Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCAllowedEnvironment and Land Constitutional Petition 8 & 24 of 2019 (Consolidated)· [2022] KEELC 12651 (KLR)

Prosperity Developers Limited v National Land Commission & 3 others

Environment and Land Court
27 September 2022
9,174 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~37 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Environment and Land Court quashed the National Land Commission's revocation of Naivasha land titles, ruling the Commission acted without jurisdiction and without a fair hearing.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
Two consolidated petitions (Nakuru ELC Petitions No.8 and No.24 of 2019) by Prosperity Developers Limited and Prigal Limited challenged Gazette Notice No.1716 of 22nd February 2019, by which the National Land Commission recommended revocation of titles over LR No.5212 and LR No.5212/168 in Naivasha and vesting of the land in KALRO. The petitioners, claiming to be bona fide purchasers for value, alleged violation of Articles 40, 47 and 50, asserting they were never served with notice of the Commission's review nor given a hearing. The NLC filed no response or submissions; the AG denied the averments; EACC, joined as interested party, contended the land was reserved since 1904 for a livestock experimental farm and later alienated irregularly. The court found no evidence the land had been alienated to KARI/KARLO before the 1995 allocation; the 1952 letter was not an allotment, so the land was unalienated government land which the Commissioner of Lands could lawfully allocate under section 3 of the Government Lands Act. Pritam Singh Panesar and the petitioners were bona fide purchasers whose titles deserved protection. The Commission breached section 14(3) of the NLC Act, Article 47 and the Fair Administrative Action Act by failing to serve notice or afford a hearing, and its five-year review mandate under section 14(1) had lapsed on 2nd May 2017 with no extension, rendering the decision ultra vires, null and void ab initio. The court quashed Gazette Notice No.1716 and all consequential actions by certiorari and awarded costs to the petitioners against the NLC and EACC.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the suit land was alienated/reserved to KARI/KARLO before the 1995 allocation

Holding

No evidence demonstrated alienation to KARI/KARLO or any other person before the 1995 allocation; the 1952 letter did not constitute an allotment, so the land was unalienated government land.

Reasoning

The court examined the letter of 6th November 1952 relied on by the interested party and found it did not constitute an allotment to the Ministry of Livestock/Agriculture. No instrument alienating the land to anyone other than the 1995 allottees was exhibited. The Supreme Court's advisory opinion in Reference No.2 of 2014 confirmed the Commissioner of Lands could allocate unalienated government land under section 3 of the Government Lands Act.

p. 10
02

Whether the petitioners held good title deserving protection

Holding

Yes. Pritam Singh Panesar was a bona fide purchaser for value, and the petitioners as subsequent bona fide purchasers acquired titles deserving protection to the extent permissible under the law.

Reasoning

The Commissioner of Lands affirmed the 1995 allotment by letter of 6th November 1997, approved the sale and consented to the informal transfer, and the full allotment charges were paid. Panesar validated the allotment with the Commissioner of Lands and nothing more was required. The petitioners, as transferees for value without notice of defect, took titles protected under sections 25 and 26 of the Land Registration Act.

p. 11
03

Whether the NLC's revocation recommendation violated Articles 47 and 50

Holding

Yes. The petitioners were never served with notice of the review or given an opportunity to be heard, breaching section 14(3) of the NLC Act, Article 47 and section 4 of the Fair Administrative Action Act.

Reasoning

The NLC filed no replying affidavit and exhibited no notice of the review. The Gazette Notice misdescribed the ownership of LR No.5212 (naming Top Farm), showing the Commission failed to access readily available registry records. Publication in national dailies without particulars was insufficient notice; affected parties must be served with particulars and afforded a hearing.

p. 16
04

Whether the NLC had jurisdiction to conduct the review in 2019

Holding

No. The five-year mandate under section 14(1) lapsed on 2nd May 2017 and no extension was proved; the Commission acted ultra vires and without jurisdiction.

Reasoning

Section 14(1) required review within five years of commencement of the Act (5th May 2012), expiring 2nd May 2017. Section 14(9) allowed the Commission to petition Parliament for an extension, but no evidence of extension was tendered and the respondents and interested party did not address the issue. The February 2019 Gazette Notice was therefore null and void for want of jurisdiction.

p. 17

Legal principles established

#
  • Section 14(1) of the National Land Commission Act gave the Commission a five-year window (to 2nd May 2017) to review grants of public land; after its lapse the Commission has no jurisdiction to review grants absent a parliamentary extension.
  • Service of notice of a title review cannot be implied; the affected party must be served with notice containing ample particulars of the alleged irregularities to enable a defence.
  • A registered proprietor's title is protected under sections 25 and 26 of the Land Registration Act and may only be challenged on the limited grounds therein.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.An order of judicial review in the nature of certiorari quashing the decision of the 1st Respondent, in particular Kenya Gazette Notice No.1716 published in the Kenya Gazette Vol.CXXI No.23 of 22nd February 2019, together with all consequential actions by the 1st Respondent affecting LR No.5212 and/or LR No.5212/168 (originally LR 5212/20) situate in Naivasha in any manner
  2. 2.Costs of the consolidated petitions awarded to the petitioners as against the 1st Respondent and the interested party

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of KenyaArticles 2(2), 10, 20(2), 21, 22(1), 24(1), 25(c), 27(1)(2), 40 (including 40(6)), 47, 50(1), 60, 67(1)(2)(3), 68(c)(v), 165(5), 258
  • National Land Commission ActSections 6, 14(1)-(9), 15
  • Fair Administrative Action ActSections 4(3), 4(4), 6
  • Land Registration ActSections 25, 26(1)(a)(b), 28
  • Government Lands Act (Cap 280) (repealed)Sections 2, 3, 7
  • Ethics and Anti-Corruption Act2011

Cases cited (11)

  • Anarita Karimi -vs- R
    (1979) eKLR

    Threshold for what constitutes a constitutional petition

  • Advisory Opinion Reference 2 of 2014 - In the matter of the National Land Commission
    (2015) eKLR

    Section 3 GLA conferred powers on the President, delegated to the Commissioner of Lands, to allocate unalienated government land

  • Sceneries Limited -vs- National Land Commission
    (2017) eKLR

    Right to be heard requires prior notice of the inquiry and sufficient information, including access to documents relied upon

  • Mwangi Stephen Muriithi -vs- National Land Commission & 3 others
    (2018) eKLR

    Decisions made without service of notice are ultra vires and null and void for breach of natural justice

  • Samuel D. Omwenga Agwenyi -vrs- National Land Commission & 2 others
    (2019) eKLR

    What constitutes adequate notice of a title review; gazette notice without particulars is deficient

  • Republic -Vs- National Land Commission & Tropical Treasure Ltd; Exparte Krystaline Salt Ltd
    (2015) eKLR

    Newspaper notice without particulars of the complaint is not sufficient notice

  • James Joram Nyaga & Another -vrs- AG
    Nairobi HC Misc App. No.1732/2004

    Distinguished - related to land demonstrated to have been alienated

  • Rep -vs- Commissioner of Lands Exparte Lima Ltd
    Eldoret HC JR No.10/2008

    Distinguished - related to land demonstrated to have been alienated

  • Rep -vs- The Senior Registrar of Titles & 2 others, Exparte Conmen Ltd
    Mombasa HC Misc Civil App. No.70/2010

    Distinguished - related to land demonstrated to have been alienated

  • Republic -vrs- National Land Commission & 3 others, Exparte Samuel Githegi Mbugua & 5 others
    (2018) eKLR

    NLC has no jurisdiction to review grants after the section 14(1) mandate expired

  • Republic -vs- National Land Commission, Exparte Giraffe Estate Limited; City County Government of Nairobi & 5 others
    (2020) eKLR

    NLC has no jurisdiction to review grants after the section 14(1) mandate expired

Jurisdiction invoked
Articles 22, 23 and 258 of the Constitution (enforcement of Bill of Rights); Environment and Land Court jurisdiction

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Later judgments citing this (3)

#

Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Prosperity Developers Limited v National Land Commission & 3 others", Case Analysis (2022). Environment and Land Constitutional Petition 8 & 24 of 2019 (Consolidated). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2022/12651/eng@2022-09-27

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.