Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCAllowedCivil Suit 210 of 2021· [2022] KEELC 13582 (KLR)

Hussein Tareq Abdalla v Dalal Juma Hassan & 15 others

Environment and Land Court of Kenya
5 October 2022
5,568 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~22 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Environment and Land Court in Mombasa merged two lawsuits over the same Mombasa properties and froze dealings on them until trial.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This is a ruling by the Environment and Land Court at Mombasa (LL Naikuni, J) on the plaintiff's notice of motion dated December 17, 2021 seeking consolidation of ELC No 210 of 2021 with ELC (Mombasa) No 183 of 2019. The plaintiff had bought shares in two parcels, LR CR-6289 and CR-6290, from the estates of Kamaldin and Atiyat Akasha Abdalla (the 1st to 15th defendants) and sought a declaration of breach of the sale agreements and a mandatory injunction compelling the 16th defendant to release the certificates of title. ELC No 183 of 2019 was an originating summons by Nurdin Akasha Abdalla and the estates against Nargis Akasha Abdalla and the Land Registrar over the same properties, from which the 2nd and 3rd plaintiffs had partially withdrawn. The 16th defendant opposed consolidation, arguing different parties, causes of action and relief, and that the partial withdrawal ended the withdrawn claims. The court applied the three consolidation parameters, found on scrutiny of the annexures that the suit properties described by title numbers and plot numbers were one and the same, held that a partial withdrawal does not end a suit, and found no prejudice incapable of compensation by costs. It allowed consolidation, designated the ELC No 183 of 2019 file as the lead file, directed conversion of the originating summons into a plaint, scheduled mention for November 2, 2022, and ordered the Land Registrar, Mombasa to register an inhibition over both parcels to preserve them pending trial. Costs of the application were made costs in the cause.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the two suits should be consolidated

Holding

Consolidation allowed: the suits involve the same parties and the same subject matter, being parcels LR CR-6289 and CR-6290, and no prejudice incapable of compensation by costs was established.

Reasoning

The court applied the three consolidation parameters: common questions of law or fact, rights or reliefs arising from the same transaction, and absence of prejudice. Despite different descriptions of the suit properties (title numbers versus plot numbers), a dive into the annexures showed the parcels were the same. The withdrawal by the 2nd and 3rd plaintiffs in ELC 183 of 2019 was partial, so that suit still subsisted. Most defendants did not oppose consolidation, which would serve the overriding objective.

p. 6
02

Effect of the withdrawal of suit by the 2nd and 3rd plaintiffs in ELC No 183 of 2019

Holding

The withdrawal was a partial withdrawal only; the suit did not abate and still subsists between the 1st plaintiff and the defendants, so consolidation remains possible.

Reasoning

The court set out order 25 rules 1, 2 and 3 of the Civil Procedure Rules on discontinuance and endorsed the Priscilla Nyambura Njue exposition that withdrawal removes only the withdrawing party's claim. Since only the 2nd and 3rd plaintiffs withdrew wholly against the defendants while the 1st plaintiff's suit continued, ELC No 183 of 2019 remained live and capable of consolidation with the present suit.

03

Preservation of the suit properties pending trial

Holding

The court ordered registration of an inhibition by the Land Registrar, Mombasa over both parcels, invoking lis pendens, to preserve the suit properties.

Reasoning

Relying on the doctrine of lis pendens under section 52(1) of the Indian Transfer of Property Act and decisions including George Kadenge v Azzuri Limited and Mawji v United States International University, and invoking natural justice, the court directed registration of an inhibition under sections 68(1) & (2) and 69(1) of the Land Registration Act and section 79 of the Land (General Regulations) 2017 to preserve the properties pending final determination of the consolidated suit.

p. 9

Legal principles established

#
  • Consolidation is appropriate where the same questions of law or fact arise, the rights or reliefs claimed arise out of the same transaction, and no party is unduly prejudiced; prejudice compensable by costs does not defeat consolidation.
  • A partial withdrawal of a suit does not terminate the whole suit; the suit subsists as between the remaining plaintiff and defendants.
  • Suits commenced differently (by plaint and by originating summons) may still be consolidated; the originating summons can be converted into a plaint under order 37 rules 16-19 of the Civil Procedure Rules.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Notice of motion dated December 17, 2021 by the plaintiff/applicant allowed
  2. 2.Order for consolidation of ELC No 183 of 2019 and ELC No 210 of 2021 into one suit, the same being of the same subject matter and same parties
  3. 3.The file on ELC No 183 of 2019 to be the lead file where all filings of pleadings will be done and proceedings recorded from henceforth
  4. 4.Mention on November 2, 2022 for further directions on the originating summons in ELC No 183 of 2019 under order 37 rules 16, 17, 18 and 19 of the Civil Procedure Rules and fixing of a hearing date within 180 days
  5. 5.Land Registrar, Mombasa directed to register an inhibition against LR CR-6289 (Original 6037/22) and CR-6290 (Original 6037/23) under sections 68(1) & (2) and 69(1) of the Land Registration Act and section 79 of the Land (General Regulations) 2017 pending hearing and determination of the consolidated suit; parties to bear this costs
  6. 6.Costs of the application to be in the cause

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010articles 159(1) & (2)
  • Civil Procedure Act, cap 21sections 1, 1A, 1B, 3, 3A, 27, 80(h)
  • Civil Procedure Rules, 2010orders 5 rule 17, 11 rule 3, 25 rules 1, 2 & 3, 37 rules 16, 17, 18 & 19, 51 rule 1
  • Environment and Land Court Act, No 19 of 2011sections 3 and 13
  • Land Registration Act, No 3 of 2012sections 68(1) & (2), 69(1), 101
  • Land Act, No 6 of 2012sections 128 and 150
  • Land (General Regulations), 2017section 79
  • Indian Transfer of Property Actsection 52(1)

Cases cited (8)

  • Selecta Kenya GMBH & Co KG v Chace Bank Kenya Limited & 2 others
    [2018] eKLR

    Relied on by 16th defendant's counsel citing Stumberg v Potgeiter on consolidation principles

  • Stumberg & Anor v Potgeiter
    1970 EA 323

    Common questions of law or fact justify consolidation; object is to avoid multiplicity of litigation

  • Priscilla Nyambura Njue v Geovhem Middle East Limited & Kenya Bureau of Standards
    [2021] eKLR

    Effect of withdrawal of a suit: plaintiff ceases to be plaintiff and cannot revive withdrawn claim

  • County Council of Nakuru v Simon Ole Kiminta & 3 others
    [2007] eKLR

    Consolidation inappropriate where suits challenge different things and would confuse issues (cited by defendant, not followed)

  • Law Society of Kenya v The Centre for Human Rights & Democracy
    Supreme Court of Kenya Petition No 14 of 2013

    Essence of consolidation: efficient, expeditious disposal; no undue advantage or disadvantage

  • Municipal Council of Mombasa v Municipal Council of Mombasa
    [2004] eKLR

    Maraga, J: consolidation combines suits treated as one, saving costs, time and effort

  • George Kadenge v Azzuri Limited
    Malindi ELC No……..

    Lis pendens - need to preserve suit properties

  • Mawji v United States International University (USIU)

    Lis pendens principle supporting preservation of suit properties

Jurisdiction invoked
Order 11 rule 3 and Order 51 rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010; sections 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act (cap 21); article 159(2) of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Hussein Tareq Abdalla v Dalal Juma Hassan & 15 others", Case Analysis (2022). Civil Suit 210 of 2021. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2022/13582/eng@2022-10-05

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.