Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCAllowedNyamira ELC Appeal (from Nyamira CM ELC No. 24 of 2020)· [2022] KEELC 2378 (KLR)

Nyamwange & 2 others v Mabeya & 3 others (Environment and Land Appeal 11 of 2021) [2022] KEELC 2378 (KLR)

Environment and Land Court
27 June 2022
1,964 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~8 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This is a first appeal to the Environment and Land Court at Nyamira against a ruling of Principal Magistrate Maurine C. Nyigei delivered on June 16, 2021 in Nyamira CM ELC No. 24 of 2020. The plaintiffs sued over the laying of a water pipeline through land parcel Gesima Settlement Scheme/5 on March 8, 2017 without consultation, claiming destruction of crops, trees, grass, vegetation and fencing valued at over Kshs 8,000,000, and seeking a declaration, removal of the pipeline or compensation, a permanent injunction, costs and interest. The 1st and 2nd defendants (Chairman and Secretary of the Nyamache Water Project) applied under Order 1 Rule 10(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules to be struck out, contending the project was a Government initiative implemented through the 3rd defendant, Lake Victoria South Water Services Board. The trial Magistrate allowed the application and struck out the suit against them with costs, relying on Pizza Harvest v Midigo and Elisheba Muthoni Mbae v Gichohi. Allowing the appeal, Mugo Kamau J held that the plaint attributed specific tortious acts to the 1st and 2nd defendants - the destruction of crops and fencing - which raised triable issues, that a cause of action is not synonymous with liability, that even one triable issue suffices, and that their own affidavit showed they were involved in the project throughout. The court, citing Madan JA in Muchina, held that however hopeless a claim, the plaintiffs must be heard and the defendants must not be condemned unheard. The appeal was allowed with costs and the 1st and 2nd defendants were reinstated as defendants.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the suit against the 1st and 2nd defendants should have been struck out for disclosing no reasonable cause of action

Holding

The appeal was allowed; the 1st and 2nd defendants were reinstated because the plaint specifically alleged that they participated in the trespass and destruction of property, raising triable issues entitling them to be heard

Reasoning

The plaint attributed to the 1st and 2nd defendants specific acts - entering the land with the sub-county commissioner and police and destroying crops, trees, grass, vegetation and fencing worth over Kshs 8,000,000. This destruction might be unconnected to pipeline laying and could be wanton destruction. In the absence of any Defence, the court could not say whether they would admit or deny the claim. Striking them out risked condemning them unheard if the claim were later proved. Citing Madan JA in Muchina, a court must act cautiously, avoid the merits, and however hopeless a claim may be, the plaintiff must be heard on it.

p. 4
02

Whether the 1st and 2nd respondents' own affidavit undermined their claim of non-involvement

Holding

Yes - their supporting affidavit showed they were involved throughout the project, including enjoining the Attorney General and a Third Party Notice in an earlier suit

Reasoning

Stephen Mabeya's affidavit deponed that the project was commenced but stalled after a neighbour obtained an injunction in Kisii HCCC No. 63 of 2007, and that they instructed their advocate to enjoin the Attorney General who took over conduct of the matter. The court reasoned that this showed the first two respondents were 'quite in the picture all along' and could not now disclaim involvement when sued for a tort. They shot themselves in the leg and should be given an opportunity to file a Defence and defend the destruction allegations.

p. 4

Legal principles established

#
  • A cause of action is not synonymous with liability; it merely means a claim attributed to a defendant, and its merit is a matter for trial
  • Even one triable issue is sufficient to defeat striking out

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The Appeal is allowed with costs
  2. 2.The 1st and 2nd defendants are forthwith reinstated as defendants in Nyamira Chief Magistrate's Court ELC Case No. 24 of 2020

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 1 Rule 10(2)

Cases cited (3)

  • Pizza Harvest Limited v Felix Midigo
    [2013] eKLR
  • Elisheba Muthoni Mbae v Nicholas Karani Gichohi & 2 others
    [2014] eKLR
  • Gudka Ltd v Alfred D. T. Dobie & Company (kenya) Ltd v Muchina
    [1982] KLR 1
On appeal from
Chief Magistrate's Court, Nyamira
Nyamira CM ELC No. 24 of 2020
Jurisdiction invoked
First appeal from the Principal Magistrate's Court under the Environment and Land Court's appellate jurisdiction (the judgment does not cite a specific provision)

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Nyamwange & 2 others v Mabeya & 3 others (Environment and Land Appeal 11 of 2021) [2022] KEELC 2378 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2022). Nyamira ELC Appeal (from Nyamira CM ELC No. 24 of 2020). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2022/2378/eng@2022-06-27

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.