Makicher General Contractors Limited v Communication Graphics Limited [2021] KEELC 1528 (KLR)
The bottom line
#A Nairobi court ordered a land seller to transfer property 19 years after the buyer paid in full, ruling the seller's counterclaim was invalid and time-barred.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Compliance with the sale agreement dated 1st August 2002
The Plaintiff complied with the terms of the sale agreement; the entire purchase price of Kshs 16,000,000 was paid and acknowledged by the Defendant, and any lateness was waived and estopped
The final tranche of Kshs 10,149,566 was released in February 2003 outside the completion date, but payment was contingent on the Defendant handing over completion documents. The Defendant acknowledged receipt and confirmed release of the balance to the vendor without protest, retaining the funds for years. The court held the Defendant waived any complaint as to lateness and is estopped under Section 120 of the Evidence Act from denying compliance, and the contract was beyond rescission by 2018.
Whether the Plaintiff obtained a refund of Kshs 2,000,000 from Commercial Carpets Limited
The Plaintiff did not obtain any refund; the alleged loan was a personal transaction of Dr. Linus Cheruyot with a separate legal entity
Transactions between corporate bodies cannot be conducted by parole; no written communication authorising a refund was produced. Commercial Carpets Ltd and Commercial Interiors Ltd are separate entities from the Defendant, and Dr. Cheruyot's personal loan cannot be attributed to the Plaintiff company. The court invoked the principle of separate corporate personality, so the Defendant cannot rely on these transactions to allege non-payment of the purchase price.
Validity and enforceability of the agreement dated 1st July 2015
The document was not validly executed by or on behalf of the Plaintiff company and is unenforceable
The document's preamble named an individual rather than the companies; it was not sealed; Charles Barchigei was not proven to be a director of the Plaintiff, and his power of attorney covered Dr. Cheruyot's personal matters only, was unregistered, and thus conferred no authority. The document also did not refer to the suit property and could not vary the 2002 agreement; extrinsic evidence cannot be used to contradict or vary a written document.
Breach of the sale agreement and entitlement to specific performance
The Defendant breached the agreement by failing to surrender completion documents; the Plaintiff is entitled to specific performance
Having received and appropriated the full purchase price, the Defendant was obliged to avail the completion documents but did not, with no indication of willingness to do so. Damages would not suffice because the Plaintiff had performed its part. Equity intervenes with specific performance where the contract is valid and the plaintiff has performed or shown readiness to perform.
Defendant's counterclaim
The counterclaim fails in its entirety
Specific performance of the 2015 document cannot issue as it is invalid and unenforceable; general damages are not recoverable for breach of contract; and the claim for vacant possession is time-barred under Section 7 of the Limitation of Actions Act, the Defendant's title having been extinguished after twelve years of the Plaintiff's possession, which was itself an actualisation of the agreement's intent.
Legal principles established
#- A party who receives and appropriates payment without protest, after the stipulated completion date, waives the issue of lateness and is estopped from challenging compliance
- A company has a distinct and separate legal personality from its shareholders and directors; only the company has capacity to enforce its legal rights
- Specific performance is based on the existence of a valid, enforceable contract and is granted where damages would be an inadequate remedy
- A claimant seeking specific performance must have performed their part of the bargain or show readiness and willingness to perform
- General damages are not recoverable for breach of contract
- An action to recover land may not be brought after twelve years from when the right of action accrued, after which title is extinguished
Court orders
#- 1.An order of specific performance compelling the Defendant to procure, execute and supply all documents necessary to transfer L.R No. 209/7008, Manyani Road East, Lavington, Nairobi to the Plaintiff as envisaged in the agreement for sale dated 1st August 2002, including the original grant, discharge of charge and KRA cancellation of charge
- 2.A permanent injunction restraining the Defendant, its agents or employees from interfering with the Plaintiff's quiet and peaceful possession and occupation of the suit property
- 3.The Defendant to execute all transfer instruments and handover all requisite approvals, clearance certificates, PIN certificates, certificate of incorporation and passport-size photographs of its directors within 21 days, and in default the Deputy Registrar of the Environment and Land Court to execute such documents
- 4.A declaration that the Plaintiff is entitled to ownership and/or occupation of the suit property, having resided thereon since 2002
- 5.The Defendant's counterclaim dismissed
- 6.The Plaintiff to have the costs of the suit as well as the counterclaim
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Original jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court over the suit property L.R No. 209/7008, Manyani Road East, Lavington, Nairobi
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Makicher General Contractors Limited v Communication Graphics Limited [2021] KEELC 1528 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2021). . Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2021/1528/eng@2021-10-14
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.