Rest Villa Limited v Kenya Power & Lighting Co. Ltd (Environment & Land Case 199 of 2007) [2022] KEELC 2278 (KLR)
The bottom line
#Kenya Power won its land counter-claim because its opponent never showed up with evidence, proving unproven court pleadings are worthless.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Effect of the Plaintiff's failure to call evidence in defence of the counter-claim
The Plaintiff's defence to the counter-claim remained mere unsubstantiated allegations, leaving the Defendant's evidence uncontroverted
Relying on Linus Nganga Kiongo and Trust Bank Ltd v Paramount Universal Bank Ltd, the court held that a party which fails to call evidence fails to substantiate its pleadings. The Plaintiff's averments therefore remained mere allegations, and the Defendant's evidence stood uncontroverted, allowing the counter-claim to be determined on the Defendant's unchallenged evidence.
Ownership of the suit property L.R No. 209/11590
The Defendant is the registered and bona fide proprietor of the suit property, bound as this court was by the Court of Appeal's decision in Njilux Motors
The Court of Appeal in Njilux Motors had already held that the Defendant's grant took precedence over competing titles, since the City Council had breached the special conditions of its grant and the Defendant's title under Section 23(1) of the RTA was absolute and indefeasible. This court is bound by that decision, and sections 24, 25 and 26 of the Land Registration Act reinforce the indefeasibility of the Defendant's title.
Validity of the Certificates of Lease and the conversion from RTA to the Registered Land Act
The Certificates of Lease for Nairobi/Block 37/167 and 168 are null and void, and the conversion of the title from Cap 281 to Cap 300 was illegal, null and void
The court found the Certificates of Lease were products of corrupt dealings emanating from an illegal conversion, the City Council having admitted breach of the special conditions in the grant. Following the Court of Appeal's findings on the corrupt scheme, the court declared the conversion and the resultant certificates null and void.
Damages for wrongful conversion
The Defendant is entitled only to nominal damages of Kshs.500,000/- for wrongful conversion
Although conversion damages are compensatory and require proof of actual loss, the court found the Plaintiff was not solely to blame for the corrupt conversion, and at the material time both parties held valid titles. The Defendant had been in occupation since 2007, so no substantial loss was proved, warranting only nominal damages.
Permanent injunction against interference with the suit property
A permanent injunction was granted restraining the Plaintiff from interfering with the Defendant's possession and occupation of the suit property
Citing Sammy Kemoo Arekai and Kenya Power & Lighting Co. Ltd v Sheriff Molana Habib, the court noted a permanent injunction issues after trial upon the merits. The matter having proceeded to trial and the Defendant having proved its case, the injunction was merited.
Legal principles established
#- Where a party fails to call evidence in support of its case, its pleadings remain mere statements of fact and unsubstantiated allegations
- Registration of a person as proprietor of land vests absolute ownership, and a certificate of title is prima facie evidence of indefeasible ownership, challengeable only on grounds of fraud, misrepresentation, or illegal, unprocedural or corrupt acquisition
- A permanent injunction issues only after the rights of the contesting parties have been adjudicated and the court has reached a final decision
Court orders
#- 1.A declaration that the Defendant is the bona fide proprietor of L.R No. 209/11590
- 2.A declaration that the Certificates of Lease for L.R No. Nairobi/Block 37/167 and 168 are not legal documents and are null and void
- 3.A permanent injunction restraining the Plaintiff from interfering with the Defendant's possession and occupation of L.R No. 209/11590
- 4.A declaration that the alleged conversion of L.R No. 209/11590 from Cap 281 to Cap 300 Laws of Kenya is null and void and of no legal consequence
- 5.Nominal damages of Kshs.500,000/- to the Defendant for wrongful conversion
- 6.Costs of the counter-claim granted to the Defendant
- Jurisdiction invoked
- First-instance determination of a counter-claim in a land dispute; no specific constitutional or statutory jurisdictional provision invoked
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Rest Villa Limited v Kenya Power & Lighting Co. Ltd (Environment & Land Case 199 of 2007) [2022] KEELC 2278 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2022). . Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2022/2278/eng@2022-05-11
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.