Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCDismissedPetition dated (ELC Petition, Makueni) — Notice of Motion dated 1st July 2020· [2021] KEELC 2089 (KLR)

Erdemann Property Limited v National Environment Tribunal; London Distillers (K) Limited (Interested Party) [2021] KEELC 2089 (KLR)

Environment and Land Court of Kenya
9 September 2021
2,510 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~10 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

A Kenyan court refused to step aside from a case, ruling that unsubstantiated bias claims do not force judges to withdraw.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
This is a ruling on a recusal application in an environmental petition before the Environment and Land Court at Makueni. The Petitioner/Applicant, through the Notice of Motion dated 1st July 2020, sought the recusal of Hon. Mr. Justice C.G. Mbogo on three grounds: that the court set aside conservatory orders on 6th March 2020 without affording the Petitioner a fair hearing; that counsel for the Interested Party was overheard saying he would speak to Justice Angote to influence the court; and that a petition against the judge was pending before the Judicial Service Commission. The relief sought was recusal, reallocation of the file by the Principal Judge of the ELC, and costs in the cause. The Interested Party opposed the application, describing it as mala fides, an abuse of process, part of a pattern of recusal applications and JSC complaints whenever rulings went against the Petitioner, and noting the Court of Appeal had found the Petitioner guilty of filing parallel proceedings. The court framed a single issue: whether the Applicant had established a cogent argument meriting recusal. Applying the objective test of a reasonable apprehension of bias, the court endorsed the East African Court of Justice decision in Attorney-General v Anyang' Nyong'o and the South African Constitutional Court decision in SARFU. It found the fair-hearing ground unsubstantiated, the telephone-conversation allegation without substance, and the pending JSC complaint insufficient to warrant recusal absent indictment or conviction. The court denounced what it saw as veiled intimidation undermining judicial independence. The application dated 1st July 2020 was dismissed with costs, delivered at Makueni via email on 9th September 2021.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the circumstances of the setting aside of conservatory orders on 6th March 2020 demonstrated bias

Holding

The ground was unsubstantiated; the record showed both counsel were heard and the court exercised judicial discretion on prima facie non-disclosure

Reasoning

The court found it had given counsel wide latitude to make their case on the setting-aside application, was prima facie satisfied there had been non-disclosure of material facts and parallel proceedings, and gave the Petitioner an opportunity to file a substantive replying affidavit. The denial of a fair hearing was therefore not made out.

p. 3
02

Whether the alleged telephone conversations between the Interested Party's counsel and Justice Angote implicated the court

Holding

No substance was provided to support the alleged conversations and the court was not shown to be party to them

Reasoning

The Petitioner did not adduce material substantiating the alleged telephone conversation involving the Interested Party's counsel, and no link to the presiding judge was demonstrated. The court regarded the allegation as wild and unsupported.

p. 3
03

Whether a pending JSC complaint against a judge warrants recusal

Holding

No; a judge will not recuse himself on the basis of every unsubstantiated complaint in which he has neither been indicted nor convicted

Reasoning

The court held that mere pendency of a complaint before the Judicial Service Commission, founded on discontent, does not constitute grounds for recusal absent any indictment or conviction and without substance to the allegations.

p. 3

Legal principles established

#
  • The test for recusal is objective: whether a reasonable, fair-minded and informed person would reasonably apprehend that the judge will not bring an impartial mind to bear on the case
  • The onus of establishing grounds for bias rests on the party seeking recusal, and disqualification is not presumed
  • A litigant has no right to object to a particular judicial officer merely because they believe he will decide against them; judicial officers must resist such pressure

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The Notice of Motion dated 1st July 2020 seeking the recusal of Hon. Mr. Justice C.G. Mbogo is dismissed
  2. 2.Costs of the application awarded against the Applicant

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Constitution of Kenya, 2010Articles 22, 50
  • Public Officer Ethics ActSection 5(1)
  • Judicial Code of Conduct and EthicsRules 5, 5(4), 5(5), 10(3), 13
  • Civil Procedure RulesSection 51(1) (as cited in the application)
  • Environment Management and Co-ordination Act (EMCA)Section 129(4) (repealed)

Cases cited (11)

  • Erdemann Properties Limited v National Environment Tribunal & 2 others
    Civil Application No. Nbi 105 of 2020
  • Kalpana H. Rawal v Judicial Service Commission & 2 others
    [2016] eKLR
  • Philip K. Tunoi & another v Judicial Service Commission & another
    [2016] eKLR
  • Republic v Firearms Licensing Board & another; Ex parte Jimi Wanjigi
    [2019] eKLR
  • Jasbir Singh Rai & 3 others v Tarlochan Singh Rai & 4 others
    [2013] eKLR
  • Kenya Hotel Properties Limited v Attorney General & 5 others
    [2018] eKLR
  • Republic v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 3 others Ex parte Wavinya Ndeti
    [2017] eKLR
  • Bernard Chege Mburu v Clement Kungu Waibara & 2 others
    [2011] eKLR
  • Tatu City Limited & 3 others v Stephen Jennings & 6 others
    [2015] eKLR
  • Attorney-General v Anyang' Nyong'o and others
    [2007] 1 EA 12 (EACJ)
  • The President of the Republic and others v South African Rugby Football Union and others
    1999 (7) BCLR 725 (CC)
Jurisdiction invoked
Articles 22 and 50 of the Constitution; Section 5(1) of the Public Officer Ethics Act; Rules 5, 10(3) and 13 of the Judicial Code of Conduct and Ethics

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "Erdemann Property Limited v National Environment Tribunal; London Distillers (K) Limited (Interested Party) [2021] KEELC 2089 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2021). Petition dated (ELC Petition, Makueni) — Notice of Motion dated 1st July 2020. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2021/2089/eng@2021-09-09

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.