Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCPartially AllowedEnvironment & Land Case 364 of 2014· [2023] KEELC 19194 (KLR)

Ng'ang'a v Rioki Real Estate Co. (1970) Ltd

Environment and Land Court of Kenya
13 July 2023
14,205 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~57 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Nairobi court upheld a tenant's 2008 leases as genuine but found no breach, granting registration of the leases and a purchase option instead of damages.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Plaintiff, a long-standing tenant of the Defendant company on L.R. Nos. 13330/368 and 13330/369 Nairobi, sued to enforce two lease agreements both dated November 17, 2008, each for 30 years. He sought a nine months' notice and first option to purchase, a mandatory injunction compelling registration of the leases, and alternatively special damages of Kshs 43,649,425 for developments, plus loss of rental income of about Kshs 221.5 million and general damages for breach. The Defendant alleged the Plaintiff's leases were forged and altered, producing its own versions without the priority-to-purchase, compensation and subletting clauses, and argued the leases were unregistered, that consent orders and estoppel barred the notice claim, and that the expert reports were uncorroborated projections. The court framed four issues: validity of the leases, breach, entitlement to reliefs, and costs. Relying on the DCI forensic examination report admitted by consent and unchallenged by any counter expert report, the court found the Plaintiff's leases valid and binding, holding the Defendant failed to meet the heightened standard for proving fraud. However, on breach, it found the Defendant had in fact given the Plaintiff the nine months' notice and first option, and that the Plaintiff's offer was too low, so no breach was established. The suit partially succeeded: the court ordered the notice and first option at fair open market value fixed by a valuer, a mandatory injunction to register the leases within 30 days of decree, and, in the alternative, special damages of Kshs 43,649,425. Claims for loss of rental income, general damages and declarations of breach were denied, and each party was ordered to bear its own costs.

Key legal issues

#
01

Validity of the competing lease agreements

Holding

The lease agreements produced by the Plaintiff (pages 1-14 of the supplementary bundle) are the valid and binding agreements between the parties.

Reasoning

The Plaintiff produced a DCI forensic examination report by CI Alex Mwongera dated April 25, 2014, admitted by consent, which matched the signatures on the Plaintiff's leases to specimens supplied by the Defendant's directors. The Defendant produced no counter forensic report or other evidence to rebut it. Applying the rule that an expert report can only be challenged by a counter expert report, and given the heightened standard for proving fraud, the Defendant failed to discharge its evidentiary burden.

p. 22
02

Whether there was breach of the lease agreements

Holding

No breach by either party; the Plaintiff was given the nine months' notice and first option to purchase but made a low offer.

Reasoning

Although clause 3(c) required nine months' notice and first priority to the Plaintiff before sale, the court found on the evidence that the Defendant did give the Plaintiff the notice and first option, and made several offers, but the Plaintiff's offer of Kshs 30,000,000 was too low and he could not commit to the Defendant's counter-offers. The suit was filed to avert an intended sale, but no actual breach was proved.

p. 23
03

Entitlement to reliefs

Holding

Only enforcement-type reliefs were appropriate: notice/first option, mandatory injunction to register the leases, and, in the alternative, special damages for developments.

Reasoning

Having found the leases valid but no breach, the court held the only appropriate remedies were enforcement of the agreed terms. It granted the nine months' notice and first option at fair open market value fixed by a valuer, a mandatory injunction compelling registration of the leases, and, alternatively, the special damages of Kshs 43,649,425 per the unchallenged valuation report. Claims for loss of rental income and general damages failed with the finding of no breach.

p. 24

Legal principles established

#
  • An expert report can only be challenged through a counter expert report; unchallenged expert findings stand.
  • Allegations of fraud must be strictly proved to a standard above a mere balance of probabilities.
  • He who alleges must prove; the burden of proof lies on the person asserting the facts.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The Defendant to give the Plaintiff a nine months' notice of its intention to sell the suit properties and the first option to purchase L.R. No. 13330/368 and L.R. No. 13330/369 at a fair open market value, to be determined by a valuer appointed by the Registrar of Valuers Registration Board, at the Plaintiff's cost.
  2. 2.An order of mandatory injunction compelling the Defendant to register the two lease agreements both dated November 17, 2008 against the titles of the respective parcels of land, with evidence of registration to be provided within 30 days of service of the decree.
  3. 3.In the alternative to prayers (a) and (b), the Defendant to pay the Plaintiff special damages of Kshs 43,649,425.00 being the value of developments on the two plots.
  4. 4.Any other relief not expressly granted is denied.
  5. 5.Each party to bear own costs of the suit.

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Evidence ActSections 107(1), 107(2), 109, 112
  • Civil Procedure ActSection 27(1)
  • Land Registration ActSections 43, 46, 54(1)
  • Stamp Duty ActSections 2, 5(1)
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 40(1)

Cases cited (31)

  • Ali Mohammed Sunkar vs Diamond Trust Bank Ltd
    (2011) eKLR

    An expert report can only be challenged through a counter expert report.

  • John G Kamuyu & Another vs Safari 'M' Park Motors
    Nairobi ELC No. 1013 of 1999

    Quoted for the Sunkar proposition on challenging expert reports.

  • Care Mission Kenya & 4 others vs Benta Akinyi Otieno & 2 others
    (2021) eKLR

    Forensic report admitted by consent without calling the examiner; uncontradicted findings stand.

  • Jennifer Nyambura Kamau Vs Humphrey Nandi
    (2013) eKLR

    Fraud must be strictly proved; evidential burden under sections 107 and 109 of the Evidence Act.

  • Central Bank of Kenya Ltd vs Trust Bank Ltd & 4 Others
    NAI Civil Appeal No. 215 of 1996 (UR)

    Onus of prima facie proof of fraud is heavier than in an ordinary civil case.

  • Rosemary Wanjiku Murithi V George Mainda Ndinwa
    NYR Civil Appeal No. 9 of 2014 (2014) eKLR

    Raising fraud in a defence is not proof of fraud.

  • Rufale vs Union Manufacturing Co. (Ramsboltom)
    (1918) L.R. 1 KB 592

    Courts cannot imply terms not expressed in the contract.

  • Attorney General of Belize et al vs Belize Telecom Ltd & Another
    (2009) 1 WLR 1980

    The court does not make or improve a contract for the parties.

  • Trollope Colls Ltd vs North West Metropolitan Regional Hospital Board
    (1973) 1 WLR 601

    Clear express terms must be applied even if other terms seem more suitable.

  • Ngere Tea Factory Company Ltd vs Alice Wambui Ndome
    (2018) eKLR

    Courts enforce contracts; they cannot rewrite the parties' agreements.

  • Shah –Vs- Guiders International Bank Ltd
    (2003) KLR

    Parties are bound by contracts they willingly executed.

  • Samson Nzaro vs Bonface Ngari
    (2020) eKLR

    In the absence of a contrary valuation report, the court adopts the plaintiff's unchallenged valuation.

  • Dormakaba Limited vs Arcitectural Supplies Kenya Limited
    (Civil Suit 136 of 2020) (2021) KEHC 210 (KLR)

    Elements of a damages claim and the standard of proof of causation in contract.

  • Consolata Anyango Ouma vs South Nyanza Sugar Co. Ltd
    (2015) eKLR

    Measure of damages for breach of contract; special damages must be pleaded and proved (Hadley v Baxendale rule).

  • Orix Oil (Kenya Limited) –Vs- Paul Kabeu & 2 others
    (2014) eKLR

    Costs follow the event under section 27(1) Civil Procedure Act.

  • Republic –Vs- Rosemary Wairimu Munene, Exparte Applicant –Vs- Ihururu Dairy Farmers Co-operative Society Limited
    J.R. No. 6 of 2014

    Costs principles.

  • Party of independent candidate of Kenya –Vs- Mutula Kilonzo & 2 others
    HC EP No. 6 of 2013

    Costs principles.

  • Sifa International Limited & Another Vs- Koinange Investment Development & 3 others
    (2009) eKLR

    Ex turpi causa maxim - no court ought to enforce an illegal contract.

  • Serah Njeri Mwobi –vs- John Kimani Njoroge
    (2013) eKLR

    Doctrine of estoppel precludes a person from asserting something contrary to what is implied by previous action or statement.

  • SNI vs AOF
    (2020) eKLR

    Parties are bound by consent orders unless material facts were mistaken or misrepresented.

  • Flora N. Wasike vs Destinno Wamboko
    (1988) eKLR

    A consent judgment or order has contractual effect and can only be set aside on grounds justifying setting aside a contract.

  • J.M Mwakio V Kenya Commercial Bank Ltd
    CA No. 28 of 1982

    Cited within Wasike on the contractual effect of consent orders.

  • 748 Air Services Limited vs Theuri Munyi
    (2017) eKLR

    Waiver is an intentional relinquishment or abandonment of a known right or privilege.

  • Affordable Homes Africa Ltd vs Henderson & 2 others
    (2004) eKLR

    A company can only take decisions through the agency of its organs - board or general meeting.

  • Swalleh C. Kariuki & another vs Violet Owiso Okuyu
    (2021) eKLR

    Loss of earnings is special damage which must be pleaded and proved.

  • Douglas Kalafa Ombeva vs David Ngama
    (2013) eKLR

    Special damages must be pleaded and proved; court will not act in a vacuum.

  • David Njuguna Ngotho Versus Family Bank Limited & another
    (2018) eKLR

    Expert witnesses as 'paid agents'; duty of expert to furnish scientific criteria for testing conclusions.

  • Abringer V Ashton

    Expert witnesses termed 'paid agents'.

  • Choge & Others vs Republic
    (1985) eKLR

    Duty of an expert witness to furnish criteria enabling independent judgment.

  • Stephen Kinini Wang'ondu vs The Ark Limited
    (2016)

    Expert evidence should be tested against known facts; primary factual evidence is of greatest importance.

  • Hadley V Baxendale
    (1854) 9. Exch. 341

    Measure of damages arising naturally from breach or reasonably contemplated by the parties.

Jurisdiction invoked
Original civil jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court over disputes relating to land (Article 162(2)(b) Constitution / ELC Act)

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Ng'ang'a v Rioki Real Estate Co. (1970) Ltd", Case Analysis (2023). Environment & Land Case 364 of 2014. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2023/19194/eng@2023-07-13

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.