Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCStruck OutEnvironment & Land Case E010 of 2023· [2023] KEELC 16932 (KLR)

Sheth v Ahmaduna Housing Properties Limited

Environment and Land Court
26 April 2023
3,921 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~16 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Mombasa court struck out a landowner's suit over a neighbour's construction because he should first use NEMA and county planning dispute processes.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The plaintiff, owner (jointly with family) of Mombasa/Block XV11/69, sued the defendant over high-rise construction on the adjoining Mombasa/Block XV11/70, alleging the development lacked proper NEMA and County Government of Mombasa approvals, proceeded without public participation, and caused damage to his perimeter wall, gate, water pipes, sewer, wiring and garage, besides stockpiling materials obstructing access. By notices of motion dated 13 and 17 February 2023 he sought prohibitory and mandatory injunctions pending trial. The defendant filed a replying affidavit asserting it had all approvals, that the plaintiff had vacated the plot, and that it had undertaken to restore the damaged wall, and raised a preliminary objection that the court lacked jurisdiction in light of sections 57-61 of the Physical and Land Use Planning Act, 2019, EMCA and the County Government Act. The court framed three issues and determined jurisdiction first. It found the plaintiff's primary prayers challenged the legality of the development and the adequacy of statutory approvals, matters that must first be processed through the institutions established under EMCA and the Physical and Land Use Planning Act, applying the Supreme Court's doctrine of judicial restraint in Kibos Distillers. It held that a nuisance/damages claim alone would fall within its jurisdiction under Article 162(2)(b) and section 13 of the ELC Act, but the damages aspect must await the statutory processes. Upholding the preliminary objection, the court struck out the applications and the entire suit with costs to the defendant under section 27 of the Civil Procedure Act.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the ELC has jurisdiction over complaints about a development allegedly lacking NEMA and county approvals

Holding

The plaintiff's primary complaints (illegality of construction, absence of approvals, lack of public participation) must first be processed through the statutory mechanisms under EMCA and the Physical and Land Use Planning Act; the court declined to assume jurisdiction prematurely.

Reasoning

The court found the genesis of the suit was the development on the defendant's plot and that the primary prayers sought declarations of illegality and a permanent injunction pending proper approvals. Such disputes fall within the statutory dispute-resolution systems under sections 57-61 of the Physical and Land Use Planning Act and EMCA, and the doctrine of judicial restraint (per Kibos Distillers, Supreme Court) required the court to refrain until those processes are exhausted.

p. 6
02

Whether the nuisance/damage claims fall within the court's jurisdiction

Holding

Had the complaints been primarily over nuisance and damage to the plaintiff's property, they would squarely fall within the court's jurisdiction under Article 162(2)(b) and section 13 of the ELC Act; the damages aspect must await the statutory determinations.

Reasoning

The court distinguished the damages/nuisance aspect from the approvals challenge. It held the damages claim is ancillary and should await the outcome of the statutory processes, after which the plaintiff may move the court as appropriate. The court stressed it was not divesting itself of jurisdiction but requiring exhaustion of lawful processes.

p. 6
03

Whether the injunction threshold (Giella v Cassman Brown) was met

Holding

Not considered; the jurisdictional finding rendered it unnecessary.

Reasoning

Because the preliminary objection succeeded and effectively determined the suit, the court did not reach the merits of the injunction application, applying the principle that a court without jurisdiction must down its tools.

p. 7

Legal principles established

#
  • A court vested with jurisdiction should nonetheless exercise judicial restraint and refrain from determining a dispute where other appropriate legislatively mandated institutions and mechanisms exist.
  • Where a court has no jurisdiction it must down its tools.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The defendant's preliminary objection dated the March 16, 2023 on jurisdiction is upheld.
  2. 2.The plaintiff's applications dated the 13th and February 17, 2023 and suit commenced through the plaint dated the February 13, 2023 are struck out with costs.

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 162(2)(b); articles 10, 40, 47, 50, 159, 165; section 8 of Part 2 of the Fourth Schedule
  • Physical and Land Use Planning ActSections 57 to 61 (No. 13 of 2019)
  • Physical Planning ActSection 29 (No. 6 of 1996)
  • County Government Act2012
  • Environment Management and Co-ordination ActSection 129
  • National Environment and Coordination Act of Kenya1999
  • Environment and Land Court ActSection 13 (No. 19 of 2011)
  • Land ActSection 26
  • Civil Procedure ActSection 27 (Chapter 21, Laws of Kenya)

Cases cited (8)

  • Edward Nduati Huhu & 2 others v John K Wambugu & others
    [2022] eKLR

    Upholding preliminary objection on jurisdiction and remitting dispute to County Physical and Land Use Liaison Committee and NET under PLUPA sections 57-61.

  • Lenkishon Kimirei Maika & 2 others v AM Kalio
    [2018] eKLR

    Remedies for non-compliance with development approvals lie under the Physical Planning Act; court cannot substitute itself for the County Government; injunction declined.

  • Owners of Motor Vessel "Lillian S" v Caltex Oil (Kenya) Ltd
    (1989) KLR 1

    Jurisdiction is everything; a court without jurisdiction must down its tools.

  • Timsales Limited v Harun Thuo Ndungu
    [2010] eKLR

    Failure to rebut evidence gives rise to a presumption that the evidence given represents the true position.

  • Hurlingham Park Ltd v Kings Developmers Ltd & another
    [2020] eKLR

    Damages for nuisance granted on similar facts where development had been completed.

  • Benson Ambuti Adega & 2 others v Kibos Distillers Ltd & 5 others
    [2020] eKLR

    Doctrine of judicial restraint - a court should refrain from determination where other legislatively mandated institutions and mechanisms exist.

  • John Rylands v Thomas Fletcher

    Cited by plaintiff's counsel on nuisance/strict liability.

  • Giella v Cassman Brown & Co Ltd
    (1973) EA 358

    Threshold for grant of interlocutory injunctions.

Jurisdiction invoked
Article 162(2)(b) of the Constitution and section 13 of the Environment and Land Court Act No. 19 of 2011 (jurisdiction contested via preliminary objection)

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Sheth v Ahmaduna Housing Properties Limited", Case Analysis (2023). Environment & Land Case E010 of 2023. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2023/16932/eng@2023-04-26

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.