Jane Wagathuitu Githinji & 2 others v Sojanmi Springfields Limited & 2 others [2022] KEELC 1958 (KLR)
The bottom line
#A Kenyan court confirmed companies must restore the environment even while appealing, and made the polluter pay to decommission dams and greenhouses.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Extent of compliance with orders 1 to 9 of the judgment of 19th June 2019
Orders 1 and 2 (water quality/EDL) not satisfactorily complied with; Order 4 (main dam EIA) breached; Order 5 (second dam) breached; Order 7 (18 unlicensed greenhouses) and Order 8 (full compliance with NEMA orders) breached; only the dam integrity test order (Order 6) showed a measure of compliance
The court reviewed NEMA's status reports and inspection findings of 24th August 2021 showing contaminated effluent exceeding discharge standards, continued use of the main and central dams without fresh EIA studies, and continued operation of 18 unlicensed greenhouses, despite NEMA restoration orders and pending criminal proceedings.
Effect of the appeal and partial stay on the restoration orders
Stay granted by the Court of Appeal applied only to orders 11 and 12; orders 1 to 9 relating to environmental restoration remained operative
The Court of Appeal's ruling of 7th May 2021 recognized that the restoration-oriented orders were not stayed, so the 1st defendant remained bound to comply with the environmental orders notwithstanding its appeal.
Court's residual role in post-judgment implementation
The court is not functus officio and may exercise oversight to ensure the judgment serves environmental conservation
Because the judgment imposed continuous participatory obligations on the defendants, the court retained a supervisory role, directing audits, reports and remedial measures to fill implementation gaps.
Legal principles established
#- A court that issues judgments imposing continuous participatory obligations retains a residual post-judgment oversight role without being rendered functus officio
- An appeal does not stay restoration orders directed at environmental conservation; compliance cannot be deferred pending appeal
- Pending criminal proceedings cannot substitute for proactive environmental remediation
Court orders
#- 1.NEMA in liaison with WRA and in consultation with the 1st defendant to have fresh water samples taken from inlet and outlet sites, with analysis and report filed in court within 60 days
- 2.The main dam to be decommissioned within 30 days of the ruling under the supervision of NEMA Inspectors
- 3.The second (central) dam to be decommissioned within 30 days of the ruling under the supervision of NEMA Inspectors
- 4.The 18 additional unlicensed greenhouses to be decommissioned within 30 days of the ruling under the supervision of NEMA Inspectors
- 5.Costs of decommissioning the two dams and the 18 greenhouses to be borne by the 1st defendant
- 6.The OCS Njoro police station to provide security to facilitate implementation of the court orders if required by NEMA
- 7.NEMA to prepare and file a report on the decommissioning within 45 days
- 8.Matter to be mentioned on 6th April 2022 to confirm compliance and/or further directions
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Article 42 and Article 69 of the Constitution; post-judgment implementation oversight over the judgment of 19th June 2019 (not expressly pleaded as a constitutional provision conferring jurisdiction)
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Jane Wagathuitu Githinji & 2 others v Sojanmi Springfields Limited & 2 others [2022] KEELC 1958 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2022). Not stated in the extract (Environment and Land Court suit at Nakuru; judgment of Munyao, J of 19th June 2019). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2022/1958/eng@2022-01-27
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.