Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCDismissedPetition dated December 16, 2019 (Amended Petition dated October 19, 2021), Environment and Land Court at Nairobi (Milimani)· [2022] KEELC 3172 (KLR)

Waste and Environment Management Association of Kenya v County Government of Nairobi & another (Petition 3 of 2021) [2022] KEELC 3172 (KLR)

Environment and Land Court
3 August 2022
9,519 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~38 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

The Environment and Land Court dismissed waste collectors' challenge to Nairobi's licence fees, finding no discrimination and ruling that poorly pleaded constitutional claims fail.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The petitioner, an association of solid waste collection and disposal companies, petitioned the Environment and Land Court at Nairobi challenging licence fees levied by the Nairobi City County Government (1st respondent), including a charge of Kshs 20,000 per truck for an authority to collect and dispose of waste, alleging discrimination contrary to Article 27, lack of public participation, and unconstitutionality of the levy. It also challenged the annual waste transportation licence fees levied by NEMA (2nd respondent) as encroaching on a devolved function and amounting to double taxation. The 1st respondent raised a jurisdictional objection and defended its charges under the Nairobi City County Finance Act, 2019 and Part Two of the Fourth Schedule; NEMA justified its charges under EMCA, 1999 and the Waste Management Regulations, 2006, and further contended the petition was barred by res judicata and sub judice given Milimani HCC Petition No 116 of 2016. The court framed four issues. It held neither res judicata nor sub judice applied: the 2016 petition concerned different legislation, NEMA was impleaded in a different capacity, and the 2016 petition remains pending and undetermined; sub judice could only ground a stay, not termination, and could not be raised in final submissions. On discrimination, the petitioner failed to discharge the burden of proof; differentiated fees based on disclosed, rational criteria (fleet size, designated vehicles) constitute permissible classification, not discrimination. The challenge to Sections 87, 88 and 89 of EMCA failed because the impugned sections were never pleaded with particulars; submissions cannot substitute pleadings or evidence. The double taxation/encroachment issue was consequently moot. The petition was dismissed in its entirety, with each party bearing its own costs in light of the Article 42 public-interest dimension.

Key legal issues

#
01

Res sub-judice and res judicata vis-à-vis Milimani HCC Petition No 116 of 2016

Holding

Neither doctrine applies: the previous petition concerned different legislation (the County Solid Waste Management Act versus the County Finance Act 2019), NEMA was impleaded in a different capacity, and the previous petition remains pending and undetermined

Reasoning

For sub-judice, the parties, capacities and subject matter must be the same; here the previous petition challenged different provisions and NEMA was an interested party there but a substantive respondent here. For res judicata, a prior determination is required; the 2nd respondent conceded the 2016 petition is still pending and unprosecuted, negating the doctrine. Further, sub-judice cannot be raised for the first time in final submissions; an application for a stay should have been filed beforehand.

p. 11
02

Alleged discriminatory differentiated licence fees by the 1st respondent

Holding

No discrimination established; the annextures showed Kshs 20,000 charged annually per designated vehicle with fees clustered by fleet size, an intelligible and rational differentiation

Reasoning

The burden lay on the petitioner to prove discrimination on a balance of probabilities. The annexed licences showed charges tied to designated motor vehicles and clustered by company size/number of vehicles. Differentiated charging on a disclosed, explained basis with an intelligible differentia rationally related to the object is permissible classification, not discrimination under Article 27(1) and (2).

p. 13
03

Constitutionality of Sections 87, 88 and 89 of EMCA, 1999

Holding

The issue fails because the impugned sections were never pleaded in the amended petition with particulars; the petitioner cannot expand the case through submissions

Reasoning

The petition did not identify the impugned sections or plead particulars of the contravention of Part Two of the Fourth Schedule. Per Anarita Karimi Njeru and Mumo Matemu, constitutional violations must be pleaded with precision. A party is bound by its pleadings, and submissions cannot substitute for pleadings or evidence; leave to amend should have been sought.

p. 16
04

Whether NEMA's annual waste transportation licence fees encroach on the county's devolved function and constitute double taxation

Holding

The issue is moot and cannot be determined because it depends on the unpleaded and undetermined constitutionality of the EMCA provisions underpinning the fees

Reasoning

NEMA's charges rest on the EMCA Act, 1999 and the Waste Management Regulations, 2006, which were not declared unconstitutional since the challenge was not properly pleaded. Any finding on encroachment or double taxation would therefore be superficial and academic; the respondents' mandates are distinct, but the court declined an academic determination.

p. 18

Legal principles established

#
  • Res sub-judice requires suits between the same parties over the same subject matter, and can only ground a stay of the later suit, not its termination
  • Res judicata presupposes a prior suit that has been heard and determined; a pending suit cannot found the doctrine
  • Differentiated fees based on an intelligible differentia rationally related to a legitimate object do not amount to unconstitutional discrimination
  • Constitutional petitions must plead with precision the provisions violated and the manner of violation; issues cannot be smuggled in via submissions
  • Submissions do not constitute evidence and cannot take the place of pleadings or evidence

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The Amended Petition dated the October 19, 2021 is dismissed.
  2. 2.Each party to bear its own costs.
  3. 3.It is so ordered.

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Article 165(5); Article 27(1) and (2); Article 42; Article 186(1); Part Two of the Fourth Schedule
  • Environment and Land Court ActSection 13(2)
  • Environment Management and Coordination Act, 1999 (EMCA)Sections 87, 88 and 89
  • Environment Management and Coordination (Waste Management) Regulations2006 Regulations
  • Nairobi City County Finance Act2019
  • Nairobi City County Solid Waste Management ActAmendments thereto and Part 3 items under CBO solid waste collection and transport
  • Civil Procedure ActSection 6 (stay of suit); Section 7 (res judicata); sections 1A and 1B
  • Evidence ActSections 108 and 109
  • Appellate Jurisdiction ActSections 3A and 3B

Cases cited (16)

  • Kenya National Commission on Human Rights versus Attorney General; Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission & 16 others (Interested Parties)
  • John Florence Maritime Ltd v The Cabinet Secretary, Transport, Infrastructure & Public Works & Another
    (2015)eKLR
  • Karia & Another v The Attorney General and Others
    [2005] 1 EA 83
  • Henderson v Henderson
    [1843] 67 ER 313
  • Samson Gwer & 5 others v Kenya Medical Research Institute & 3 others
    [2020] eKLR
  • Raila Odinga & Others v Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission & Others
    Petition No 5 of 2013
  • James Nyasora Nyarangi & 3 others v Attorney General
    [2008] eKLR
  • Nyarangi & 6 Others versus The Attorney General
    (2008)eKLR 688
  • Zab Adami versus Malta
    Application No 16631 of 2004
  • Peter K Waweru v Republic
    (2006)eKLR
  • Aids Law Project v Attorney General & 3 Others
    (2015)eKLR
  • Anarita Karimi Njeru versus Republic
    (1979)eKLR
  • Mumo Matemu versus Trusted Society of Human Rights Alliance and 5 Others
    (2013)eKLR
  • Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission versus Stephen Mutinda Mule & Others
    (2014)eKLR
  • Daniel Toroitich Arap Moi versus Mwangi Stephen Muriithi & another
    [2014] eKLR
  • Enock Krau Muhanji versus Hamid Abdala Mbarak
    (2013)eKLR
Jurisdiction invoked
Constitution of Kenya, 2010 (petition originally filed in the High Court and transferred to the Environment and Land Court as the dispute touched the right to a clean and healthy environment under Article 42)

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Later judgments citing this (2)

#

Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Waste and Environment Management Association of Kenya v County Government of Nairobi & another (Petition 3 of 2021) [2022] KEELC 3172 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2022). Petition dated December 16, 2019 (Amended Petition dated October 19, 2021), Environment and Land Court at Nairobi (Milimani). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2022/3172/eng@2022-08-03

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.