Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCAllowedEnvironment and Land Appeal 9 of 2018· [2023] KEELC 17044 (KLR)

Martine Kupai & 2 others v Ngugi Ndibii Wamutua (Sued as the legal representative of Kimgori Lolakupai)

Environment and Land Court
27 April 2023
3,164 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~13 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Environment and Land Court confirmed that a beneficiary with a limited ad litem grant cannot sue for a deceased's estate when an executor already holds a full grant.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The appellants appealed against a ruling of Hon W Juma, Chief Magistrate, Narok, delivered on September 20, 2018 in Narok CMCC No 87 of 2018, which had declined to strike out the respondent's suit as res judicata and had found that a limited grant ad litem issued on September 9, 2016 conferred locus standi on the respondent to sue for the estate of the late Ole Lolakupai. The appeal was canvassed by written submissions. The appellants argued that the deceased's will of August 17, 1989 appointed the Public Trustee as executor, that a full grant issued to the Public Trustee on May 15, 2013, and that Munyao Sila J had ruled on February 16, 2016 in Nakuru ELC No 51 of 2014 that the respondent lacked capacity to sue for the estate; hence the ad litem grant could not confer locus and the fresh suit was res judicata under Henderson v Henderson as applied in John Florence Maritime Services. The respondent contended the earlier suit was struck out at a preliminary stage without a hearing on the merits and that the ad litem grant gave him capacity. Mbogo J, applying the first-appeal standards in Mwanasokoni and Selle, held that the trial magistrate failed to consider the superior court's ruling; the capacity issue had already been determined and the estate's representation vested in the Public Trustee. The court allowed the appeal, set aside the ruling of September 20, 2018, allowed the application dated July 10, 2018, struck out the plaintiff's suit as res judicata for want of locus standi, and awarded costs of the application and the appeal to the appellants.

Key legal issues

#
01

Locus standi of a beneficiary holding letters of administration ad litem where an executor holds a full grant

Holding

The ad litem grant could not confer locus standi; the proper plaintiff was the Public Trustee as executor under the will.

Reasoning

The deceased's will of August 17, 1989 appointed the Public Trustee as executor, and a full grant issued on May 15, 2013 in Nakuru HC Succession Cause No 262 of 2013. Munyao Sila J had already ruled on February 16, 2016 that the respondent held no letters of administration and that the Public Trustee were the personal representatives. The trial magistrate erred in treating a later ad litem grant as conferring capacity that a superior court had determined vested elsewhere.

p. 5
02

Res judicata / finality following the ruling of February 16, 2016

Holding

The issue of the respondent's capacity having been determined in ELC No 51 of 2014, the subsequent suit was res judicata and an abuse of process.

Reasoning

The respondent sued in his own capacity in Nakuru ELC No 51 of 2014 and the suit was struck out on February 16, 2016 on the capacity issue. After that determination he obtained a limited grant ad litem on September 9, 2016 and re-filed the same claim. Applying Henderson v Henderson and John Florence Maritime Services, the court held the locus issue had already been determined and the re-instituted suit offended the doctrine of finality.

p. 6
03

Duties of a first appellate court

Holding

A first appeal court is entitled to revisit the evidence, evaluate it and reach its own conclusion, subject to established limitations on interfering with findings of fact.

Reasoning

The court cited Mwanasokoni v Kenya Bus Service and Selle v Associated Motor Boat Co for the standard: findings of fact are not disturbed unless based on no evidence, on a misapprehension of the evidence, or on wrong principles, with due allowance for the absence of the appellate court from the trial.

Legal principles established

#
  • Where a will appoints an executor (the Public Trustee) and a full grant has issued to that executor, a beneficiary cannot acquire locus to sue for the estate through letters of administration ad litem.
  • A suit struck out for lack of capacity, where the capacity issue was determined by a superior court, cannot be re-instituted; the issue of locus having been determined, the matter is res judicata.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The ruling of the learned trial magistrate delivered on September 20, 2018 in Narok CMCC No 87 of 2018 is set aside
  2. 2.The notice of motion application dated July 10, 2018 is allowed
  3. 3.The application be heard before the plaintiff's suit dated October 28, 2016 pending before the trial court
  4. 4.The plaintiff's suit is struck out in its entirety on the ground that the suit is res judicata
  5. 5.The plaintiff has no locus standi to present the suit
  6. 6.Costs of the application are provided for
  7. 7.Costs of the appeal to be borne by the respondent

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Law of Succession ActSection 54
  • Law of Succession ActSections 79, 82 and 83
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 42 rule 2

Cases cited (8)

  • Henderson versus Henderson

    Doctrine of finality/res judicata - a party cannot relitigate issues already decided.

  • John Florence Maritime Services Limited & Another versus Cabinet Secretary for Transport and Infrastructure & 3 Others
    [2015] eKLR

    Application of the Henderson v Henderson res judicata principle.

  • Julian Adoyo Ongunga versus Francis Kiberenge Abano
    Migori Civil Appeal No 119 of 2015

    Letters of administration ad litem cannot confer locus standi to institute suit.

  • Patrick Kiseki Mutisya (suing as the personal representatives of the estate of Nzomo Mutisya (deceased) v KB Sangani & Sons Limited & Others
    [2012] eKLR

    Capacity to sue for a deceased's estate where an executor exists.

  • Kipngetich Kalya Kones (Suing as the administrator of the estate of Kipkalya Kiprono Kones (deceased) v Wilson Kiplangat Kones
    [2021] eKLR

    The proper plaintiff for a deceased's estate is the executor/administrator.

  • E T versus Attorney General & Another
    [2012] eKLR

    Res judicata and abuse of court process.

  • Mwanasokoni versus Kenya Bus Service Ltd
    1982-88 1 KAR 278

    First appellate court's approach to findings of fact.

  • Selle & Another v Associated Motor Boat Co & Others
    1968 EA 424

    First appellate court must make due allowance for not seeing or hearing witnesses.

On appeal from
Chief Magistrate's Court at Narok
Narok CMCC No 87 of 2018
Jurisdiction invoked
First appeal to the Environment and Land Court under the ELC Act against the ruling of the Chief Magistrate's Court at Narok

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Martine Kupai & 2 others v Ngugi Ndibii Wamutua (Sued as the legal representative of Kimgori Lolakupai)", Case Analysis (2023). Environment and Land Appeal 9 of 2018. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2023/17044/eng@2023-04-27

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.