Skip to content
AI-generated case briefs sourced from Kenya Law · Not legal advice
AI-generated case brief
Case Brief · caselaw.co.ke
ELCDismissedNotice of Motion Application dated 1st October 2021· [2021] KEELC 801 (KLR)

George Boniface Mbugua v Mohammed Jawayd Iqbal [2021] KEELC 801 (KLR)

Environment and Land Court
25 November 2021
4,167 words in judgment
View original judgmentRead on Kenya Law Watch case
AI-assisted case brief
·~17 min to read original · ~4 min brief

The bottom line

#

Kenya's Environment and Land Court dismissed a bid to review a ruling, confirming that review applications cannot substitute for an appeal.

What this practically means

#

Executive summary

#
The Plaintiff, George Boniface Mbugua, moved the Environment and Land Court by Notice of Motion dated 1st October 2021 seeking review and setting aside of a Ruling delivered by Obaga J on 23rd September 2021, which had disallowed his request to adduce additional evidence (a valuation report and financial analyst report) in the pending assessment of mesne profits. The suit originated in a 1986 agreement for the purchase of L.R No.1/387 along Ngong Road, Nairobi. The High Court originally decreed specific performance in the Plaintiff's favour, but the Court of Appeal in Civil Appeal No. 242 of 2018, by judgment of 8th November 2019, overturned that decision and remitted the matter for assessment of rent/mesne profits/damages due to the Defendant only, taking into account the Kshs 1,500,000 the Plaintiff paid towards the abortive purchase. The Defendant opposed the review, contending the court lacked jurisdiction to deviate from the Court of Appeal's directions. The court, Angote J, framed one issue: whether the Plaintiff had made out a case warranting review under Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules. The court held there was no error apparent on the face of the record; at most the Plaintiff disputed the court's interpretation of the appellate directions, a matter for appeal. Although adopting the view that 'any other sufficient reason' need not be analogous to the statutory grounds, the court found the inflation/unjust-enrichment argument should have been raised before the Court of Appeal, which fixed the amount payable. The application was dismissed with costs on 25th November 2021.

Key legal issues

#
01

Whether the Ruling of 23rd September 2021 contains an error apparent on the face of the record

Holding

No error apparent; the Plaintiff was merely questioning the court's interpretation of the Court of Appeal directions, which is a matter for appeal.

Reasoning

The court held that its decision to decline additional evidence, even if wrong, was not a patent error staring one in the face. Whether the interpretation of the Court of Appeal judgment is right or wrong requires lengthy deliberations with possible divergent opinions, and a possible view cannot constitute an error apparent on the face of the record. Such dissatisfaction should have been pursued by appeal rather than by an application for review.

p. 4
02

Whether there is any other sufficient reason to warrant review

Holding

No; the Plaintiff's unjust-enrichment argument based on inflation of the Kshs 1,500,000 should have been canvassed at the Court of Appeal, which was categorical on the amount payable.

Reasoning

Although the court adopted the non-analogous view of 'sufficient reason', it found the Plaintiff's inflation/appreciation argument did not qualify. The Court of Appeal had expressly remitted the matter for assessment of rent/mesne profits/damages due to the Defendant only, taking into account the Kshs 1,500,000 paid, and not any other amount. Seeking to increase that sum through review would circumvent the appellate court's directions.

p. 5
03

Whether the court may allow additional evidence in the assessment of mesne profits

Holding

No; the court is bound by the Court of Appeal's direction that assessment be based on the evidence adduced at trial.

Reasoning

The Court of Appeal remitted the matter for assessment of rent/mesne profits/damages taking into account only the sum of Kshs 1,500,000 paid towards the abortive purchase. Allowing additional evidence such as valuation and financial analyst reports would go against the appellate court's orders. The onus of proving the counterclaim for mesne profits lies on the Defendant, on the evidence already on record.

p. 5

Legal principles established

#
  • A court's power to review its own judgment is not absolute and is confined to discovery of new and important matter, error apparent on the face of the record, or any other sufficient reason.
  • An error apparent on the face of the record must be a patent error requiring no elaborate argument; a mere erroneous decision or wrong view is a ground for appeal, not review.
  • The ground 'any other sufficient reason' for review need not be analogous to the other specified grounds.

Court orders

#
  1. 1.The Plaintiff's Application dated 1st October 2021 is dismissed with costs

Authorities

#

Legislation

  • Civil Procedure ActSection 80
  • Civil Procedure RulesOrder 45 Rule 1(1)
  • Code of Civil Procedure of IndiaOrder 47 Rule 1

Cases cited (15)

  • Benjoh Amalgamated Limited and another v Kenya Commercial Bank Limited
    [2014] eKLR
  • Kenya Trypanosomiasis Research Institute v Anthony Kabimba Gusinjilu (Suing for and on behalf of 112 Plaintiffs)
    [2019] eKLR
  • Muyodi vs. Industrial and Commercial Development Corporation & Another
    [2006] 1 EA 243
  • Nyamogo and Nyamogo v Kogo
    [2001] EA 174
  • Apollo Waswa Basude & 2 others (As administrators to the Estate of the late Sepiriya Rosiko) Vs Nsabwa Ham
    Civil Appeal No 288 of 2016
  • Nyamongo vs Nyamongo
  • Pancras T. Swai v Kenya Breweries Limited
    [2014] eKLR
  • Nasibwa Wakenya Moses vs. University of Nairobi & Another
    [2019] eKLR
  • Sadar Mohamed vs Charan Singh and Another
  • Evan Bwire vs Andrew Nginda
  • Assets Recovery Agency vs Charity Wangui Gethi & 3 others
    [2020] eKLR
  • Kuria v Shah
    [1990] KLR 316
  • Sarder Mohamed v. Charan Singh Nand Singh and Another
    (1959) EA 793
  • Shanzu Investments Limited v. Commissioner for Lands
    Civil Appeal No. 100 of 1993
  • Wangechi Kimata & Another vs Charan Singh
    C.A. No. 80 of 1985
Jurisdiction invoked
Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 Rule 1(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules

Key timeline

#

Practical implications

#

Frequently asked questions

#

Cite this brief

#

Cite this brief

Caselaw, "George Boniface Mbugua v Mohammed Jawayd Iqbal [2021] KEELC 801 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2021). Notice of Motion Application dated 1st October 2021. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2021/801/eng@2021-11-25

Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.