Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCPartially AllowedEnvironment & Land Case 54 of 1999· [2023] KEELC 17454 (KLR)

Ndamwe v Amukonambi & 9 others

Environment and Land Court of Kenya
15 May 2023
18,887 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~76 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan court cancelled fraudulently obtained land titles, ruling that a tribunal without jurisdiction cannot decide who owns registered land.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Plaintiff, son of the late Ndamwe Wakoli, sued his deceased mother's estate, his deceased brother's estate (the 2nd Defendant), and eight purchasers over land parcel West Pokot/Siyoi 'A'/2713 and its resultant subdivisions. He sought declarations of ownership, cancellation of titles, eviction, injunction, and nullification of the Kapenguria Land Dispute Tribunal award adopted in Kitale SPMCC No. 105 of 1998. The Defendants counterclaimed that the Plaintiff held the land in trust for the 2nd Defendant. The court framed seven issues. It held that the Tribunal lacked jurisdiction under Section 3 of the repealed Land Disputes Tribunal Act to determine ownership of registered land, rendering its decision and all consequential orders a nullity that no adoption could sanitize. However, it refused prayer (c) seeking to quash the Tribunal award because the Plaintiff failed to exhaust the statutory appeal mechanism under Section 8 and abandoned his judicial review proceedings. The court found all subdivisions and titles flowing from parcel 2713 were illegally, fraudulently and improperly obtained: the Executive Officer exceeded the vesting order; the purchasers transacted during the pendency of the suit and in breach of a 2006 restriction, defeating lis pendens; post-death transactions violated Section 45 of the Law of Succession Act; and Land Control Board consent was not proved. The purchasers were not innocent purchasers for value. The trust claim failed for want of proof, oral evidence not overriding documentary evidence. The Counterclaim was dismissed. The Plaintiff's suit partially succeeded: ownership declared, subdivisions cancelled, register rectified, with a 60-day negotiation window before conditional eviction and injunction. The 3rd-10th Defendants bear half the costs.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the Kapenguria Land Dispute Tribunal had jurisdiction to determine ownership of registered land

Holding

The Tribunal lacked jurisdiction to determine ownership of land where a title exists under the Registered Land Act; its decision was a nullity

Reasoning

Section 3 of the repealed Land Disputes Tribunal Act limited the Tribunal's jurisdiction to matters of a civil nature concerning division of, or determination of boundaries to land, a claim to occupy or work land, or trespass to land. It did not confer jurisdiction to give ownership of land where a title exists. The Tribunal should have downed its tools and sent parties to the proper forum. The court relied on Joseph Malakwen Lelei and Jonathan Amunavi to hold that where a tribunal exercises jurisdiction it does not possess, its proceedings and decisions are null and void.

p. 24
02

Whether the Plaintiff's suit seeking to quash the Tribunal's award was properly before the court

Holding

The relief sought in prayer (c) was incompetent because the Plaintiff failed to comply with the mandatory provisions of Section 8 of the repealed Act and failed to establish exceptions to the doctrine of exhaustion

Reasoning

The court found that the Plaintiff essentially invited the court to quash the Tribunal's decision but had disguised the suit as one seeking declaratory orders. The Plaintiff was required to appeal to the Appeals Committee within 30 days and, if dissatisfied on a point of law, move the High Court within 60 days with certification by a Judge. He did neither. He also filed judicial review proceedings in 1999 but abandoned them. Granting the relief would amount to the court arrogating itself with jurisdiction it does not have.

p. 22
03

Whether the titles emanating from the subsequent subdivisions were obtained fraudulently

Holding

All titles flowing from the subdivisions were obtained illegally, by means of fraud or on account of a corrupt scheme

Reasoning

The court found that the Executive Officer signed an application for subdivision rather than the transfer forms mandated by the vesting order. The purchasers entered into sale agreements during the pendency of the suit and while a restriction dated 01/02/2006 was in force, contrary to the doctrine of lis pendens. Further, transactions after the 2nd Defendant's death on 27/05/2010 violated Section 45 of the Law of Succession Act prohibiting intermeddling with a deceased's estate. No Land Control Board consent was proved for the subdivisions and sales.

p. 27
04

Whether the 3rd - 10th Defendants were bona fide innocent purchasers for value without notice

Holding

The purchasers were not innocent purchasers for value without notice

Reasoning

Although the purchasers claimed to have conducted due diligence, none produced a certificate of official search. The restriction dated 01/02/2006 predated their sale agreements and barred dealings until the suit was finalized. Some agreements were attested to by their own advocate after the restriction was filed, indicating awareness. The court held they either knowingly disregarded the restriction or were engaged in a fraudulent scheme, and in any event were bound by lis pendens.

p. 29
05

Whether the Plaintiff held the land in trust for Salim Ndamwe (Counterclaim)

Holding

The claim of trust fails; the Defendants did not discharge the burden of proof

Reasoning

The Adjudication documents did not indicate that parcel 603 was registered in trust for other persons. The oral testimony was unconvincing and inadmissible hearsay from witnesses who were children or absent at the material time. The Defendants also pleaded inconsistently, claiming trust over parcel 2713 rather than the original parcel 603. The court found the evidence fell short of the standard of proof on a balance of probabilities.

p. 30
06

Whether the transfers complied with the Land Control Act

Holding

The transfers were void for violating mandatory provisions of the Land Control Act

Reasoning

Section 6 of the Land Control Act provides that transactions in agricultural land, including division of property to issue new titles, are void unless consent has been obtained. Other than the subdivision of West Pokot/Siyoi 'A'/2713, it was not demonstrated that the subdivision of parcel 4434 and the subsequent sales were approved by the Land Control Board as required.

p. 30

Legal principles established

#
  • A tribunal without jurisdiction over ownership of registered land makes a decision that is a nullity, and no adoption by a court can sanitize it
  • The doctrine of exhaustion requires parties to pursue statutory dispute resolution mechanisms before invoking the court's jurisdiction
  • The doctrine of lis pendens bars parties from transacting over property that is the subject of pending litigation, and the absence of injunctive orders does not dilute its effect
  • The nemo dat quod non habet rule applies where a deceased person's estate is disposed of without vesting orders, rendering such transactions fraudulent and illegal
  • Oral evidence cannot override documentary evidence in establishing a claim of trust over registered land

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Declaration that the Plaintiff is the legal and rightful owner of all that parcel of land namely West Pokot/Siyoi 'A'/2713
  2. 2.Declaration that the decision and proceedings of the Kapenguria Land District Tribunal were a nullity, including the judgment emanating from Kitale SPMCC Land case No. 105 of 1998
  3. 3.Cancellation of all the resultant subdivisions arising out of West Pokot/Siyoi 'A'/2713 and rectification of the register so that the land reverts back to West Pokot/Siyoi 'A'/2713 in the name of the Plaintiff
  4. 4.Direction that the parties negotiate on any potential agreements in respect to the suit parcel of land within sixty (60) days from the date of the order, while following the provisions of the Land Control Act
  5. 5.If the parties fail to agree within sixty (60) days or any longer period but ONLY at the option of the Plaintiff, an order of eviction to issue evicting all the Defendants, their assigns, personal representatives, agents, servants or anyone claiming under them
  6. 6.Upon the option of eviction being exercised by the Plaintiff, a permanent injunction shall take effect restraining the Defendants, their agents, servants, assigns, personal representatives or whosoever claiming under them from interfering with all that parcel of land namely West Pokot/Siyoi 'A'/2713
  7. 7.The Counterclaim amended on 18/12/2020 and filed on 21/12/2020 lacks merit and is hereby dismissed with no orders as to costs
  8. 8.The 3rd - 10th Defendants will bear half of the costs of the Plaintiff's suit

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of Kenya (repealed)Sections 115 and 116
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 159(2)(d)
  • Land Adjudication ActSections 6, 7, 13, 26, 27 and 29
  • Land Disputes Tribunal Act (repealed)Sections 3 and 8
  • Registered Land Act (repealed)Sections 27, 28, 132(1), 132(2), 136(1), 137(2) and 159
  • Land Registration ActSections 24, 25(1) and 26(1)
  • Civil Procedure ActSection 27(1)
  • Evidence ActSection 107
  • Law of Succession ActSection 45
  • Land Control ActSections 6 and 8
  • Penal CodeSection 95

Cases cited (8)

  • Geoffrey Muthinja Kabiru & 2 Others vs. Samuel Munga Henry & 1756 Others
    [2015] eKLR

    The doctrine of exhaustion of alternative dispute resolution mechanisms and its exceptions

  • Macfoy vs. United Africa Co. Ltd
    [1961] 3 All E.R. 1169

    An act done without jurisdiction is a nullity; you cannot put something on nothing and expect it to stay there

  • Joseph Malakwen Lelei & another vs. Rift Valley Land Disputes Appeals Committee & 2 others
    [2014] eKLR

    Tribunals lack jurisdiction to determine title to or ownership of registered land; such decisions are null and void

  • Jonathan Amunavi vs. Chairman Sabatia Division Land Disputes Tribunal & Another
    C.A Civil Appeal No 256 Of 2002 (Kisumu)

    Disputes relating to title to land and beneficial interest can only be tried by the High Court

  • Diamond Trust Bank Kenya Ltd vs. Said Hamad Shamisi & 2 Others
    [2015] eKLR

    The nemo dat quod non habet rule and protection of commercial transactions

  • Katana Kalume & Another V Municipal Council Fo Mombasa & Another
    [2019] eKLKR

    No person can pass a better title than the one he has

  • Mawji vs. US International University & Another
    [1976] KLR 185

    The doctrine of lis pendens as a substantive law of general application

  • Bishopsgate Motor Finance Corporation Ltd V Transpoert Brakes Ltd
    (1949) 1 KB 322

    The two principles of protection of property and protection of commercial transactions

Jurisdiction invoked
Original jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court under Article 162(2)(b) of the Constitution (land disputes); the court also considered the repealed Land Disputes Tribunal Act, Section 8

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Ndamwe v Amukonambi & 9 others", Case Analysis (2023). Environment & Land Case 54 of 1999. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2023/17454/eng@2023-05-15

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.