Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCPartially AllowedNot stated in the judgment (suit concerning Waitaluk/Kapkoi 11/Gutongorio suit lands)· [2022] KEELC 3133 (KLR)

Muna & 5 others v Boscardin & 5 others (Environment & Land Case 27 of 2020) [2022] KEELC 3133 (KLR)

Environment and Land Court
2 June 2022
5,034 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~20 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan court confirmed that a counterclaim lives independently of the main suit and survives a defendant's death, while clarifying what a status quo order actually freezes.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
In an interlocutory ruling in a land dispute before the Environment and Land Court at Kitale, the Court dealt with two prayers arising after the death of the 2nd Defendant, Elizabeth Wacheke Waruiru, on 24th December 2021: first, interpretation and enforcement of the status quo order issued on 30/06/2020; and second, the marking as withdrawn of the suit against the deceased and the fate of her joint Counterclaim. The Court invoked Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution and Section 3 of the Civil Procedure Act to determine the unanchored application on substantive justice. On status quo, counsel agreed that ploughing and construction were ongoing on the suit lands but disputed their meaning; the Court held that everything was to remain as at the date of filing the suit – no fresh cultivation, no construction, no new structures – and directed anyone who had erected structures to pull them down and seal foundations within fifteen days. On the Counterclaim, the Court held, relying on Order 7 Rule 13 of the Civil Procedure Rules and Section 35 of the Limitation of Actions Act, that a counterclaim is a separate and independent action which does not die with the primary suit; the withdrawal of the suit against the deceased did not extinguish her Counterclaim. Applying Section 2(1) of the Law Reform Act, the Court further held that the Counterclaim's causes (fraud, negligence, cancellation and annulment of titles) survived the deceased, not being within the statutory exceptions. The suit was put in abeyance to allow substitution by the estate, with mention on 27/09/2022; each party was directed to bear its own costs, the parties being family members with a window to settle out of court.

Key legal issues

#
01

The meaning and scope of the status quo order issued on 30/06/2020

Holding

Status quo meant that everything on the suit lands was to remain as at the date of filing the suit: no fresh cultivation or planting, no construction, no new fences or structures, and no removal of animals save by owners' volition

Reasoning

The Court reconstructed the factual position as at the date of the order from the documents filed. Counsel differed on whether the order permitted continued cultivation by those in occupation; the Court held that the position prevailing at filing was to be frozen, and persons who had erected structures or brought materials were to dismantle them within fifteen days failing which the Plaintiffs could do so at their cost.

p. 6
02

Whether a counterclaim is independent of the suit in which it is pleaded

Holding

A counterclaim is a separate entity from the suit; it is treated as a separate action under Section 35 of the Limitation of Actions Act, though when tried together both merge into one judgment

Reasoning

The Court anchored its finding on Order 7 Rule 13 of the Civil Procedure Rules, which permits a counterclaim to proceed where the plaintiff's suit is stayed, discontinued or dismissed, and on Section 35 of the Limitation of Actions Act, which deems a set-off or counterclaim to be a separate action commenced on the same date as the main action. It endorsed the Indian Supreme Court's characterisation of a counterclaim as a cross-suit and Beatrice Mumbi Wamahiu v Mobil Oil Kenya Ltd.

p. 7
03

Whether withdrawal of the suit against the deceased 2nd Defendant affected her Counterclaim

Holding

The withdrawal of the suit did not affect the life and existence of the Counterclaim

Reasoning

Having found that a counterclaim may be treated as a claim independent of the suit, Order 7 Rule 13 applied: upon discontinuance of the plaintiff's suit, the counterclaim may nevertheless be proceeded with. The Notice of Withdrawal filed on 03/03/2022 following the 2nd Defendant's death therefore did not extinguish the Counterclaim she had filed jointly with the other Defendants on 21/09/2020.

p. 8
04

Whether the deceased 2nd Defendant's Counterclaim survived her death

Holding

The Counterclaim survived her death because the claims (fraud, negligence, cancellation and annulment of titles, customary trust) are not among the causes of action excepted by Section 2(1) of the Law Reform Act

Reasoning

Applying Section 2(1) of the Law Reform Act, all causes of action subsisting against or vested in a person survive for the benefit of the estate, save for actions of a personal nature such as defamation, seduction, inducing a spouse to leave, or adultery claims. The maxim actio personalis moritur cum persona applies only to actions of a personal nature. The 2nd Defendant's Counterclaim, being founded on fraud and title, fell outside the exceptions and survived for her estate, which must take out substitution before abatement after twelve months.

p. 8

Legal principles established

#
  • A counterclaim is a separate and independent action whose survival is not pegged on the pendency or continuance of the primary suit
  • Where the plaintiff's suit is stayed, discontinued or dismissed, the counterclaim may nevertheless be proceeded with
  • Causes of action against or vested in a person survive for the benefit of the estate except for the causes of action excepted under Section 2(1) of the Law Reform Act
  • There is no doctrine of everlasting joinder of parties; a suit by or against a party may be discontinued upon death, settlement or change of circumstances

Court orders

#
  1. 1.Interpretation of the status quo order of 30/06/2020: no fresh cultivation or planting, no construction, no new fences or structures; existing fences, structures and animals to remain as at the date of filing the suit
  2. 2.Any person who has brought construction materials or put up structures on the suit lands to pull them down, remove the materials and seal the foundation within fifteen (15) days of the ruling, failing which the Plaintiffs may do so at that individual's cost
  3. 3.The Counterclaim of the deceased 2nd Defendant survived her death and did not lapse upon withdrawal of the suit against her
  4. 4.The estate of the deceased 2nd Defendant may pursue substitution of representatives before the cause abates twelve months after death; the entire suit is automatically put in abeyance for that purpose in terms of Order 24 Rule 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules
  5. 5.Mention on 27/09/2022 to confirm progress of substitution, if any
  6. 6.Each party to bear its own costs of the application

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of KenyaArticle 159(2)(d)
  • Civil Procedure ActSection 3
  • Civil Procedure Rules, 2010Order 24 Rules 1, 2, 3 and 4
  • Civil Procedure Rules, 2010Order 7 Rule 3
  • Civil Procedure Rules, 2010Order 7 Rule 13
  • Limitation of Actions ActSection 35
  • Law Reform Act, Chapter 26, Laws of KenyaSection 2(1)
  • Indian Civil Procedure RulesOrder 8 Rule 6A(2)

Cases cited (9)

  • Willam Koross v Hezekiah Kiptoo & 4 others
    C.A. No. 223 of 2013
  • Tabera Clearing Agency Lts v. Southern Credit Banking & 2 others
  • Musha Chengo Kenga & another v Lenox Kahindi Fakuro (On behalf of the Fakuro Randu)
    [2019] eKLR
  • Titus Kiragu v. Jackson Mugo Mathai
    (2015) eKLR
  • Kaboi Mucheru v. Gakua Mucheru Mbugi
    (2015) eKLR
  • Said Sweilem Gheithan Saanum v. Commissioner of Lands (being sued through the Attorney General) & 5 others
    (2015) eKLR
  • County Government of Kilifi v. Mombasa Cement Limited
    [2017] eKLR
  • Sh. Jag Mohan Chawla & another v Dera Radha Swami Satsang & Ors.
  • Beatrice Mumbi Wamahiu v Mobil Oil Kenya Ltd
    [2011] eKLR
Jurisdiction invoked
Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution of Kenya and Section 3 of the Civil Procedure Act (inherent power and override of technicalities)

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Later judgments citing this (1)

#

Judgments in the corpus that rely on this one. Where the Court said how it treated the authority, that is shown.

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Muna & 5 others v Boscardin & 5 others (Environment & Land Case 27 of 2020) [2022] KEELC 3133 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2022). Not stated in the judgment (suit concerning Waitaluk/Kapkoi 11/Gutongorio suit lands). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2022/3133/eng@2022-06-02

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.