Lake Oil Limited v David Ndegwa Kamau [2021] KEELC 188 (KLR)
The bottom line
#A Kenyan landlord failed to evict a petrol station tenant because the termination notice gave 40 days instead of the 90 days required by the lease.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Whether the Plaintiff breached the lease terms as alleged
No breach was proved; the Defendant bore the burden of proof and led no evidence such as enforcement notices or complaints to the relevant authorities
The Defendant alleged breaches of specific lease clauses but produced no supporting evidence: no building plans or enforcement notices from Nairobi City County, no complaint or notice from EPRA, and the neighbour's demand letter about dumped tyres did not clearly refer to the Plaintiff. The court held that allegations must be proved by credible evidence under Sections 107, 108 and 112 of the Evidence Act, and the standard is on a balance of probabilities.
Whether the Notice to terminate dated 5th July 2020 was lawful
It was unlawful; clause 8.8 of the lease entitled the lessee to 90 days' notice to remedy any breach, but the notice allowed only about 40 days, expiring on 15th August 2020
Clause 8.8 required service of a written notice requiring the lessee to remedy the breach, and only if the lessee failed to comply within 90 days could the lessor repossess. The demand notice of 5th July 2020 fixed termination at 15th August 2020, far short of 90 days, and gave no window to remedy. The court held the Defendant could not unilaterally alter the executed contract by sidewind.
Whether the court can order immediate closure of the petrol/gas station
No; closure of a non-compliant petrol station is a statutory power of the Energy and Petroleum Regulatory Authority, with appeals to the Energy Tribunal, and this court lacks jurisdiction over such matters
The Energy Act, 2019 establishes EPRA to regulate and supervise the petroleum industry, including imposing sanctions such as closure for licensing defaults, and establishes the Energy Tribunal for appeals. The court held it must exercise deference and cannot delve into matters belonging to statutory bodies; a party must first exhaust statutory dispute resolution mechanisms.
Whether the Defendant is entitled to damages for breach of contract
No damages are payable: no particulars of special loss were pleaded, and general damages are not recoverable for breach of contract
The counterclaim did not specify whether special or general damages were sought and pleaded no particulars of special loss; special damages must be specifically pleaded and proved. As for general damages, the settled position is that they are not allowable in breach of contract claims, following Dharamshi v Karsan as restated in Kenya Tourist Development Corporation v Sundowner Lodge.
Legal principles established
#- The burden of proving breach of a contract lies on the party alleging the breach, who must avail credible and sufficient evidence
- A court cannot re-write a contract; parties are bound by the terms they executed
- Where a statute creates a specialised body with enforcement powers over a regulated activity, the court should defer to that body and its appellate tribunal
- Special damages must be specifically pleaded and particularly proved; general damages are not awardable for breach of contract
Court orders
#- 1.The Plaintiff's suit is allowed in terms of prayer I of the Plaint (permanent injunction restraining the Defendant from taking over, entering, trespassing or taking possession of L.R No. Nairobi/Block 118/875), subject to deletion of the words 'pending hearing and determination of the suit'
- 2.The Defendant's counterclaim is dismissed
- 3.The Plaintiff is awarded the costs of the suit as well as the counterclaim
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Original civil jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court over a lease dispute relating to L.R No. Nairobi/Block 118/875
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Lake Oil Limited v David Ndegwa Kamau [2021] KEELC 188 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2021). Not stated on the face of the judgment (Plaint dated 7th August 2020). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2021/188/eng@2021-12-16
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.