Republic v National Land Commission & 2 others; Raphael Musyoka Ndeti(Interested Party) Ex parte Dakawou Transporters Limited [2020] KEELC 3499 (KLR)
The bottom line
#Kenya's National Land Commission can revoke titles to land that was once public land, even if it is now privately registered, unless you prove you bought it innocently and paid for it.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Jurisdiction of the NLC over land now held as private land under leasehold tenure
The Commission had jurisdiction. Section 14(1) review covers dispositions of land that was initially public land, even where the title is now private leasehold; the Commission may direct revocation where the procedure of allocation was not followed.
The court adopted Black's Law Dictionary's definition of 'disposition' and relied on Ex-parte Holborn Properties and Compar Investments to hold that leasehold classification as private land does not bar review; what matters is the history of alienation from public land. The government being head lessor of the suit property confirmed the public-land origin and the Commission's mandate under Article 68(c)(v) and Section 14(1).
Whether the Commission's determination was illegal, unlawful or unreasonable, and the degree of merit review
The decision was proportional, reasonable, lawful and legal. Judicial review now incorporates proportionality under Section 7(2)(l) of the Fair Administrative Action Act, permitting some merit scrutiny, though the court cannot substitute its own decision.
Applying Suchan Investment, the court noted a shift towards merit consideration via proportionality, but confined itself to process. It found the Applicant was invited by public notices, was represented, filed a response and submitted documents. The Commission considered all relevant factors, including the absence of an approved PDP, a moratorium, and prior allocation to the Ndetis.
Whether the Applicant was a bona fide purchaser for value without notice under Section 14(7)
No. The Applicant failed to prove payment of value and discrepancies between the sale agreement (Kshs. 16,000,000) and the transfer (Kshs. 8,000,000) indicated bad faith.
Applying the Katende criteria as cited in Lawrence P. Mukiri Mungai, the court found no evidence of payment of the purchase price; the agreement was with the Applicant but the transfer went to Oil City Services Limited; and a diligent registry search would have revealed the defect. The claim to bona fide purchaser protection therefore failed.
Whether the Commission acted outside its five-year mandate under Section 14(1)
The mandate was properly exercised. The Act commenced on 2nd May, 2012 and the decision was rendered on 28th April, 2017, before expiry on about 1st May, 2017; the later gazettement did not offend the limitation.
The court distinguished the decision date from the gazettement date, holding the mandate is complete upon rendering the decision directing revocation. The gazette notice of 9th November, 2018 merely published the earlier decision, so the application based on lapse of mandate failed.
Legal principles established
#- The National Land Commission's mandate under Article 68(c)(v) of the Constitution and Section 14 of the National Land Commission Act extends to reviewing grants and dispositions of land that was initially public land even after it has been registered as private land.
- For the purposes of Section 14(1), the Commission's five-year mandate is satisfied if the decision is rendered within the five years; the date of gazettement is immaterial.
- A party seeking protection under Section 14(7) of the National Land Commission Act as a bona fide purchaser for value without notice must prove the Katende criteria, including payment of valuable consideration and good faith.
Court orders
#- 1.The Notice of Motion dated 26th November, 2018 is dismissed with costs
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Judicial review jurisdiction over the National Land Commission's exercise of its mandate under Article 68(c)(v) of the Constitution and Section 14 of the National Land Commission Act
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Republic v National Land Commission & 2 others; Raphael Musyoka Ndeti(Interested Party) Ex parte Dakawou Transporters Limited [2020] KEELC 3499 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2020). Judicial Review Notice of Motion dated 26th November, 2018. Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2020/3499/eng@2020-02-21
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.