Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCAllowedEnvironment & Land Case 168 of 2009· [2023] KEELC 16159 (KLR)

Kenya Anti-Corruption Commission v Bernsoft Limited & 2 others

Environment and Land Court of Kenya
16 February 2023
14,723 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~59 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Environment and Land Court cancelled fraudulently acquired titles over reserved public land in Mombasa, ordering the defendants to pay Kshs. 35 million.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Environment and Land Court at Mombasa (LL Naikuni J) allowed a public-property recovery suit brought in 2009 by the then Kenya Anti-Corruption Commission against Bernsoft Limited, Equitronics Limited and Sammy Silas Komen Mwaita, the former Commissioner of Lands. The plaintiff proved that Land Reference MN/1/2396 in Bamburi/Nyali, Mombasa, was surveyed in 1976 under Survey Plan Folio 131/31, built on in 1977 as a Government senior staff house (HG 143) for staff of the Directorate of Civil Aviation, Customs and Meteorology, and later vested in the Kenya Civil Aviation Authority by Gazette Notice of 13 October 2006. In 2002 the 3rd Defendant issued Grant No. CR 36327 to the 1st Defendant using the Government's own Survey and Deed Plans, without presidential execution, letter of allotment, Part Development Plan or boarding under the Government Lands Act; the property was transferred to the 2nd Defendant. The 1st and 2nd Defendants never entered appearance or defended; the 3rd Defendant filed a defence but did not attend trial. Holding that the land was reserved public property and not unalienated Government land, the court found the Grant a nullity, held indefeasibility inapplicable to fraudulently acquired titles, found the 3rd Defendant personally liable for misfeasance in public office, and held the suit exempt from limitation under Section 42(1)(k) of the Limitation of Actions Act. The court cancelled the titles, ordered registration in favour of KCAA/Government, awarded Kshs. 30,000,000 general damages and mesne profits jointly against all Defendants, Kshs. 5,000,000 personally against the 3rd Defendant, and costs to the plaintiff.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the Grant issued to the 1st Defendant over reserved public land was valid

Holding

The Grant was a nullity: the suit property was surveyed, reserved and used for public staff housing, hence not unalienated Government land, and the 3rd Defendant as Commissioner of Lands had no authority to issue the Grant without the President's execution or any boarding process

Reasoning

The court traced the 1974 reservation of twenty plots, the 1976 Survey Plan and Deed Plan, construction of Government houses and their entry in the Government Building Register. Under Sections 3, 7, 9 and 12 of the GLA, alienation of unalienated land was the President's preserve and reserved land could not be alienated. No PDP, letter of allotment, boarding or presidential execution was proved, so the 2002 Grant was fraudulent and ultra vires.

p. 19
02

Whether the Defendants' title was protected by indefeasibility

Holding

No - title is indefeasible only if lawfully acquired; Section 26(1) of the Land Registration Act permits challenge for fraud or corrupt scheme, and Section 80 permits rectification

Reasoning

Relying on Section 26(1) of the Land Registration Act and authorities such as Munyu Maina v Hiram Gathiha Maina, the court held that a registered proprietor whose root of title is challenged must prove the legality of acquisition. The Defendants adduced no evidence of lawful allocation, could not claim to be innocent purchasers, and the 2nd Defendant was treated as a constructive trustee holding the property for the public.

p. 18
03

Whether the 3rd Defendant was properly sued personally and liable for misfeasance in public office

Holding

Yes - he acted ultra vires and in his personal capacity; the office is not liable for acts outside statutory powers, and he was ordered to personally pay Kshs. 5,000,000

Reasoning

Citing Rhyl Urban Amusement Limited, Ref v Deputy Governor of Parkhurst Prison and Three Rivers District Council, the court held that a public officer who dishonestly acts outside his authority loses official protection and is personally liable in the tort of misfeasance in public office. Joining him personally also accorded with natural justice, giving him an opportunity to be heard on the validity of the alienation.

p. 12
04

Whether the suit was statute-barred

Holding

No - Section 42(1)(k) and (2) of the Limitation of Actions Act exempts actions for recovery of public property and applies retroactively

Reasoning

The court accepted the plaintiff's submission that recovery or compensation for loss of public property is excluded from the Limitation of Actions Act, and that Section 42(2) gives the exemption retroactive effect. The action was brought under ACECA, not the GLA, so Section 7 of the Limitation of Actions Act did not apply despite the property having been alienated in 2002.

p. 13
05

Whether the plaintiff had locus standi

Holding

Yes - Section 7(1)(h) of ACECA gave the Commission mandate to investigate loss of public property and institute civil proceedings for recovery

Reasoning

The court found the plaintiff, though defunct and succeeded by EACC structures, had legal capacity to institute the suit by virtue of Section 7(1)(h) of the Anti-Corruption and Economic Crimes Act, 2003, which empowers investigation of any loss or damage to public property and institution of civil proceedings for recovery or compensation. No party challenged this capacity in the pleadings.

Legal principles established

#
  • The power to alienate unalienated Government land under Section 3 of the Government Lands Act vested in the President personally, and the Commissioner of Lands had no power to alienate land already reserved for another public purpose
  • Indefeasibility of title does not protect titles acquired illegally, unprocedurally or through a corrupt scheme
  • A public officer who acts outside his statutory authority is personally liable and cannot shelter behind the office he held
  • Recovery of public property actions are exempt from the Limitation of Actions Act under Section 42(1)(k)

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Judgment entered in favour of the Plaintiff and against the 1st, 2nd and 3rd Defendants jointly and severally with costs
  2. 2.Registrar of Titles directed to cancel and/or revoke the Certificate of Title and registry records for LR MN/1/2396 – MN/1/2415 and suit property MN/1/2396 illegally registered in the name of the 2nd Defendant, pursuant to Sections 121 and 122 of the GLA (repealed), Sections 23(1)&(2) and 24 of the Registered Titles Act (repealed) and Sections 79(1)(2) and 80(1)&(2) of the Land Registration Act, and in tandem with the Ndung'u Commission recommendations
  3. 3.Registrar of Title Mombasa directed to register LR MN/1/2396 – MN/1/2415 and suit property MN/1/2396 into the names of the Kenya Civil Aviation Authority and/or the Government of Kenya
  4. 4.Registrar of Title Mombasa directed to issue Certificates of Title for those properties into the names of the Kenya Civil Aviation Authority and/or the Government of Kenya
  5. 5.1st, 2nd and 3rd Defendants ordered to pay general damages and Mesne Profits of Kshs. 30,000,000 for loss of user for the 22 years of illegal possession from 2002 to date, within 60 days
  6. 6.3rd Defendant ordered to personally pay Kshs. 5,000,000 for liability, abuse of office and breach of the tort of misfeasance in office within 60 days
  7. 7.Costs of the suit to be borne by the 1st, 2nd and 3rd Defendants

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • State Corporations ActCap. 446
  • Anti-Corruption and Economic Crimes ActNo. 3 of 2003, Sections 7(1)(h), 23
  • Companies ActCap 486
  • Public Services Commission Act
  • Government Lands ActCap 280 (repealed), Sections 3, 7, 9, 12, 13, 20, 121, 122, 128
  • Civil Aviation ActChapter 394
  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Articles 25(c), 40(6), 50(1) and (2), 61, 60-72
  • Interpretation and General Provisions ActCap 2, Section 23(3)(c)
  • Land Registration ActNo. 3 of 2012, Sections 25(1), 26(1), 79, 80, 107
  • Land ActNo. 6 of 2012, Section 7
  • Registration of Titles ActCap 281 (repealed), Sections 23, 23(1)&(2), 24
  • Limitation of Actions ActCap 22, Sections 4(2), 7, 42(1)(k) and (2)
  • Civil Procedure ActCap. 21, Section 27(1)
  • Civil Procedure Rules, 2010Orders 10 Rules 4, 6, 9 and 11
  • Government Financial Regulations and Board of Survey Procedures

Cases cited (30)

  • African Line Transport Company Limited v The Honorable Attorney General
    Mombasa HCCC No. 276 of 2003 (2007) eKLR

    Corrected procedure for issuance of a Grant for unalienated Government land

  • John Peter Mureithi & Another v The Republic
    Nbi Misc. Civil Application No. 158 of 2005 (2006) eKLR

    Doctrine of public interest vis-à-vis private interest

  • The Town Council of Ol-Kalau v Ng'ang'a General Hardware
    Nbi. Civil Appeal No. 269 of 1977

    Limited powers of Commissioner of Lands over unalienated Government land

  • Champakalal Ramn Shal v The Attorney General & Another
    Mombasa HCCC No. 145 of 1997

    Interpretation of Sections 3, 7, 9, 12 and 13 of the GLA

  • Insurance Company of East Africa v The Attorney General & Another
    Mombasa HCCC No. 135 of 1998 (2001) eKLR

    Limits on Commissioner of Lands' mandate over unalienated Government land

  • James Joram Nyaga & Another v the Hon Attorney General & Another
    Nairobi High Court Misc. Civil Application No. 1732 of 2004 (2007) eKLR

    Limits on Commissioner of Lands' powers

  • Milan Kumarn Shah & 2 Others v City Council of Nairobi
    Civil Suit No. 1024 of 2005 (OS) Nbi. HCCC 3063 of 1996

    Limits on alienation powers

  • Paul Nderitu Ndungu & 20 Others v Pashito Holdings

    Duty to cater for public rights; joinder of Commissioner of Lands and natural justice

  • Dr. Syedna Mohammed Burhannudin Swaleh & two others v Benja Properties Limited
    Nbi. HCCC No. 73 of 2000

    Limits on Commissioner of Lands' powers

  • Shiva Mombasa Limited v Kenya Revenue Authority & Another
    Mombasa HCCC No. 171 of 2004 eKLR

    Limits on Commissioner of Lands' powers

  • Kenya Anti Corruption Commission v James Raymond Njenga & Another
    Eldoret HCCC No. 61 of 2008 (2010) eKLR

    Limits on Commissioner of Lands' powers

  • Tukero Ole Kina & Another v Sheikh Said (also known as TSS) & 5 others
    (2015) eKLR

    Effect of repeal on rights acquired under repealed law

  • Samwuel Kamau Macharia & Another v Kenya Commercial Bank Limited & Others
    (2012) eKLR

    Statutes are prima facie prospective unless retrospectivity expressly intended

  • Masek Ole Timukoi & 3 others v Kenya Grain Growers Ltd & 2 others
    ELC (Nku) No. 272 of 2015 (OS)

    Protection of registered proprietor's rights

  • M'Mbaoni M'Thaara v James Mbaka
    ELC (Chuka) No. 110 of 2017

    Protection of title by registration

  • Dr. Joseph M. K. Arap Ngok v Justice Moijo Ole Keiwua
    Civil Appeal 60 of 1992

    Land property comes into existence only after letter of allotment and issuance of title

  • Joseph Komen Somek v Patrick Kennedy Suter
    ELC Eldoret Appeal No. 2 of 2016 (2018) eKLR

    Purpose of Section 26(1)(b) - protecting real title holders

  • Peter Njoroge Nganga v Kenya Reinsurance Corporal Limited & Others
    ELC (Kjd) No. 204 of 2017

    Cancellation and rectification of title under Section 80 of the Land Registration Act

  • Munyu Maina v Hiram Gathiha Maina
    (2013) eKLR

    Registered proprietor must prove legality of acquisition when root of title is challenged

  • Huber L. Martin & 2 others v Margaret J. Kamau & 5 Others
    (2016) eKLR

    Challenge to root of title

  • Alberta Mae Galli v Attorney General & 4 Others
    (2006)

    Condemnation of fraudulently acquired title (Onyancha J)

  • Rhyl Urban Amusement Limited
    (1959) AKER

    An ultra vires act of a Minister is not the act of the office

  • Kenya Anti-Corruption Commission v Bhangra Limited & Another
    Civil Application No. 185 of 2009 (2009) eKLR

    Non-joinder of Commissioner of Lands should not render suits incompetent

  • Kenya Anti-Corruption Commission v Judith Marylyn Okungu
    Appl. No. 187 of 2007 (2007) eKLR

    Right to sue a public officer in personal capacity for wrongs committed in office

  • Ref v Deputy Governor of Parkhurst Prison & Others
    (1992) 1 AC 58

    Tort of misfeasance in public office - personal liability for bad faith acts outside authority

  • Three Rivers District Council and Others v Governor and Company of the Bank of England (No. 3)
    (2000) 3 ALL ER 1

    Misfeasance in office lies where decision taken knowing it exceeds powers

  • J.K. Chatract & Another v Shah Cedar Mart
    (1967) E.A. 93

    No estoppel against a statute

  • Reids Heweet & Company v Joseph
    AIR 1918 Cal. 717

    Costs follow the event

  • Myres v Defries
    (1880) 5 Ex. D. 180

    Costs follow the event, read distributively

  • Jasbir Singh Rai & 3 others v Tarlochan Singh Rai & 4 Others
    [2014] eKLR

    Basic rule on attribution of costs - costs follow the event

Jurisdiction invoked
Original civil jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court; suit instituted under Section 7(1)(h) of the Anti-Corruption and Economic Crimes Act, 2003 for recovery of public property

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Kenya Anti-Corruption Commission v Bernsoft Limited & 2 others", Case Analysis (2023). Environment & Land Case 168 of 2009. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2023/16159/eng@2023-02-16

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.