Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCPartially AllowedEnvironment and Land Appeal 2 of 2021· [2023] KEELC 17471 (KLR)

Muhendato v Dzilala

Environment and Land Court of Kenya
11 May 2023
4,786 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~19 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Environment and Land Court dismissed a family land trust claim because the claimant couldn't prove fraud or a customary trust with solid evidence.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This first appeal from the Principal Magistrate's Court at Kwale challenged a judgment declaring that the Appellant held plot Kwale/Ngombeni/897 in trust for himself and the Respondent's family, with compensation proceeds from the Dongo Kundu by-pass compulsory acquisition to be shared equally among the heirs of the family patriarch. The Appellant raised seven grounds, including res judicata, failure of proof of fraud, and absence of evidence of a customary trust. The ELC first held that the prior suit, Kwale PMCC No. 62 of 2014, having been dismissed for want of prosecution, was neither pending nor res judicata, following Michael Bett Siror v Jackson Koech. On the merits, applying Selle v Associated Motor Boat Co., the court re-evaluated the evidence. It found the Respondent failed to prove fraud to the elevated standard required: no adjudication records were produced, PW1's account of his father's exclusion was hearsay, and the Appellant's documentary trail showed a procedurally obtained title. Applying the Supreme Court's tests in Isack M'inanga Kiebia v Isaya Theuri M'Lintari, the court found no evidence that the land was family or clan land before registration, no clan arrangement as in Kiebia, and no corroboration of the trust claim; the green card trustee entry had to be read with the Kadhi's court order that excluded the Respondent. The appeal was allowed, the trial judgment set aside, and the Respondent's suit dismissed with no orders as to costs, the dispute being between relatives.

Key legal issues

#
01

Res judicata / sub judice where the prior suit was dismissed for want of prosecution

Holding

The suit was neither pending nor res judicata; a dismissal for want of prosecution is not a judgment on the merits

Reasoning

The trial court had found the elements of res judicata unproved. On appeal the court held a suit dismissed for want of prosecution cannot be regarded as pending for purposes of section 6 of the Civil Procedure Act, nor can its dismissal amount to a judgment, following Michael Bett Siror v Jackson Koech. The defendant's twin submissions that the suit was both pending and decided were contradictory.

p. 4
02

Whether fraud in the acquisition of the title was proved

Holding

Fraud was not proved; the green card showing the plaintiff's father was not registered did not by itself prove fraud

Reasoning

The burden lay on the plaintiff under section 107 of the Evidence Act, and fraud requires proof to a standard slightly above balance of probabilities. PW1 admitted he was in school during adjudication and never participated; his evidence on exclusion of his father was hearsay. No adjudication records were produced and the Kadhi's court summons were unrebutted. The Appellant's documentary trail showed a procedurally obtained title.

p. 6
03

Whether a customary trust was established over the suit property

Holding

No customary trust was proved; the trial court's finding that the land was family land by ancestry lacked evidentiary support

Reasoning

Applying the Supreme Court's Kiebia tests, the court found no evidence that the land was family or clan land before registration. The green card entry 'as trustee cause no.201/2014' had to be read with the Kadhi's court order which excluded the plaintiff. Unlike Kiebia, there was no clan agreement or arrangement at adjudication. The plaintiff called no corroborating witnesses, and the chief's letter was unrebutted.

p. 8

Legal principles established

#
  • A suit dismissed for want of prosecution is not decided on its merits and cannot found a plea of res judicata
  • A customary trust can only be found after evaluation of evidence against the Kiebia tests; not every claim of a right to land qualifies

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The appeal is upheld
  2. 2.The judgment of the trial court delivered on 20/01/2021 is set aside and replaced with an order dismissing the Respondent's suit
  3. 3.No orders as to costs, this being a dispute involving relatives

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Civil Procedure Actsection 6
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 17 Rule 2 (6)
  • Evidence Act (Cap 80)section 107
  • Registered Land Act (repealed)sections 27, 28 and 30
  • Land Registration Act 2012sections 24, 25, 26 & 28 (b)

Cases cited (5)

  • Michael Bett Siror Vs. Jackson Koech
    (2019) eKLR

    A suit dismissed for want of prosecution cannot amount to a judgment for res judicata purposes

  • Selle Vs. Associated Motor Boat Co.
    (EA.123)

    Duty of a first appellate court to re-evaluate evidence and draw its own conclusions

  • Vijay Mortaria Vs. Nansigh Darbar & Another
    (2000) eKLR

    Standard of proof of fraud is slightly above balance of probabilities

  • Isack M’inanga Kiebia Vs Isaya Theuri M’Lintari
    (2018) eKLR

    Elements and tests for establishing a customary trust

  • Henry Mwangi Vs. Charles Mwangi
    CA 245

    Under customary law the eldest son inherits land to hold in trust for himself and other heirs

On appeal from
Principal Magistrate's Court at Kwale
Civil Suit (MELC) No. 82 of 2018
Jurisdiction invoked
First appellate jurisdiction over the Principal Magistrate's Court (Environment and Land jurisdiction)

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Muhendato v Dzilala", Case Analysis (2023). Environment and Land Appeal 2 of 2021. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2023/17471/eng@2023-05-11

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.