,000,000/-
  5. 5.The 1st, 2nd and 3rd defendants shall bear the costs of the suit and counterclaim

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Evidence Act, Cap 80Section 98
  • Civil Procedure Act, Cap 21Section 27
  • Land Actgeneral (due diligence and statutory power of sale)

Cases cited (25)

  • Amina Abdul Kadir Hawa v Rabinder Nath Anand & Another
    (2012) eKLR

    Breach by vendor failing to deliver completion documents

  • Ayub Ndungi v Marion Waithera Gachera
    (2009) eKLR

    Rescission requires restitution of deposit; not possible where purchaser given possession and developed land

  • Mbugua Njuguna v Elijah Mburu & Another
    (2004) eKLR

    Specific performance

  • Hasamuddin Gulamhussein & others v Kidogi Basi Housing Cooperative
    (2009) eKLR

    Specific performance

  • Elijah Kipkorir Barmalel & Another v John Kiplagat Cherono & 3 Others
    (2010) eKLR

    Specific performance

  • Malhotna v Chavidhury
    (1979) 1 ALL ER 186

    Specific performance

  • Jose Estates Limited v Muthemu Farm Limited & 2 others
    (2019) eKLR

    Fraud must be pleaded and proved; bona fide purchaser

  • Central Bank of Kenya Limited v Trust Bank Limited & 40 Others
    (1996) eKLR

    Standard of proof of fraud

  • Katende v Haridar & Company Limited
    (2008) 2 E.A 173

    Bona fide purchaser for value without notice

  • Bruce Joseph Bockle v Coquers Limited
    (2014) eKLR

    Hardship in granting specific performance against a stranger to the transaction

  • Cieri Plains Company Limited & 2 others v Ecobank Kenya Limited
    (2017) eKLR

    Reliefs causing hardship to non-participating parties

  • George Njenga Kagai v Samwel Kabi Njoroge & Another
    (2019) eKLR

    Specific performance requires readiness and ability to complete

  • Biley Olouch Okun Onanda v Ayub Muthee Migweta & 2 others
    (2017)

    Considered by the court on specific performance

  • Larnet Leiyagu v Attorney General
    (2018) eKLR

    Kshs 1,500,000 awarded for unlawful eviction

  • Munaver Alibhai t/a Diani Gallery v South Coast Holdings Limited
    (2020) eKLR

    Kshs 2,000,000 general damages for unlawful eviction

  • Peter Mauki Kaijenga & 9 others v Chief of the Defence Forces & Another
    (2019) eKLR

    Aggravated and punitive damages

  • Godfrey Julias Ndemba Mbogori v Nairobi City Council
    (2007) eKLR

    Aggravated and punitive damages

  • Ken Odondi & 2 others v James Okoth Omburah t/a Okoth Omburah & Company Advocates
    (2013) eKLR

    Aggravated and punitive damages

  • Isaiah M'Mugambi M'Muketha v Attorney General & 2 others
    (2016) eKLR

    Aggravated and punitive damages

  • Moses Parantai & Peris Wanjiku Mukuru suing as the legal representatives of the estate of Sospeter Mukuru Mbeere (deceased) v Stephen Njoroge Macharia
    (2020) eKLR

    Notice of fraud must be proved against a purchaser/chargee

  • Gurder Singh Birdi & Marinder Singh Ghatora v Abubakar Madhubuti
    Civil Appeal No. 165 of 1996

    Plaintiff seeking specific performance must have performed all his obligations

  • Lulume v Coffee Marketing Board
    (1970) EA 155

    No term should be implied in a contract unless it was intended

  • Thrift Homes Ltd v Kenya Investment Ltd
    2015 eKLR

    Specific performance is discretionary and refused where adequate alternative remedy exists

  • Emfil Limited v Registrar of Titles Mombasa & 2 others
    Mombasa Civil Appeal No. 312 of 2012 [2014] eKLR

    Fraud must be strictly pleaded and proved on a higher standard than balance of probabilities

  • John Kamunya & another v John Nginyi Muchiri & 3 others
    [2015] eKLR

    Fraud must be strictly and specifically pleaded before a court can interrogate it

Jurisdiction invoked
Original civil jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court over the suit property L.R. Nairobi Block 26/113

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Alton Homes Limited & another v Chelegoi & 4 others", Case Analysis (2023). Environment & Land Case 371 of 2019. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2023/19806/eng@2023-08-30

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.