Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCDismissedEnvironment & Land Case 596 of 2014· [2023] KEELC 16055 (KLR)

Nurani & another (Suing as the Legal Administrators of the Estate of Sadrudin Shmsudin Ismail Nurani) v Gulam & 2 others

Environment and Land Court
23 February 2023
2,681 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~11 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan court refused to step aside from a land case, ruling that unproven claims of judicial bias are not enough to disqualify a judge.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
By a notice of motion dated June 20, 2022, the 2nd defendant, Sunshine Cottages Limited, sought the recusal of O. A. Angote, J from hearing and determining Environment & Land Case 596 of 2014. It was alleged that the judge was a close family friend of Mr Steve Luseno, counsel for the 2nd plaintiff, and had previously worked with Mr Luseno's wife at the then Kenya Anti-Corruption Commission, creating a reasonable apprehension of bias contrary to Article 50 of the Constitution. The 1st plaintiff opposed the application as an abuse of process and a dilatory tactic following the dismissal of the 2nd defendant's application to recall PW1; Mr Luseno swore that he had no familial relations with the court. The court framed the sole issue as whether it should recuse itself. Applying Rule 21 of the Judicial Service (Code of Conduct and Ethics) Regulations, 2020 and the objective test in Jasbir Singh Rai, Republic v Mwalulu and Kalpana H Rawal, the court held that the applicant bore the burden of establishing facts from which a fair-minded and informed observer would infer bias; bare allegations are insufficient and the source of unprovable information must be disclosed. The applicant tendered no evidence of the alleged friendship and did not disclose his source. The court further held that a prior professional association with counsel's spouse in a government institution is not, on its own, a ground for recusal, since that would absurdly require judges with prior public-sector careers to disqualify themselves whenever former colleagues appeared. The application was dismissed with costs.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the alleged family friendship between the judge and the 2nd plaintiff's counsel warranted recusal

Holding

No; the applicant tendered no evidence of the relationship and did not disclose the source of the information, contrary to the Kalpana Rawal standard.

Reasoning

The court applied the objective test requiring specific facts establishing a reasonable possibility of bias to a fair-minded and informed observer. The applicant made bare allegations of friendship without evidence or disclosure of the source. Following Kalpana H Rawal, unprovable statements of information require disclosure of their source so credibility can be assessed. The allegation therefore failed.

p. 5
02

Whether prior professional association with counsel's spouse at KACC is a ground for recusal

Holding

No; such a prior professional relationship in a government institution cannot found actual or perceived bias.

Reasoning

The court reasoned that if prior collegiality in a government institution were a ground for recusal, all judges who once worked in the Attorney General's office, ODPP or NEMA would have to disqualify themselves whenever former colleagues or their spouses appeared before them - an absurd result contrary to the laid-down grounds for disqualification under Rule 21.

p. 5
03

Whether the recusal application was a dilatory tactic

Holding

The court observed the application followed the dismissal of the applicant's application to recall PW1, suggesting an apprehension arising from adverse rulings rather than genuine bias.

Reasoning

The court noted the applicant's natural apprehension stemmed from losing an application to have PW1 recalled for cross-examination. The respondents argued the application was brought after adverse decisions to intimidate the court. The court found the facts would not lead a fair-minded and informed observer to conclude a reasonable possibility of bias.

p. 5

Legal principles established

#
  • The test for a judge's impartiality is the perception of a well-informed, thoughtful observer who understands all the facts and has examined the record and the law; unsubstantiated suspicion of bias will not suffice.
  • An applicant for recusal bears the duty of establishing facts from which a fair-minded and informed observer would infer bias; bare allegations are insufficient, and the source of unprovable information must be disclosed.
  • A judge's previous professional association with counsel's spouse in a government institution is not, on its own, a ground for recusal.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The 2nd defendant's notice of motion dated June 20, 2022 seeking the judge's recusal is dismissed with costs

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of KenyaArticle 50
  • Judicial Service (Code of Conduct and Ethics) RegulationsRule 21

Cases cited (15)

  • Jasbir Singh Rai & 3 others v Tarlochan Singh Rai & 4 others
    [2013] eKLR

    Test for judicial impartiality is the perception of a well-informed, thoughtful observer; unsubstantiated suspicion of bias will not suffice

  • Perry v Schwarzenegger
    671 F 3d 1052 (9th Circuit February 7, 2012)

    Reasonable person test for judge's impartiality, quoted with approval in Jasbir Singh Rai

  • Robert Tom Martins Kibisu v Republic
    [2018] eKLR

    Local jurisprudence on recusal applications

  • Nathan Obwana v Robert Bisakaya Wanyera & 2 others
    [2013] eKLR

    Recounting principles on disqualification of a judge

  • Republic v Mwalulu & 8 others
    [2005] 1 KLR

    Principles on which a judge would disqualify himself; objective test; facts must be specifically alleged and established

  • Kalpana H Rawal v Judicial Service Commission & 2 others
    (2016) eKLR

    Applicant bears duty of establishing facts from which bias may be inferred; source of unprovable information must be disclosed

  • Kalpana H Rawal & 2 others v Judicial Service Commission & 2 others
    [2016] eKLR

    Judge's oath to perform judicial duties with fairness, independence, competence and integrity

  • Ajay Shah v Attorney General & Another & 2 others
    [2013] eKLR
  • President of the Republic of South Africa & others v South African Rugby Football Union and others
    CCT16/98 [1999] ZACC 9
  • Barnaba Kipsongok Tenai v Republic
    [2014] eKLR
  • R v Sussex Justices Exp McCarthy
    [1924] 1 KB 256
  • Lawrence Kinyua Mwai vs Nyaringu Farmers Company Limited
    [2017] eKLR
  • Abdikadir Mohammed Ali & another v Ali Digale & 9 others
    [2020] eKLR
  • Prayosha Ventures Limited v NIC Bank Ltd & another, Beatrice Jeruto Kipketer & another (Interested Parties)
    [2020] eKLR
  • Miller v Miller
    [1988] eKLR
Jurisdiction invoked
Original jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court; application for judicial recusal under Rule 21 of the Judicial Service (Code of Conduct and Ethics) Regulations, 2020 and Article 50 of the Constitution

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Nurani & another (Suing as the Legal Administrators of the Estate of Sadrudin Shmsudin Ismail Nurani) v Gulam & 2 others", Case Analysis (2023). Environment & Land Case 596 of 2014. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2023/16055/eng@2023-02-23

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.