Benson Mutiso Makau v Lydia Wambui Kimemia & another [2020] KEELC 2742 (KLR)
The bottom line
#When two people are sold the same plot, the buyer who got it first and is already using it wins.
What this practically means
#Executive summary
#Key legal issues
#Whether the parties' respective parcels are at the same location and who has the better title
Plot No. V 2322 claimed by the plaintiff falls within Plot No. P.8972 and Plot No. P.9439 owned by the 1st defendant, who acquired and occupied them first; her interest prevails
The court found the case to be one of double allocation typical of Embakasi Ranching's operations. The 1st defendant acquired her two plots in 1998, took possession in 2003, fenced them in 2004 and built on them, all before the plaintiff acquired Plot No. V 2322 in 2007. The surveyor PW2's oral evidence was found untrustworthy and prejudiced; he failed to produce the company's records. First in time plus possession carried the day.
Whether the defendants trespassed on the plaintiff's plot
No trespass by the defendants; the plaintiff's plot falls within the 1st defendant's land, of which she was already in possession
Because the disputed ground lay within the 1st defendant's two parcels, allocated to her earlier and in her possession at the material time, she and her agents had every right to be there. The plaintiff, having no right to enter without her permission or a court order, was himself the trespasser when he fenced off a portion on PW2's instructions.
Whether the plaintiff trespassed on the 1st defendant's parcels and what damages flow
The plaintiff trespassed by entering and fencing a portion without permission; only nominal/general damages of Kshs. 20,000/- were awarded as no loss was proved
Overwhelming evidence showed the property was in the 1st defendant's possession under valid certificates when the plaintiff purported to fence it. Although trespass was established, the 1st defendant proved no actual loss - the plaintiff's fence had been removed by the time she arrived - so the court awarded only Kshs. 20,000/- as general damages with interest.
Credibility of PW2, the Embakasi Ranching surveyor
PW2's evidence was rejected as untrustworthy and biased in favour of the plaintiff
PW2, though an employee and custodian of the company's records, gave oral evidence unbacked by documents and omitted from his statement that he had earlier shown the 1st defendant the very land and confirmed it to her on site visits. He also claimed he was forced by a former Chairman to confirm her allocation. His selective and prejudiced testimony was disbelieved.
Legal principles established
#- In a double allocation of land, the interest of the first allottee who is also in possession prevails over a later certificate of ownership
- Entry upon land in the possession of another without that person's permission or a court order constitutes trespass
- A party's failure to produce documents in his possession that would have supported his evidence draws an adverse inference
Court orders
#- 1.The plaintiff's suit is dismissed
- 2.It is declared that the 1st defendant is the lawful owner of Plot No. P.8972 and Plot No. P.9439
- 3.A permanent injunction is issued restraining the plaintiff by himself or through his agents from trespassing on, interfering with or altering the current boundaries of Plot No. P.8972 and Plot No. P.9439 belonging to the 1st defendant within Embakasi Ranching Company Limited's land in Ruai
- 4.The 1st defendant is awarded Kshs. 20,000/- as general damages for trespass together with interest at court rates from the date of judgment until payment in full
- 5.The 1st defendant shall have the costs of the suit and the counter-claim while the 2nd defendant shall have only the costs of the suit
- Jurisdiction invoked
- Original civil jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court over disputes relating to land (plot within L.R No. 105/7984, Ruai, Nairobi County)
Key timeline
#Practical implications
#Frequently asked questions
#Cite this brief
#Cite this brief
Caselaw, "Benson Mutiso Makau v Lydia Wambui Kimemia & another [2020] KEELC 2742 (KLR)", Case Analysis (2020). not stated in the judgment (suit filed on 8th May, 2013). Source: https://new.kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/keelc/2020/2742/eng@2020-05-05
Suggested citation format for research notes or client memos. Always verify the original judgment before relying on any point.