Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCDismissedEnvironment and Land Constitutional Petition 1 of 2021· [2022] KEELC 15261 (KLR)

Malua v Yatta & 2 others

Environment and Land Court of Kenya
8 December 2022
12,394 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~50 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A 33-year delay in a land appeal did not void the decision, and a litigant who paid the adjudicating officer lost his case entirely.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Petitioner, son of the late Musila Ngua, petitioned the Environment and Land Court at Kitui challenging the decision of the Deputy County Commissioner, Kitui West (the designated appellate authority under Section 29 of the Land Adjudication Act) in Minister's Appeals Nos 241 and 245 of 1988 concerning parcels 186 and 188 Nzalae Land Adjudication Section, delivered on April 30, 2019 after a 33-year delay. He sought declarations that the proceedings and verdict were null and void for breach of the right to a fair hearing within a reasonable time (Section 77(1) and (9) of the repealed Constitution; Articles 25(c), 47 and 50(1)), that the 2nd Respondent's independence was compromised by payments solicited from the parties, and that Section 29 of the Land Adjudication Act was unconstitutional for lacking timeframes, procedural safeguards and an institutional framework. The court framed three issues. On delay, it accepted the 33-year period was inordinate and unexplained, but following Julius Kamau Mbugua and Andrew Kibet Cheruiyot held the right is not absolute, the delay did not affect the fairness of the trial, both parties were fully heard, and the claim was an afterthought raised only after the Petitioner lost. On impartiality, M-Pesa evidence proved the Petitioner himself paid the 2nd Respondent some Kshs 150,000 during the pendency of the appeals - payments the court found irregular and for an illegal purpose - but the alleged Kshs 300,000 payment by the 1st Respondent was unproved hearsay; the ex turpi causa maxim barred the Petitioner's claim. On constitutionality, applying the purpose and effect test and the presumption of constitutionality, the court found Section 29 not in conflict with the Constitution, the Bill of Rights and the Fair Administrative Action Act still binding the Minister. The Petition was dismissed with costs to the 1st Respondent, and the court reiterated that the 2nd Respondent's conduct should be investigated by the EACC.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the 33-year delay in hearing the Minister's appeals violated the right to a fair hearing within a reasonable time and fair administrative action

Holding

The delay was inordinate and unexplained, but it did not affect the fairness of the trial; nullification would be disproportionate and the claim was an afterthought raised only after the Petitioner lost.

Reasoning

The court accepted the 33-year delay and the absence of reasons, but applying Julius Kamau Mbugua and Andrew Kibet Cheruiyot held the right is not absolute. Both parties were heard, witnesses called, and a site visit conducted. The Petitioner participated fully and only complained after an unfavourable outcome; the remedy of nullification would harm both parties and the public interest.

p. 11
02

Whether the 2nd Respondent's independence and impartiality was compromised by payments made by the parties

Holding

The Petitioner's own payments of Kshs 150,000 to the 2nd Respondent were irregular and for an illegal purpose, but the alleged Kshs 300,000 payment by the 1st Respondent was not proved; the ex turpi causa maxim barred the Petitioner's claim.

Reasoning

M-Pesa statements proved payments from the Petitioner to the 2nd Respondent during the pendency of the appeals, which were irregular since official channels and receipts should have been used. However, hearsay allegations of payment by the 1st Respondent, unsupported by direct evidence, failed under Section 107(1) of the Evidence Act. The Petitioner's participation in the irregular payments disentitled him to relief.

p. 15
03

Whether Section 29 of the Land Adjudication Act is unconstitutional

Holding

Section 29 is not in conflict with the Constitution; the presumption of constitutionality was not rebutted on purpose or effect.

Reasoning

The court applied the purpose and effect test. Section 29 provides an avenue of appeal at the apex of the adjudication dispute-resolution process; the Bill of Rights binds the Minister notwithstanding the Act's silence; the Land Adjudication Regulations provide procedure; and the Fair Administrative Action Act offers review. The Petitioner adduced no evidence or argument showing non-conformity with the cited constitutional provisions.

p. 21

Legal principles established

#
  • The right to a hearing within a reasonable time is not absolute and must be balanced against societal interests; nullification of proceedings is a disproportionate remedy absent definite, not speculative, prejudice
  • A violation of the right to a trial within a reasonable time should be raised at the earliest opportunity, failing which it may be defeated by waiver
  • There is a rebuttable presumption of constitutionality of statutes and the burden lies on the party alleging unconstitutionality
  • Constitutionality of a statutory provision is tested by examining both its purpose and the effect of its implementation
  • No legal remedy or benefit can flow from an illegal act (ex turpi causa non oritur actio)

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The Petition dated June 14, 2019 is dismissed
  2. 2.Costs of the Petition awarded to the 1st Respondent

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of Kenya 2010Articles 1, 2, 3, 4, 8, 10, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 25(c), 27, 31, 47(1) and (2), 50(1), 63(5), 73(1), 75(1), 79, 159(1) and (2), 252, 258, 259, 260; Sixth Schedule ss 6 and 7
  • Repealed Constitution of KenyaSections 77(1), 77(9), 77(a); Chapter IX, Section 116
  • Land Adjudication ActCap 284, Sections 26, 29(1) and (2), 35
  • Land Adjudication Regulations 1970Rule 4(2) and Second Schedule
  • Fair Administrative Action ActNo 4 of 2015, Sections 4(1), 7(1) and (2)
  • Public Officer Ethics ActNo 4 of 2003, Sections 9 and 11
  • Leadership and Integrity ActNo 19 of 2012
  • Evidence ActCap 80, Section 107(1)
  • Bribery ActSection 6
  • Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission Act2011, Sections 13(2)(b), 28
  • Anti-Corruption and Economic Crimes Actgeneral
  • Land Registration ActNo 3 of 2012
  • Community Land ActNo 27 of 2016
  • Land Consolidation Actgeneral
  • Trust Land ActCap 288 (repealed)
  • Land (Group Representatives) ActCap 287 (repealed)
  • Government Lands ActCap 280 (repealed)
  • Registration of Titles ActCap 281 (repealed)
  • Land Titles ActCap 282 (repealed)
  • Registered Land ActCap 300 (repealed)
  • Indian Transfer of Property Act 1882repealed
  • Statute Law (Miscellaneous Amendments) ActNo 7 of 2016
  • Sessional Paper No 3 of 2009 on National Land Policygeneral
  • United Nations Universal Declaration of Human RightsArticle 8 and 10

Cases cited (21)

  • Shameem v State
    (2007) FJCA

    The concept of reasonableness defies definition; delay assessed in circumstances of each case

  • Craig v South Australia
    [1995] 184 CLR 163

    Decision made ultra vires where law did not empower delay

  • MZAPC v Minister For Immigration and Border Protection
    [2021] HCA 17

    Public authority defendants generally expected to explain themselves despite burden on applicant

  • Stead v State Government Insurance Commission
    [1986] 161 CLR

    Denial of natural justice - respondent to show properly conducted trial could not have produced different result

  • WZAPH
    (2015) 256 CLR 326

    Same proposition on burden where natural justice denied

  • Julius Kamau Mbugua v Republic
    [2010] eKLR

    Restatement of Commonwealth principles on trial within a reasonable time, burden, waiver and remedies

  • Andrew Kibet Cheruiyot & another v Medical Practioners & Dentists Board & 2 others
    [2014] eKLR

    Invalidation of proceedings injurious to public interest except in exceptional circumstances showing serious prejudice

  • Matwanga Kilonzo v District Commissioner, Kitui & another
    [2021] eKLR

    Fresh evidence not always necessary in appeals under section 29 of the Land Adjudication Act

  • Republic v Special District Commissioner & another
    [2006] eKLR

    Manner in which the Minister should conduct proceedings under section 29

  • Martin vs Tauranga

    Where delay has not affected trial fairness, breach met by compensation rather than abandoning trial process

  • Edderman Property Ltd & 2 others v Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission & 3 others
    [2021] eKLR

    EACC's constitutional and statutory mandate to investigate corruption

  • Pamela Zipporah Moriasi v Republic
    [2021] eKLR

    Elements of the offence of receiving a bribe under Section 6 of the Bribery Act

  • Gideon Makori Abere v Republic
    [2019] eKLR

    Ingredients of the offence of receiving a bribe

  • Kenya Ports Authority v Fadhil Juma Kisuwa
    [2017] eKLR

    Ex turpi causa non oritur actio - no remedy flows from an illegal act

  • Holman v Johnson
    [1775] 1 Cowp 341

    Lord Mansfield's classic statement of the ex turpi causa principle

  • Kalundi Mutua v Simon Mutiuli Kang'e & Others
    Kitui ELC Petition No 8 of 2021 (Unreported)

    Court's earlier views on identical constitutional challenge to Section 29 of the Land Adjudication Act

  • Gathigia v Kenyatta University
    Nairobi HCMA No 1029 of 2007 [2008] KLR 587

    Principles guiding quasi-judicial tribunals in procedure and fair hearing

  • Hypolito Cassiani De Souza vs Chairman Members of Tanga Town Council
    1961 EA 77

    General principles for statutory domestic or administrative tribunals sitting in a quasi-judicial capacity

  • Kenya Human Rights Commission & another v Non-Governmental Organizations Co-ordination Board & another
    [2018] eKLR

    Administrative actions must meet the constitutional test of legality, reasonableness and procedural fairness

  • Ndynabo v Attorney General of Tanzania
    [2001] EA 495

    Presumption of constitutionality of legislation and burden on challenger

  • The Queen v Big M Drug Mart Ltd
    1986 LRC (Const) 332

    Both purpose and effect are relevant in determining constitutionality

Jurisdiction invoked
Articles 21(1), 25(c), 27(1), 47(1) and (2), 50(1) of the Constitution of Kenya 2010 and Sections 77(1) and 77(9) of the repealed Constitution, read with Sections 6 and 7 of the Sixth Schedule

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Malua v Yatta & 2 others", Case Analysis (2022). Environment and Land Constitutional Petition 1 of 2021. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2022/15261/eng@2022-12-08

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.